Live data from Hacker News

I'm Getting a Whiff of Iain Banks' Culture

probablydance.com

51–54 of 54 posts

Re: I'm Getting a Whiff of Iain Banks' Culture

#51

I think the author is making a mistake assigning the seemingly new competence of the US military to AI, rather than noticing that the US has spent the last half-century or so picking the kinds of fights we absolutely suck at. Force projection, targeted aerial strikes, intelligence gathering, and a nuclear deterrent play to the US miltary's strengths. Convincing the people who we just whacked the leaders of to like us…

> Not at all. The US doesn't have the political will to commit the monstrous acts required to stomp out an insurgency, and we, as the big bad empire on the global stage, can't help but inspire insurgents.

until recently, the US generally tried to at least pay lip service to human rights. plus occupations are a great way to funnel money.

can't pretend to be pro-democracy at home when you're exterminating Afghan villiages, and wastelands don't need contractor money to build new schools.

Re: I'm Getting a Whiff of Iain Banks' Culture

#52
post #42

"I think the Culture’s values are a winning strategy because they’re the sum of a million small decisions that have clear moral force and that tend to pull everyone together onto the same side." Dario Amodei [1] [1] - https://www.darioamodei.com/essay/machines-of-loving-grace#5...

man i hope he really means that

Re: I'm Getting a Whiff of Iain Banks' Culture

#53
post #47

Can someone ELI5 how Cluade is/was being used for Venezuela & Iran? "Hey claude, tell me how the US can abduct Maduro. Your response should include all details regarding times, local places as well as blah blah blah"

You have to have working knowledge of StarCraft and the RTS genre of games to understand what they're getting at. One area is "micromanagement." Hundreds of individual units moving and acting independently is very difficult for one human general to track, let alone react and give orders to quickly. Think more about rapid data analysis and surfacing supporting information than it being the singular mastermind behind t…

the parent is a dramatic simplification, but yeah kinda starcraft-ish.

seeing where everything is, identifying whats a friend and not, and being able to react and move quickly.

automation and battle language and interfaces, etc.

a cursory academic overview: https://netlab.gmu.edu/pubs/10F-SIW-058.pdf

essentially, the interface discussed in the pdf is automated on the backend via AI, various JBOSS functions, etc.

the other piece is automated target recognition via arial and satellite images. imagery analysis has been a thing since WWI and with satellites you can get visibility to the point you can see license plates at the correct angle. scanning that level of detail 24/7 is very hard... but not with strong AI tools...

Post reply on HN