Live data from Hacker News

That viral Reddit post about food delivery apps was an AI scam

theverge.com

51–55 of 55 posts

Re: That viral Reddit post about food delivery apps was an AI scam

#51

The Verge's article here is the least compelling. They report it with the same confidence and style as their original article when the Reddit post first made waves. I recommend reading https://www.platformer.news/fake-uber-eats-whisleblower-hoax... instead. It offers better reasoning, and an honest reflection about how close they were to getting taken in by the original Reddit post.

Yeah this article lays it out much better than the verge.

> “On the other hand, LLMs are weapons of mass fabrication,” said Alexios Mantzarlis, co-author of the Indicator, a newsletter about digital deception. “Fabulists can now bog down reporters with evidence credible enough that it warrants review at a scale not possible before. The time you spent engaging with this made up story is time you did not spend on real leads. I have no idea of the motive of the poster — my assumption is it was just a prank — but distracting and bogging down media with bogus leads is also a tactic of Russian influence operations (see Operation Overload).”

Crazy new times ahead.

Re: That viral Reddit post about food delivery apps was an AI scam

#52

> The Verge put the original 586-word Reddit post through several free online AI detectors, in addition to Gemini, ChatGPT, and Claude. The results were mixed: Copyleaks, GPTZero, Pangram, Gemini, and Claude all pegged it as likely AI-generated, but ZeroGPT and QuillBot both reported it as human-written. ChatGPT played it down the middle. Why does anyone, let alone a journalist, trust these? They are worse than usele…

+1,000,000. Journalist would be an inflated title given this reporters understanding of what LLMs can and can't do. I'd label them a blogger, commenter, or "enthusiast" given their understanding of the area they're covering.

Re: That viral Reddit post about food delivery apps was an AI scam

#53
post #31
post #17

Hacker News fakes posts later ( AKA the famous Dropbox post ) The best web archive is 22 hours in (.is is 2 hours with same top) and the top believes the post. Nihilist and a NPC failure to understand tech and industry[1] FTW https://web.archive.org/web/20260103035501/https://news.ycom ... [1] Both programming and business logic are rubbish in the post. A childhish view of the world from people who have never been th…

I can't make out what you're specifically saying here, but "fakes posts later" doesn't pattern-match in my mind to anything we actually do. All of things we actually do regarding re-upping posts, timestamps, and so on, I've explained many times (e.g. about timestamps here: https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&que... ), and we're always happy to answer good-faith questions. As for "the famous Dropb…

Read their other comments. Why do you allow this as a mod?

Re: That viral Reddit post about food delivery apps was an AI scam

#54
I think the telling part is that so many people believed it without questioning.

Like there's the oft-debunked "factoid" that says that the Windows Start Menu is written in react native... While the fact itself may be false, the fact that so many people readily believed it says a lot about the start menu.

If someone were to make a similar claim about something like HN was built in react then almost everyone here would instantly fact check.

Re: That viral Reddit post about food delivery apps was an AI scam

#55
post #31

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I can't make out what you're specifically saying here, but "fakes posts later" doesn't pattern-match in my mind to anything we actually do. All of things we actually do regarding re-upping posts, timestamps, and so on, I've explained many times (e.g. about timestamps here: https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&que... ), and we're always happy to answer good-faith questions. As for "the famous Dropb…

Read their other comments. Why do you allow this as a mod?

We don't. That account has been banned for months: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45545661.

If you're seeing their other comments, it must be because you have 'showdead' turned on in your profile. Anyone is welcome to turn that on and see all the comments that have been killed for various reasons, but it's important to understand that if you do, you're signing up to see the worst that the internet brings to HN.

As I mentioned at https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43538728, users sometimes forget that they turned 'showdead' on, then wonder why they're seeing such dreadful stuff in the comments. Could it be that that's what happened in this case?

Post reply on HN