Live data from Hacker News

UK intelligence censored report on global warming and homeland security

theoryofchange1.substack.com

51–60 of 64 posts

Re: UK intelligence censored report on global warming and homeland security

#51
post #26

Here is the solution nobody is talking about: The population of the UK or Europe did not explode in the last hundred years. It did not even double. The population used to be more rural and relatively self sufficient in terms of food. There is actually enough land in Europe to feed everybody, especially considering the great progress we made scientifically. You can actually sustain yourself on a few hundred square met…

I think the fundamental problem is the conflict between climate, family and live-style vs corporate interest and economic growth. Ideally, we should want populations that are either not growing or slowly shrinking, but we can't have this because multi-national corporations don't want to invest in countries with a declining consumer base. We must therefore sustain population growth indefinitely. Similar humans would p…

Makes sense if you want to make money, and have money enough to not have to suffer the worst of it yourself. Of course, nobody voted for it, but those that promised not to do it and did it anyway were democratically elected, so only a fascist would take issue with it surely.

Re: UK intelligence censored report on global warming and homeland security

#52
post #38

The UK is consistently amongst the lowest household expenditure on food in the entire world. Only 3 countries in the world are self sufficient in food. If this "reasonable worst-case" scenario happens, surely the UK is one of the better placed to deal with it?

> The UK is consistently amongst the lowest household expenditure on food in the entire world.

How?

> Only 3 countries in the world are self sufficient in food.

Surely a small island nation is not one of them?

Re: UK intelligence censored report on global warming and homeland security

#53
post #9

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I don't think it's been possible to feed the UK domestically since before WW2. I note you put the word "social" in there; very little social housing is being built, it's mostly private. Agrivoltaics are also possible, but of course everyone would rather do the politics of emotions ("hate farmers") than discuss the issues. Such as how we grow enough electricity, too.

> I don't think it's been possible to feed the UK domestically since before WW2. Of course you can, I know people being almost self sustainable right now on very little land. It is hard, frugal but highly rewarding and we have evolved to do it since very recently. Energy and heating is a bit more complicated. We obviously cannot burn wood or coal like we use to because this is actually very damaging to the planet. So…

> Of course you can, I know people being almost self sustainable right now on very little land.

Please run the numbers for UK farmland divided by UK population.

Re: UK intelligence censored report on global warming and homeland security

#54
post #27

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Depends where they're coming from I guess. There's basically no where on Earth where people are as liberal as Europe. No liberal would want millions of people coming from Afghanistan, for example.

Presumably you mean No True Liberal.

Presumably they mean that acceptance of migration is a continuum and the numbers of climate refugees would push a large fraction of people self identifying as liberal to oppose it.

Re: UK intelligence censored report on global warming and homeland security

#55
post #33

Earlier quoted context omitted.

To his credit Clarkson has done more form farming with his show than countryfile or the archers has done in decades. He bought it as a tax break, but I’d leave not ire for “farmers” like the musician and vacuum cleaner salesman. Nothing caused me to laugh more at the “woe is the millionaire march” than seeing Lloyd Webber and his dog out on the march.

> vacuum cleaner salesman. Dyson? Sure - he seems performative (from afar, I'm antipodean to this BTW) with his industrialised strawberry wheels etc. > the musician Lost me .. I'm sure the UK has a few gumbooted millionaire class rockers / composers - I'm guessing that's a throw at the impresario of musical theatre with a life peerage who is rarely seen cutting hay. I'm not sure I'd class either of those as farmers (…

Andrew Lloyd Webber. Billionaire composer of musicals like cats and phantom. Also a farmer apparently, owning thousands of acres and befitting from the tax breaks and hope value.

They either employ people to farm the land (like Clarkson did I to 2019, and indeed stop does), or rent the land out for a tiny return on investment in the 1-2% range while avoiding the only tax that even attempts to fight against the aristocracy

Re: UK intelligence censored report on global warming and homeland security

#56
post #33

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> vacuum cleaner salesman. Dyson? Sure - he seems performative (from afar, I'm antipodean to this BTW) with his industrialised strawberry wheels etc. > the musician Lost me .. I'm sure the UK has a few gumbooted millionaire class rockers / composers - I'm guessing that's a throw at the impresario of musical theatre with a life peerage who is rarely seen cutting hay. I'm not sure I'd class either of those as farmers (…

Andrew Lloyd Webber. Billionaire composer of musicals like cats and phantom. Also a farmer apparently, owning thousands of acres and befitting from the tax breaks and hope value. They either employ people to farm the land (like Clarkson did I to 2019, and indeed stop does), or rent the land out for a tiny return on investment in the 1-2% range while avoiding the only tax that even attempts to fight against the aristo…

Sure, land owner .. not farmer, as the term is used here.

Re: UK intelligence censored report on global warming and homeland security

#57

Here is the solution nobody is talking about: The population of the UK or Europe did not explode in the last hundred years. It did not even double. The population used to be more rural and relatively self sufficient in terms of food. There is actually enough land in Europe to feed everybody, especially considering the great progress we made scientifically. You can actually sustain yourself on a few hundred square met…

> The great migration of the local population to the city to get a good factory or a bank job is over I believe. But the country side is still empty.

My major belief/bet is that young professionals that work in front of the computer all day will figure out that living in a very expensive city doesn’t make much sense and there are a ton of cheap rural houses in the beautiful countryside and we’ll have a reverse migration for young, educated white collars. Right now it’s just a trending topic for youtubers, but most people, especially Gen-Z existing in an economic limbo, have not caught on.

At least that’s my plan because it makes so much economic sense, I have had enough of city life and I am too old to care about urban amenities vs quality of life.

Re: UK intelligence censored report on global warming and homeland security

#59
post #38

The UK is consistently amongst the lowest household expenditure on food in the entire world. Only 3 countries in the world are self sufficient in food. If this "reasonable worst-case" scenario happens, surely the UK is one of the better placed to deal with it?

> The UK is consistently amongst the lowest household expenditure on food in the entire world. How? > Only 3 countries in the world are self sufficient in food. Surely a small island nation is not one of them?

The UK achieves this by having a diet relatively unchanged from that of Londoners during the Blitz

Re: UK intelligence censored report on global warming and homeland security

#60

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> The UK is consistently amongst the lowest household expenditure on food in the entire world. How? > Only 3 countries in the world are self sufficient in food. Surely a small island nation is not one of them?

The UK achieves this by having a diet relatively unchanged from that of Londoners during the Blitz

I don't think the UK does achieve it at all. Cut off all import lines and what would happen?
Post reply on HN