Live data from Hacker News

What happens to college towns after peak 18-year-old?

theargumentmag.com

51–60 of 63 posts

Re: What happens to college towns after peak 18-year-old?

#51
post #40

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I would expect a great school to be appealing to potential students, and therefore attract a lot of them. I would also expect a great school to have high academic standards that not all applicants meet.

It's a good thing you told us all that otherwise we wouldn't know which schools were "good" & which ones were "bad".

I would say its the applicants who seem to know which ones are good.

Re: What happens to college towns after peak 18-year-old?

#52
post #49
post #26

Seems like all the developed countries face the same issue - people there feel insecure and are scared to make important decisions, like they choose to have a dog instead of a family/child. What puzzles me is why all these countries actively do nothing about it.

Deciding whether or not to have children IS the important decision, it’s not a given that everybody wants children. We’re not “afraid”, fucking lol

Personal preference is one thing, statistics is the other. Spain for example has twice as much dogs as children. I guess it’s just a very pet loving nation. Nothing to do with the economy.

Re: What happens to college towns after peak 18-year-old?

#53
How many (public and private) colleges does the United States even need? 100, maybe? 50? 25? I think too many people have been going to college over the past, oh, 40 years or so, and part of that is because we have so many freaking colleges and universities. We don't need so many. There are so many jobs out there that do not require a degree, and even more that should not require a degree.

Re: What happens to college towns after peak 18-year-old?

#55
post #5

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Is there any profession where they aren't focused on staying employed?

You mean, is there any state funded system in which the primary drive of the system is to elrotect and expand itself, even at the expense of providing the good ir service for which it was created? History says no...

> You mean, is there any state funded system in which the primary drive of the system is to elrotect and expand itself, even at the expense of providing the good ir service for which it was created?

> History says no...

Aside from the obvious typos, I think that there is a crucial 'not' missing in the first sentence.

Also, why single out state funded systems? I don't believe that private enterprises have been a great model for provision of goods or services over self enrichment. (I now see that stouset said the same hours ago: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45546268.)

Re: What happens to college towns after peak 18-year-old?

#56
post #32

Earlier quoted context omitted.

This only works for exclusive, high prestige schools. Not many rich foreigners are going to pay full freight to send their kids to Western Kentucky University.

America itself and the opportunity to get your foot in the door with a student visa is the prestige factor for many students - the prestige of the university is secondary. That allows a lit of third tier universities to fill their master's programs with international students

Those days are over with the current administration.

Re: What happens to college towns after peak 18-year-old?

#57
post #32

Earlier quoted context omitted.

America itself and the opportunity to get your foot in the door with a student visa is the prestige factor for many students - the prestige of the university is secondary. That allows a lit of third tier universities to fill their master's programs with international students

Those days are over with the current administration.

[deleted]

Re: What happens to college towns after peak 18-year-old?

#58
post #32

Earlier quoted context omitted.

America itself and the opportunity to get your foot in the door with a student visa is the prestige factor for many students - the prestige of the university is secondary. That allows a lit of third tier universities to fill their master's programs with international students

Those days are over with the current administration.

Not to worry, China will pick up the torch. They just came up with a new H1B style visa.

https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/cvg4eeerzrwo

Re: What happens to college towns after peak 18-year-old?

#59

> But here’s the most telling data point from the school’s National Student Clearinghouse data: Over 60% of WKU-admitted applicants who don’t attend WKY don’t enroll anywhere. Not at a competitor, not at a community college — nowhere. Colleges are still competing with one another, but increasingly, they’re competing with the labor market itself. Labor shortages are leading to college credentials not being needed. Thi…

And the best part is that even when the labor shortage ends, the myth that the credential was ever necessary is permanently broken.

Lol fat chance. Credentials are necessary for advanced civilization. They exist to facilitate the cooperation of strangers. Do you want to deal with uncredentialed doctors, lawyers, engineers, teachers, finance managers, etc.? It is a quite idiotic that you need credentials to be a plumber but not a software engineer. Thankfully there is a strong preference for credentials. But the ridiculous calls for no credentials at all (led by those who don't have them) echo throughout forums like this on a regular basis.

Re: What happens to college towns after peak 18-year-old?

#60
post #42

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Plumbers charge like 200/hr if you get to the point where you work for yourself that seems pretty good?

Until you slip a disc around C6, or your back or knees give out. While "dirty hands == clean money", the problem is that it often ends in sacrifice in health and/or body that leads to involuntary early retirement. My dad had an A/C and electrical automotive specialty shop until 1985 when that took him out in his mid 30's. He also had Agent Orange exposure in the military and exposure to various carcinogens with a cul…

I think your dad's experience is in the minority. You could usually do that kind of work until at least your 50s. What people in his position often do is take office jobs in adjacent fields. For example, if you were a mechanic but can't work that anymore, you could work in customer service or sales since you know something about the business. If you really stick it out till your 40s and beyond, management or entrepreneurship might be more appropriate. But that isn't for everyone.
Post reply on HN