Live data from Hacker News

Workspace Agents in ChatGPT

openai.com

51–60 of 74 posts

Re: Workspace Agents in ChatGPT

#51
post #16

I feel for the startups sweating each one of these frontier lab releases. How many more are thinking “am I next?”

Yeah, I’m happy I gave up, it’s just not possible to compete and the constant stress to try to keep up is not worth it. (I built https://nelly.is as a solo founder without funding)

The trick is niching down, this has always been the trick.

Re: Workspace Agents in ChatGPT

#52
post #23

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I really like Notion's UI. I wish they would focus only on that and let me access my Notion DB as .md files with Claude.

Take a look at Outline! I use it almost exactly like a cloud based Obsidian vault. And they have been very responsive for MCP feature requests

I don't think they have added a Obsidian Bases / Notion Database like feature yet, right? Saw some discussion of adding a NocoDB integration, but also didn't see that happen yet.

Re: Workspace Agents in ChatGPT

#53
i actually like the concept of workspace agent, because i am feeling some real pain here to run long-term project while retaining context for each instance of agent. but based on the demo it seems more like for cooperation instead of preserving long-term project state: decisions made, actions taken, approvals given, history of what each agent did and why. it is then just a more convenient chatgpt entry in group chat.

another thing: this is all on OpenAI's servers. Which is fine if that's what you want. But there's a real class of user — technical, working on actual production code, security-conscious — for whom "my workspace lives on my machine, in my git repo, under my version control, works for my other non-openai tools" is a hard requirement, not a preference.

Re: Workspace Agents in ChatGPT

#56

Without commenting on the product itself (I haven't tried it), the marketing copy around this release commits the same sins I have seen from Anthropic and Grok and all the rest of them. I'm so tired of seeing these companies trivializing other people's work! Nobody's job is "edit files" and "respond to messages"! People have jobs like "find and close leads" and "reconcile accounts" and "arrange student field trips" a…

[dead]

Re: Workspace Agents in ChatGPT

#57

From the announcement, I'm getting only a vague idea about what this is. It sounds like this Agent might run in some kind of sandbox with access to files? It would be nice if there were some documentation for the environment it runs in and what tools it has.

Yeah it looks like it's just a shared project. I thought we could already do this?

Re: Workspace Agents in ChatGPT

#60
Two problems:

- How you keep on top of what they are up to?

- How do they organize and coordinate?

I think this can only work based on a solid agent id system.

Shameless plug: I have been working on a solution for it, available at https://github.com/awebai/aweb and with a distributed, independently verifiable, and fully open id system at https://awid.ai

I wonder if this could be made to work with OpenAI's workspace agents.

Post reply on HN