Live data from Hacker News

Modern Board Games: and why you should play them (2022)

boardgamegeek.com

51–60 of 108 posts

Re: Modern Board Games: and why you should play them (2022)

#51
post #16

I recommend Wingspan for a wide range of gamers. If you don't have anyone to play with there is a very nice app you can play (steam, ios) with great music, AI, relaxing vibe.

I love the Wingspan soundtrack, it's available on Bandcamp! https://monstercouch.bandcamp.com/album/wingspan-original-vi...

Re: Modern Board Games: and why you should play them (2022)

#52

The peak board game experience to me is Blood on the Clocktower.

I just checked it out, what's the difference between it and non-board-games like werewolf and mafia?

It's very similar; they're all "social deduction" games.

Re: Modern Board Games: and why you should play them (2022)

#53
I tried a few, the only one that really meshed with me in terms of competitiveness, strategy, constant pivoting and wide decision space is Dune Imperium Uprising. My group started with wingspan which was fun but we ended up hating how much it became just pure chance.

Dune was basically the opposite you have an element of RNG from deckbuilding, you have multi-step planning and if someone else takes your move you have to recalibrate your plan, you can pull off crazy combos and hidden plans with intrigues.

I highly recommend Dune Imperium Uprising for engineers.

Would love if anyone can recommend any game of similar depth. We tried Arcs, root, and some others but couldn’t find anything similarly competitive and deep while not being one of those way too complicated games like twilight imperium or something.

Re: Modern Board Games: and why you should play them (2022)

#55

I'm thinking of breaking up with my local board game Meetup. The reason why is: everybody there has board game ADD! I've been coming for 2 years, but we never play the same game twice; someone always brings the Hot New Game of the moment. But I find that the first playthough is the least-fun one. That's the one where you're trying to remember what the grey cubes do, and whether they're worth victory points or not. An…

> victory points

TIL this is an established term and not a joke term invented by a certain YouTube personality.

Re: Modern Board Games: and why you should play them (2022)

#56
post #11

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The article is more about a certain style of "modern" games, which is an interesting strand but does not exhaust the category: classic games (chess, go, shogi, backgammon), card games (bridge, poker), TCGs (magic the gathering, hearthstone) often are as complex and sophisticated as any of those. If you're looking specifically for games in that style, Twilight Struggle has been studied extensively and there's signific…

Hmm i found 7 wonders and dominion to flatten out in strategy quite fast. Dominion requires to monitor cards that while helpful initially,can burden your hand in the end.

In support of Dominion: there are a million expansions that add new cards and mechanics.

Re: Modern Board Games: and why you should play them (2022)

#57
When I was a team lead I used to play board games as fun activity after releases.

I find it’s a great activity for people that aren’t that social. You get to participate in a group activity where your focus is on the game. Choosing the right game for the group is important though.

Re: Modern Board Games: and why you should play them (2022)

#58

Any particularly complex or sophisticated board games HN likes to play? Curious what kind of games appeal to the HN mindset

I think the most complex board game I've really played any amount of is Carcasonne (Not particularly complicated). Often, if I'm playing a board game, I prefer it to be on the simpler end, more of a relaxing thing. One memorable board gaming experience I had was playing Splendor (I believe) with my cousin, and it ended up being almost completely silent, just passing tokens around and the occasional "oh..." when anoth…

> Pit is also popular in my family when there's a gathering of us

We call Pit "The Yelling Game". For being over 100 years old, it's elegant, clever, and fun.

Re: Modern Board Games: and why you should play them (2022)

#59
post #31

We are living in a board game and card game Renaissance. For those outside of "the hobby", there are thousands of new titles being released every year. Some challenge the notion of what it even means to be a game. Even in the party game space, there is a lot of innovation. It doesn't matter what kind of game you like, there is one from the last 10 years that is your "perfect" game. If you hop on to BGG or the right D…

I’d argue we’re past the peak though.

These days far too many board games are designed to appeal on Kickstarter with needless plastic minis and content. All that time and effort could have gone to play testing and improving the game but instead you get 2kg of plastic that doesn’t improve the game in anyway, increasing costs, and day one expansions or bonus content that’s often mediocre.

For every truely innovative game out there, there’s many more that look great and have incredible table presence but are throughly mediocre rehashes of the something else and rely purely on hype or great art.

Now you see people backing KS or buying 2nd hand games specifically for scalping, and Kickstarters preying on people with FOMO.

Also you can no longer trust Board Game Geek ratings.

The good news is, the vast majority of what’s really good, is probably already out there and available new or 2nd hand for a fair price.

Post reply on HN