Live data from Hacker News

Issue links now open in a popup

github.com

51–60 of 138 posts

Re: Issue links now open in a popup

#51

This title is misleading: yes, a bunch of users didn't liked it. But of course there's UI research and likely A/B testing showed github that this might be preferable to the majority of users. Personally, I don't like it much. It sounds like leakage from AzDO design. Maybe a option to turn it off would be the best way out. Disclaimer: I work for msft, although I've no connection to github, ado or any other such tool.

I guarantee you it's not preferable to the majority of github users.

Re: Issue links now open in a popup

#52
post #7

It’s always been interesting to me that multi-million and even billion dollar tech companies don’t have perfect websites in terms of UX. Just last night I was helping my GF set up an ad for her job on LinkedIn. The UX was terrible. Like awful and basic things like save and exit were completely broken. Meanwhile LinkedIn makes what percentage of their revenue through ads? Same with google ads. It’s like these products…

It's more like no one cares about UX. People keep using the product and they keep printing. Why invest in a UX researcher or designer?

Re: Issue links now open in a popup

#53

It sounds like the root issue is that some people prefer opening new tabs while others prefer staying in the same browser window. I surfed the web when all links, even across websites always stayed in the same browser window, and I still prefer that. But I can understand that some people prefer opening new browser tabs instead. I think web browsers should revisit how they handle links with target=_blank/_top, and sho…

Idk, it almost seem a workaround for slow/broken go-back? If go-back is fast and state preserving, it's basically a fullscreen modal.

All(?) browser open links in a new tab when middle-clicked?

Re: Issue links now open in a popup

#54
post #7

It’s always been interesting to me that multi-million and even billion dollar tech companies don’t have perfect websites in terms of UX. Just last night I was helping my GF set up an ad for her job on LinkedIn. The UX was terrible. Like awful and basic things like save and exit were completely broken. Meanwhile LinkedIn makes what percentage of their revenue through ads? Same with google ads. It’s like these products…

I don't think there is such a thing as perfect UX and I'm not asking for it. I just want them to stop making it worse . Seriously tho, why isn't this something that a browser can do? Why can't I just split a tab and say all links from the left tab open in the right? Why not be able to scroll through history as a list of such panes like a smalltalk browser or file explorer on a mac? Maybe even a history tree, able to…

You might like Zen Browser

Re: Issue links now open in a popup

#55
post #31
post #8

Earlier quoted context omitted.

UX is really, really hard - and for some reason still not fully respected as a discipline.

Respect has to be earned, and I don't think anyone (within margin of error) with UX in their job title has earned it. Most of their work consists of shuffling design elements around for its own sake. Sometimes they strike gold (or at least silver or copper), but it never feels like that's done because they target a better design, rather they stumble upon it while making designs whose goal is to be different. You have…

Most people with UX in their job title these days aren't really UX designers. They're graphic designers that now have UX in their title because that is the fashion.

Re: Issue links now open in a popup

#56
post #7

It’s always been interesting to me that multi-million and even billion dollar tech companies don’t have perfect websites in terms of UX. Just last night I was helping my GF set up an ad for her job on LinkedIn. The UX was terrible. Like awful and basic things like save and exit were completely broken. Meanwhile LinkedIn makes what percentage of their revenue through ads? Same with google ads. It’s like these products…

As someone who has built a lot of greenfield UIs while also maintaining old ones (13+ years old SaaS), I recently set up LinkedIn ads and realized the UX is abysmal considering it’s something they’re actually trying to make money from. Maybe—just maybe-I’ve seen such poor UX in a free web app that lacks a maintenance budget. The only reasonable explanation I can come up with is they have a lot of silos within the ad portion of their platform, and each team works on their little corner and no one tries to work with it end to end. Since it’s LinkedIn, this is inexcusable. You go and try to make an ad campaign and then an ad set within it containing some ads, and then come back to it a week later and try to find all these entities you created. You may land on one and take a very long time gritting your teeth and praying for a way click around until you can find another one. What‘s the net drain on worldwide GDP caused by the time-wasting UX of this component of LinkedIn?!

Re: Issue links now open in a popup

#57
post #8
post #7

It’s always been interesting to me that multi-million and even billion dollar tech companies don’t have perfect websites in terms of UX. Just last night I was helping my GF set up an ad for her job on LinkedIn. The UX was terrible. Like awful and basic things like save and exit were completely broken. Meanwhile LinkedIn makes what percentage of their revenue through ads? Same with google ads. It’s like these products…

UX is really, really hard - and for some reason still not fully respected as a discipline.

It really isn’t that hard if you frame it correctly.

Computers are data processing machines with input and output. People today think they are vehicles to show design skill, and that’s not what they are. Focusing on design instead of utility is how you ruin any UI/UX anywhere.

Sites like GitHub do not exist for the designer. Sites like GitHub exist for software developers. Software developers should be calling the shots on that site, not designers.

Ralphlauren.com should be designed by designers. Dieterrams.com should be designed by designers. Etc.

Sites for designers should be designed by people who want to show off their designs.

Sites for data entry and manipulation should be designed for those who use that information. Creatives should stay away from sites like GitHub.

Re: Issue links now open in a popup

#58
post #23

There's browser extensions to bring back more user control on youtube, facebook, trello* and many others; looks like someone should make one for github soon. *the markdown enabler needs updating last I checked

There's already something like this for GitHub: https://github.com/refined-github/refined-github

Thanks for sharing - loads of great ideas there for the GitHub team.

Re: Issue links now open in a popup

#59
post #26

It's interesting to see that the UX issues that are annoying me when using Azure DevOps are finding their way into GitHub. In case they are truly chasing Azure DevOps level UX, I would recommend they implement an HTML editor for issues that, depending on whether the user has dark mode or light mode enabled, saves some CSS of the respective mode and makes it unreadable if read within the other mode.

They should also order the comments in order of recency top to bottom so you have to read the page in reverse.

Re: Issue links now open in a popup

#60
post #8
post #7

It’s always been interesting to me that multi-million and even billion dollar tech companies don’t have perfect websites in terms of UX. Just last night I was helping my GF set up an ad for her job on LinkedIn. The UX was terrible. Like awful and basic things like save and exit were completely broken. Meanwhile LinkedIn makes what percentage of their revenue through ads? Same with google ads. It’s like these products…

UX is really, really hard - and for some reason still not fully respected as a discipline.

I agree, and I think the metrification of UX hasn't helped here.

If you read the old Win32 interface design studies, and Raymond Chen's "Old New Thing, The: Practical Development Throughout the Evolution of Windows" you realize what people click isn't always what they want.

And old UX was ensuring that it was build in a way that what the user clicked was what they wanted.

Now? Since the MBAs came in the UX is another hostile piece of software, trying to trigger you into spending money.

Post reply on HN