Live data from Hacker News

Indefinite Book Club Hiatus

whatever.scalzi.com

51–52 of 52 posts

Re: Indefinite Book Club Hiatus

#51
post #40

Earlier quoted context omitted.

On that note I get the impression the whole publishing industry has an AI problem. I wrote a novel and started sending it out to agents recently. The number of agents who emphasise no-AI, or simply say that due to volume they won't reply... Then, as an aspiring author you rapidly start getting messages offering editor services, or book clubs (like this), or agent access, and it becomes clear those are AI and require…

Your book sounds really interesting! Hope you get it published

Thanks :)

Re: Indefinite Book Club Hiatus

#52

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I've seen these. They promise a book club with a wide audience, and then you need to pay for having your book present [or some other fee]. It's to take advantage of authors who want to get their book seen and read and bought. Book clubs used to be a good mechanism for word of mouth marketing.

On that note I get the impression the whole publishing industry has an AI problem. I wrote a novel and started sending it out to agents recently. The number of agents who emphasise no-AI, or simply say that due to volume they won't reply... Then, as an aspiring author you rapidly start getting messages offering editor services, or book clubs (like this), or agent access, and it becomes clear those are AI and require…

Slop is an issue, but you've also set yourself up in a difficult situation. The reality of the market is that publishers are interested in selling books, so they look for indications that your work might sell. If you haven't published in shorter formats (demonstrating skill in writing), you don't have an audience/social media presence, and you're offering something the majority of the customer base doesn't want (work produced with LLM assistance), that's a lot of hurdles to overcome even before you add the terrible odds in traditional submissions.
Post reply on HN