Live data from Hacker News

The Tesla Model Y Just Scored the Worst Reliability Rating in a Decade

autoblog.com

51–60 of 70 posts

Re: The Tesla Model Y Just Scored the Worst Reliability Rating in a Decade

#51

Had my Model Y for 4 years with no issue! Funny enough, my 2007 BMW had so many issues and cost so much to maintain i used to call it a “wallet burning machine”

So your 19 year old car has more trouble than your 4 year old car? Weird.

I had the car for about 5 years since 2007 - didn't say I had it for 19 years :)

Re: The Tesla Model Y Just Scored the Worst Reliability Rating in a Decade

#53

[Bought cheapest Tesla Model 3 Nov 2022.] [Before that - owner of 2 consecutive Priuses] - before that 2 caravans 2 jeeps etc (I am 60+yrs old) I have the answer to all these questions :-) Its very simple. I was about to answer "me too - i have no clue why the germans say that" (to all the (real) tesla owners here that explain that their car was by far the most reliable car they ever drove.. But then I forced my mind…

I have a Model Y from September 2022 (made in China). Aside from there being white paint on the inside passenger door on delivery (which they fixed the next day), I haven't had an issue since getting it.

The first service was a couple of months ago where they:

- Changed the HVAC filter

- Changed the HEPA and carbon filter

- Checked the brakes, which were fine.

Aside from that, I've put on new windscreen wiper blades and a new set of tires.

Re: The Tesla Model Y Just Scored the Worst Reliability Rating in a Decade

#55
Regardless of the accuracy of this particular report, the general trend seems to be that Teslas are not improving in reliability, fit, finish, or worst of all, availability of spare parts as time progresses. This is now, what, a 15 year old company?

My biased opinion is that it won't get better in the future, because Tesla has ceased to be a company that aspirational people will work at, and the CEO isn't even interested in being CEO of a car company.

I hope that Chinese EV makers gain access to the US market directly or indirectly, and are able to globally diversify. It's the only way we'll really get the EV revolution and the diversity of models and form factors.

We'll certainly never get it with Tesla. They are years behind in battery tech, they basically make two cars.

If Tesla had a real CEO, they wouldn't just have 10 models of cars, they'd have multiple marques, true luxury cars, entry level cars, probably would have acquired other struggling automakers for production capacity, market access, existing designs to adapt, would have had companies pushing PHEVs with their motors, battery packaging, and battery management.

Instead, they make two cars, and still have a CEO that did perhaps the single dumbest public gaff in the history of corporations with his public nazi salutes and AfD dogwhistling.

Re: The Tesla Model Y Just Scored the Worst Reliability Rating in a Decade

#59
Tesla has its problems (between 2019 and 2024 the auto headlights and auto wipers were borderline unusable, now they are merely tolerable, and autopilot is a whole story on it's own), but maintenance is not one of Tesla's issues.

Useable, human-readable errors in the app/touch screen (the car self diagnosed it's 12V battery problem and told me to call a tech) and mobile service is just an awesome experience.

Re: The Tesla Model Y Just Scored the Worst Reliability Rating in a Decade

#60
post #59

Tesla has its problems (between 2019 and 2024 the auto headlights and auto wipers were borderline unusable, now they are merely tolerable, and autopilot is a whole story on it's own), but maintenance is not one of Tesla's issues. Useable, human-readable errors in the app/touch screen (the car self diagnosed it's 12V battery problem and told me to call a tech) and mobile service is just an awesome experience.

Except if a car was reliable it shouldn’t have errors at least until at least being 10 years old (the 12V battery is an exception because it has a smaller lifespan than the car). I never had a check engine light on my previous car during 10 years of ownership, I’m worried about consumers getting used to a new normal of low quality.
Post reply on HN