Live data from Hacker News

Claude Code's DX is too good. And that's a problem

bharath.sh

51–60 of 97 posts

Re: Claude Code's DX is too good. And that's a problem

#51

> In a monorepo, just loading the project consumes ~20k tokens I don't work on a monorepo, and as an example, what I would consider a mid-size service in my mid-size company is 7M tokens. I can't but ask: do all people who are so enthusiastic about AI for coding only work on trivial projects?

You obviously don't have any idea how any of this actually works.

Re: Claude Code's DX is too good. And that's a problem

#52

> In a monorepo, just loading the project consumes ~20k tokens I don't work on a monorepo, and as an example, what I would consider a mid-size service in my mid-size company is 7M tokens. I can't but ask: do all people who are so enthusiastic about AI for coding only work on trivial projects?

should have been clearer here. by "loading the project" I meant the initial context claude builds like CLAUDE.md, directory structure, etc... not literally putting every line of code into context. 7M tokens would obviously not fit in a 200k window

Re: Claude Code's DX is too good. And that's a problem

#53

> In a monorepo, just loading the project consumes ~20k tokens I don't work on a monorepo, and as an example, what I would consider a mid-size service in my mid-size company is 7M tokens. I can't but ask: do all people who are so enthusiastic about AI for coding only work on trivial projects?

I dunno if I’d fall myself “enthusiastic” but I successfully use AI on a large production monorepo. The onus is on the user to break down the problem into llm-sized bites. How to do this effectively is a skill that takes time to develop. You’re not crazy: if you go in and ask it to do things in broad strokes it won’t work.

Re: Claude Code's DX is too good. And that's a problem

#54

Author here. I wrote this because everyone is talking about Claude Code right now and it's all over my timeline. Claude Code has this effect where you KNOW it's good but can't quite say WHY. So I spent the weekend digging into the DX decisions that make Claude Code delightful.

Do you have any sources you've found that document Claude Code's UI in detail? I'm really curious about what they've built, as a UI designer.

Anthropic has some docs at docs.anthropic.com but honestly most of what I learned came from just using it and poking around. the slash commands have help text built in. shrivu shankar has a good breakdown of the features too if you're looking for a more structured overview

Re: Claude Code's DX is too good. And that's a problem

#55
post #13

I've not used Claude Claude yet, but why would it be bad if it gains features that people use? Did people ever complain about Photoshop to have too many features demanding some cognitive load? Excel? Practically every IDE out there? There is a reason people use those tools instead of the plain text editor or paint. It's for power users and people will become power users of AI as well. Some will forever stick to chatg…

good question. the difference with AI tools is the interface isn't stable in the same way photoshop or excel is. with traditional software you learn it once and muscle memory carries you. with LLM tools the model itself changes, the optimal prompting style shifts, features interact with model behavior in unpredictable ways. so the cognitive load compounds differently. not saying features are bad, just that the tradeoffs are different

Re: Claude Code's DX is too good. And that's a problem

#56

Earlier quoted context omitted.

How much AI did you use to write up this article? It tripped up my "fake AI-written article" detector a few times despite being interesting enough to read to the end

used claude to polish the draft and tighten sentences. the thinking, analysis, and examples are all mine and based on personal experiences. spent the weekend reflecting on my past experiences with claude code and actually digging into why claude code feels the way it does. curious to know what tripped your detector.

Lots of things - typical llm em-dash situations although using dash. Lists of 3s after a colon where the 3 items aren't great. Short sentences for "impact" that sounds kind of like a high school essay i.e. "God level engineer...Zero ego."

I cannot at all understand writing an essay and then having an llm "tighten up the sentences" which instead just makes it sound like slop generated from a list of bullets

Re: Claude Code's DX is too good. And that's a problem

#58
post #17

Earlier quoted context omitted.

“Here’s the thing” “The best part?”

"It's not just X, it's Y" I find it really hard to read articles that use AI slop aphorisms. Please use your own words, it matters.

What if I no good in English?

Jokes aside, my English is passable and I'm fine with it when writing comments but I'm very aware that some of it doesn't sound native due to me, well, not being native speaker.

I use AI to make it sound more fluent when writing for my blog.

Re: Claude Code's DX is too good. And that's a problem

#59
post #42

> With Opus 4.5, Claude Code feels like having a god-level engineer beside you. Opinionated but friendly. Zero ego. Who keeps forgetting variable names and function calling conventions it used 4 seconds ago while using 136 GBs of ram for the cli causing you to frequently force quit the whole terminal. Its not even human level.

I've been running claude code on a 13 year old potato and it's never used 136GB of RAM - possibly because I only have 8GB.

Its vram or something makes the OS completely busy even I have only 32 gb ram. task manager shows 100+ gbs forcing to terminate

Re: Claude Code's DX is too good. And that's a problem

#60
I feel the same way about Junie.

I have an "image sorter" that sucks in images from image galleries into tagging system with semantic web capabilities "Character:Mona -> Copyright:Genshin_Impact" and ML capabilities (it learns to tag the same way you do)

Gen 1 of it was cued by a bookmarklet to have a webcrawler pull the gallery HTML and the images. I started having Cloudflare problems so Gen 2 worked by saving complete pages and importing the directories, that had problems so I was looking at a Gen 3 using a bookmarklet to fetch and POST the images out of the browser into the server so I tell Junie my plan and it tells me I'll have CORS trouble and "Would you consider making a browser extension?"

Well I had considered that but was intimidated at the prospect, figured I'd probably have to carve out an uninterrupted weekend to study browser extensions, kick my son out of the house to go busk with his guitar instead of playing upstairs (the emotional/social bit is important) and even then have a high chance of not really getting it done and then end up taking another month to get an uninterrupted weekend. I told Junie "I've got no idea how you do that, don't you need a build system, don't you need to sign it?" and it said "No, you can just make the manifest file and a JS file and do a temporary install" so I say "make it so" and in 20 minutes I have the browser extension.

It still isn't working end-to-end, but I'm now debugging it and ought to be able to get it working in a weekend with interruptions even if I didn't get any more AI help.

Post reply on HN