Live data from Hacker News

In a U.S. First, New Mexico Opens Doors to Free Child Care for All

wsj.com

51–60 of 540 posts

Re: In a U.S. First, New Mexico Opens Doors to Free Child Care for All

#51
post #35

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Yeah, it turns out that things like free health care, adequate food, good schools, and all that other socialist mumbo jumbo is actually good for productivity and the economy, too.

Totally agree. However, this only works in a high trust society, which we no longer have.

While in a low trust society, which you obviously already have, people are most productive when they're at perpetual risk of starvation.

Re: In a U.S. First, New Mexico Opens Doors to Free Child Care for All

#53
post #49

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Our politicians are unpopular because they do nothing to help us, and when they explicitly help us it's framed as lazy poor people looking for handouts. It makes no sense.

Maybe people should stop voting for the party that does that then. And for politicians that do that then.

It turns out that the promise to hurt other people more is a winning strategy.

Re: In a U.S. First, New Mexico Opens Doors to Free Child Care for All

#54
post #34

This is one of my pet peeves. If you believe in the welfare state concept, you should never refer to anything that’s subsidized as “free.” It’s a recipe for disaster. As a European who was uprooted and settled in the US, I’ve become painfully aware of how little we Europeans comprehend the workings of the economy. I believe this is partly due to the propaganda surrounding the welfare state as “free.” Of course, nothi…

Looking at USA right now, I just do not see how is that superior.

Re: In a U.S. First, New Mexico Opens Doors to Free Child Care for All

#55

What if a federal law is passed to make this illegal?

Ignore the law and tie it up in court until regime change? Something is only real or of concern if there are consequences. Words and opinions without force backing them are just words and opinions.

Re: In a U.S. First, New Mexico Opens Doors to Free Child Care for All

#56
post #35

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It was done so mothers could work building tanks and airplanes, not out of any concern for the children.

Yeah, it turns out that things like free health care, adequate food, good schools, and all that other socialist mumbo jumbo is actually good for productivity and the economy, too.

Have you seen comparisons between American and Canadian productivity? It’s definitely more complicated than just socialist leaning government programs make the country more productive.

Re: In a U.S. First, New Mexico Opens Doors to Free Child Care for All

#57
post #37

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Might as well complain about how we get free roads and fire services.

No one has accused roads and fire services of being free.

This is a good example, because a "freeway" is free at point of use, but obviously understood to not be free of construction and maintenance cost. It is called "freeway" because "free-to-drive-on highway" would be too wordy.

Re: In a U.S. First, New Mexico Opens Doors to Free Child Care for All

#58

Given the negative world wide trend with birthrates, this should be a priority with every developed country even if it eventually comes at the expense of elderly socialized healthcare.

We would be even better off subsidizing parents staying home with their own children. Unfortunately most subsidies have proven ineffective at nudging up birth rates.

Re: In a U.S. First, New Mexico Opens Doors to Free Child Care for All

#59

Medicare should cover children. Then we'd be covering children and the elderly. I think that seems fair--children deserve healthcare (just like education) as a fundamental right. It shouldn't be dependent on their parents.

It should cover everyone. No body goes to the doctor because they want to. I'll dare say it would be a net positive to even expand this to the undocumented. Many of them have dependents, it's not going to be great if your dad can't afford his insulin and is thus unable to work to provide for you. This includes a large percentage of our farm workers who are literally getting sprayed with pesticides all day. That's ano…

Expanding to undocumented providers is probably ripe for abuse. Although perhaps abusable either way.

What stops someone from saying “I’m an undocumented provider with 500 kids. Pay me 500 x AMOUNT”.

Public schools have residence and identity requirements. What’s an undocumented childcare provider going to have?

Re: In a U.S. First, New Mexico Opens Doors to Free Child Care for All

#60
post #7

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Land value tax is interesting because it encourages/forces more efficient use but you can do a lot more by cutting demand through limiting immigration and financialization opportunities.

I'm not sure why people don't immediately get serfdom vibes whenever they mention a land tax.

Probably because most of us are already unlanded serfs, except we also get vibes now. Yay, 1000 years of progress!
Post reply on HN