Live data from Hacker News

The most male and female reasons to end up hospital

leobenedictus.substack.com

51–60 of 82 posts

Re: The most male and female reasons to end up hospital

#51

Men, asymptotic to 100% factors, women absolute 100% factors. Wondering if this is point author is trying to make?

The author actually addresses that - he hadn't even considered that pregnancy related issues would top the list.

I think this was just a fun exercise for a curious mind. I don't think it needs to have a point - it's not an essay.

Re: The most male and female reasons to end up hospital

#53
post #46

Some of these categories are awfully vague. "Non-treatment procedures"??

I interpreted that as "a procedure that does not treat a medical condition". So, possibly various non-doctor-ordered weight-loss-related procedures, cosmetic surgery, etc.

Re: The most male and female reasons to end up hospital

#56
post #41
post #3

So to summarize... Men, stop riding motorcycles Women, stop having kids That last one might have some detrimental effects long term though. So while men are taking risks, women take one for the team

The pregnancy numbers are a policy and not related to accidents. It would be similar to say that children at age 3, 5 and 12 months are much more likely to end up in the hospital than other age groups, since those are the ages when they get vaccinations. As with all statistics, there is some apple to oranges comparisons and some contexts that get lost.

Surely "admissions" does not include scheduled doctor's appointments?

Re: The most male and female reasons to end up hospital

#57
post #3

So to summarize... Men, stop riding motorcycles Women, stop having kids That last one might have some detrimental effects long term though. So while men are taking risks, women take one for the team

What a ridiculously sexist thing to even dare say out loud. The most male-dominated category is "fall from scaffolding." Men aren't up there for fun. They built the roof that shelters you and your family when it storms.

[deleted]

Re: The most male and female reasons to end up hospital

#59

Who on earth are those 1.7% men who go for "obstetric and gynaecological devices"? Are they accompanying their wives, end up fainting during the procedures, hit their heads and have to be patched up?

Babies. 8% of the patients under that category are Age 0

Edit: the full billing code is "Obstetric and gynaecological devices associated with adverse incidents" Billing code Y76 "describes the circumstance causing an injury, not the nature of the injury."

So injuring a baby during delivery with forceps would result in this code.

Re: The most male and female reasons to end up hospital

#60
post #48
post #32

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Aren’t we being a little sensitive? The OP didn’t say all of the reasons for male related injuries were needless, but if you look at the list, it’s dominated by activities that are inherently voluntary and risky.

aren't you being a little naive by calling dangerous activities men have to take to survive "inherently voluntary"? go to a 3° world country or works as an immigrant somewhere rich to check your options. transportation included. it's easy to say one shouldn't use a cheap motorcycle and go for the one way sardine packed 2 hours bus ride across the city to reach work, everyday

Only 3 out of 18 reasons on that list are work-related, 2 maybe can be work related (lawnmowing and powered tools/household machinery?). I think cycling accidents (5 positions on the list) are in part normal cycling (like when riding to work) without rider's fault, and in a larger part taking unnecessary risks while riding, or riding for sport. And I'd guess motorcycle accidents (4 on the list) are mostly taking risks and riding too fast. 3 reasons are "assault". And that leaves only 1 reason from the list, sports equipment.

So out of 18 reasons on the list, only a small part is "activities men have to take to survive", but many of the others aren't "inherently voluntary and risky" or cannot be blamed on the hospitalized person. The list is too short to be really interesting, when half of that list is the same thing with small variations (cycling/motorcycling), and the same for women (mostly pregnancy).

Post reply on HN