Live data from Hacker News

Verizon starts requiring 365 days of paid service before it will unlock phones

arstechnica.com

51–60 of 130 posts

Re: Verizon starts requiring 365 days of paid service before it will unlock phones

#51

Having lived in a lot of countries over the past couple of decades, I can say this is absolutely something Americans do completely wrong. Just buy your phone at full price. The "free" phones cost significantly more than a full price phone.

I suspect that many Americans would struggle to afford to pay for a phone outright. The vast majority live paycheck to paycheck and are already in record amounts of household debt.

Re: Verizon starts requiring 365 days of paid service before it will unlock phones

#53
post #5

Can a carrier ever surreptitiously lock an unlocked phone, or is it only on phones financed or purchased through the carrier? For example, if I bought an unlocked phone and attached it to my Verizon plan, could Verizon lock it?

Historically phone locking was done at the modem level via an NCK code - if a phone is supplied by a carrier the modem will come pre-locked and will only be unlocked upon entry of an NCK code which the carrier has the secret key to generate (hash(secret+imei)). With this system if the phone is not locked to begin with I am not aware of any way to toggle this mechanism remotely. With smartphones however, the game has…

I am not sure what the Android situation is in comparison.

If you have root, you can easily unlock the modem and keep it unlocked.

Re: Verizon starts requiring 365 days of paid service before it will unlock phones

#54

I still remember at the beginning of the mobile era, when there were tons of small "repair shops" that would unlock phones for a small fee. They are likely still around.

One of my oldest MSN friends (I think I have him on WhatsApp now) would unlock iPhones and later Androids for ages, his status on MSN was literally "I will unlock your phone" or something like that. Guy was from Belize, cool dude.

Re: Verizon starts requiring 365 days of paid service before it will unlock phones

#55

Having lived in a lot of countries over the past couple of decades, I can say this is absolutely something Americans do completely wrong. Just buy your phone at full price. The "free" phones cost significantly more than a full price phone.

I suspect that many Americans would struggle to afford to pay for a phone outright. The vast majority live paycheck to paycheck and are already in record amounts of household debt.

This is often repeated but false - it’s not the vast majority, nor even a majority.

https://www.cnbc.com/2024/11/19/bank-of-america-nearly-half-...

Re: Verizon starts requiring 365 days of paid service before it will unlock phones

#56

Earlier quoted context omitted.

it's a lot easier to pay smaller amounts over time than it is to pay a large lump sum, even if it is technically less after x number of years. Delayed gratification etc, but also sometimes folks need a phone and can't put off the purchase until they save up the upfront price. T

but also sometimes folks need a phone and can't put off the purchase until they save up the upfront price. Whatever happened to planning ahead? No wonder things are the way they are.

Things being the way they are is exactly the reason Americans can't afford to pay for a cell phone upfront. There's no amount of "planning ahead" that will change that when people are living paycheck to paycheck and having to go into debt to afford basic things like groceries.

Re: Verizon starts requiring 365 days of paid service before it will unlock phones

#57
post #20
post #14

Earlier quoted context omitted.

My monthly plan payment would not go down if I brought my own phone.

You sure about that? Look up Visible, Mint Mobile, Total Wireless, US Mobile, Tello... Same carrier networks, same quality of service. You can even pay a bit extra for prioritized data and other fancy features. You can get basic unlimited plans for $15-30 and premium plans in the $30-50 range vs $100+ at the big carriers. The only difference is that you aren't paying for your "free" phone.

And if you don’t use a lot of data, at least US Mobile has a by the gig plan. My family has three phones on it for a total $30 per month. Those months that we go over, it automatically charges $2 for each extra GB, with data pooled between the lines.

It is easy to switch between Verizon, AT&T, and T-Mobile as well. This was helpful for me as all three of the networks normally have one bar or less at my house. T-mobile WiFi calling works more reliably than Verizon.

Re: Verizon starts requiring 365 days of paid service before it will unlock phones

#58

Having lived in a lot of countries over the past couple of decades, I can say this is absolutely something Americans do completely wrong. Just buy your phone at full price. The "free" phones cost significantly more than a full price phone.

it's a lot easier to pay smaller amounts over time than it is to pay a large lump sum, even if it is technically less after x number of years. Delayed gratification etc, but also sometimes folks need a phone and can't put off the purchase until they save up the upfront price. T

You can get usable $150 phones to fulfill a need. Nobody needs a $1000 phone they can't afford.

Re: Verizon starts requiring 365 days of paid service before it will unlock phones

#59

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I suspect that many Americans would struggle to afford to pay for a phone outright. The vast majority live paycheck to paycheck and are already in record amounts of household debt.

This is often repeated but false - it’s not the vast majority, nor even a majority. https://www.cnbc.com/2024/11/19/bank-of-america-nearly-half-...

It just depends on who you ask and what they think living paycheck to paycheck means.

https://finance.yahoo.com/news/52-americans-live-paycheck-pa...

https://www.consumeraffairs.com/news/goldman-sachs-study-fin...

https://econofact.org/factbrief/is-there-a-consensus-that-a-...

No matter if it's "Nearly half" or 60%, things are clearly far from good for most Americans.

Re: Verizon starts requiring 365 days of paid service before it will unlock phones

#60
post #48

Earlier quoted context omitted.

In Norway several of the mobile phone telecom operators sell phones on down payment plans that cost nothing extra compared to buying it cash up front. It has been like this for several years and it’s great! You can pay a pretty low monthly down payment over a period of 36 month. As far as I’ve been able to tell, I don’t even have to enter into any binding contract for any phone plan to buy the phone this way. And eve…

Yes but you will generally pay more for your monthly plan in those cases vs. buying an unlocked phone at full price and a dirt-cheap SIM like Lebara.

You can still do that as well
Post reply on HN