Live data from Hacker News

Dark Mode Sucks

tomechangosubanana.com

51–60 of 172 posts

Re: Dark Mode Sucks

#51

True. Use dark mode or don’t, but stop going on about it.

You often don't have a choice. Not without being forced to tinker around with your browser in ways that aren't readily accessible to many/most users. What us dark-mode haters are really asking for is a simple option to click.

I've never seen a browser force dark mode on you as they all seem to default to light mode. Same with the OS.

It's also easily configured in Firefox.

Re: Dark Mode Sucks

#52
There’s a significant lack of self-awareness necessary to criticize a group of people for using hyperbolic language and then rebut them with unsupported claims about “eyesight-damaging practices”.

Re: Dark Mode Sucks

#53
This post is a self-described "rant" which doesn't contemplate why some people prefer dark mode (I prefer light mode myself), but let's make something constructive out of it:

Please consider the comfort of your users: sufficient contrast, sufficient text size, and when feasible, a choice of dark mode or light mode.

Re: Dark Mode Sucks

#55
I've been convinced by my team that unified light mode is a good idea.

There's always a website, a person screensharing, a shared screenshot or something else that is light, and it WILL bother you if everything else is set to dark.

A dark thing in otherwise light settings doesn't produce the same issue, therefore adapting your settings for light work is more protective.

My main issue has been finding good light color schemes, particularly for neovim. Most have awful ideas like light yellow colors over light background, that I suspect come from just porting the dark mode to a light background as an afterthought. All of the themes I use have a few adjustments in my config.

Re: Dark Mode Sucks

#57
post #13

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> Dark mode should be reserved for after sunset and before sunrise. Isn’t that already how it works in all major operating systems?

No, it’s only configurable. And many people like myself leave it dark mode permanently unless in a bright place. I think the debate comes down to how bright you keep your environment. OP likes bright overhead lighting and confuses that preference for the superiority of a preference downstream of it. Yawn. I’d rather look at a bright 27” screen in dark mode where I see full color fidelity than dim the screen so that b…

It’s definitely not only configurable. In macOS I have it set to change according to time of day.

Re: Dark Mode Sucks

#58
I view dark mode as basically an accessibility tool. Provide the option of light/dark mode to your users so they can choose what works best for them. I prefer dark mode for most things, but what I’ve actually found is that I just don’t like pure white backgrounds with pure black text. It’s just that a lot of light modes are exactly that.

Re: Dark Mode Sucks

#59
I have no ambiant lighting. I have my window opened or the CO2 level gets bad. If I get lights, all the fucking insect existing in the forest will come in my room. Or I can get a fresh breeze while being on my PC in the evening.

With Dark Mode.

Re: Dark Mode Sucks

#60
This is the privileged majority punching down at minority, not unlike an abled person whining about the existence of accessibility options, or a native-born American complaining about government forms also having a Spanish section after the English section.

There's a reason that extensions like Dark Mode¹ have 10,000,000+ installs while no "Light Mode" extensions can even exist as far as I can tell: more or less the entire internet is already light-mode by default, with no option even provided by webmasters for dark mode for those who want it on a vast majority of websites.

What I can't comprehend is why the people who already have light mode as the default across the entire internet can't be content letting people with a preference for dark mode even exist without aggressively trying to erase the preferences of people who don't feel the exact same way as themselves.

Further, for anyone using OLED panels, which is a non-insignificant portion, black backgrounds reduce power draw and therefore global carbon emissions. Light backgrounds literally accelerate climate change, however marginally.

¹https://darkreader.org/

Post reply on HN