Live data from Hacker News

US plans to automatically register young men for military draft

bbc.com

51–60 of 65 posts

Re: US plans to automatically register young men for military draft

#51

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I never had problems with any of those.

You were probably registered when you got a drivers license.

The point remains that I never registered. So either registration doesn’t matter or some other automated process did it for me. Therefore the process should just be automated in a single uniform way to save the government money.

Re: US plans to automatically register young men for military draft

#52

Earlier quoted context omitted.

No biggie, you can always develop bonespurs!

> you can always develop bonespurs I've looked into it, and this ailment is weirdly linked to the wealth of your parents.

Ah, that's the Rich Man's Burden, it weighs heavily on the bone (spurs).

Re: US plans to automatically register young men for military draft

#53

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Now all that Social Media, Google account data, online banking info etc. comes home to roost. Unlike Vietnam, one can no longer hide from government in times of unrest. Perhaps that's the wake-up call privacy needs.

> Unlike Vietnam, one can no longer hide from government in times of unrest. That's true but you can leave for Canada or Europe.

For a total of 90 days in a rolling 180 day period in case of the Schengen area. That's a bit less than needed.

Re: US plans to automatically register young men for military draft

#54

Will trans men and women be automatically registered too? Since the US military has previously kicked out all trans people

Not sure about US but since another comment linked to an article about Germany, there you cannot avoid conscription by changing gender.

The fact that conscription is gender based should be challenged in the courts. Either there is equal society or not

Re: US plans to automatically register young men for military draft

#57
I'm genuinely perplexed as to why this story was flagged.

As multiple commenters have pointed out, this is actually not new(e.g you get registered when you get your driver's license).

I wonder why flagging brigade on HN has such a thin skin when it comes to anything even remotely critical of the current govt.

Re: US plans to automatically register young men for military draft

#58
post #50

Earlier quoted context omitted.

In fact, women tend to outdo men in extreme endurance competition. It’s part of the trade-off for a lower ceiling on absolute strength. But yes, in modern warfare there are as many jobs if not more that require precision or some level of intelligence as those that require brute strength. Even if fewer of them are right at the front line, they’re just as important. You don’t send a large percentage of women to the fro…

Not just endurance sports. Anecdotal evidence, but female rock climbers have been more skilled in my experience. Perhaps because the brute force escape hatch isn't as available.

Rock climbing is pretty weird. At the top level, it is clear male athletes have most advantages: height, and shoulder strength, that make routes designed for male very hard to compete on for most female athlete.

On the other hand, routes set for female athlete are also very hard for males to compete on. Some of them you can bruteforce (with strenght a la Janja, or with size), but some of them male joints just can't handle the rotations needed.

Still, a male athlete would do better on female route than a female athlete would on male routes imho (at the top level, at mine it just doesn't matter).

But when you're rock climbing in montains with people who have the same experience, yeah, women tends to do better. And even when you're the most experienced, women tends to get better faster especially when you're doing "multi-pitch climbing" (google translate on this, i hope that's right) for a few days in a row.

Re: US plans to automatically register young men for military draft

#59
post #33

Is this democratic?

Democratic means giving all citizens a say in government. What are you trying to convey with the word?

OK, wrong word. I meant if automatically registering young men for military service is something that can be done in a democratic society. It seems like you're making young men potentially go to war regardless of how they feel about it.

Seems something that is the mark of an authoritarian society.

Re: US plans to automatically register young men for military draft

#60
post #18
post #3

Weird we have this technology but not the technology for automatic voter registration, or automatic tax filing...

Draft registration is compulsory based on residency; registering someone in error has no consequences unless there is a draft, which seems unlikely (no draft since Vietnam, large differences in how the US carries out war since then). In the event of erroneous registration when there is an active draft, past procedure was to allow time to reply and object, including through court process, so an erroneous registration…

But none of those reasons are technical limitations. They are political.

The “system” knows who can vote, even if there might not be a unified system currently to automatically validate that.

Same with taxes. These things can be automatically reported at the time of purchase.

Post reply on HN