Live data from Hacker News

Facebook and Instagram to offer ad-free service in UK for up to £3.99 a month

theguardian.com

51–54 of 54 posts

Re: Facebook and Instagram to offer ad-free service in UK for up to £3.99 a month

#51
post #40

Earlier quoted context omitted.

>Advertising can be privacy-respecting Not the effective kind.

The entire previous history of humanity we only had non-targeted ads in newspapers, on billboards, and on TV and radio, and everyone was ok with that. But suddenly, on the internet, it's somehow "not possible" to have advertising that isn't personalized or even dynamic at all. How so?

Whilst I broadly agree, ads have been targeted to location for a long time. Newspapers and TV would have geographical editions so you don't advertise say your theatre production to people who are too far away to care. With billboards or earlier fliers, you did the same.

Re: Facebook and Instagram to offer ad-free service in UK for up to £3.99 a month

#52
post #51
post #40

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The entire previous history of humanity we only had non-targeted ads in newspapers, on billboards, and on TV and radio, and everyone was ok with that. But suddenly, on the internet, it's somehow "not possible" to have advertising that isn't personalized or even dynamic at all. How so?

Whilst I broadly agree, ads have been targeted to location for a long time. Newspapers and TV would have geographical editions so you don't advertise say your theatre production to people who are too far away to care. With billboards or earlier fliers, you did the same.

Of course. Also TV ads would usually be shown during programs that the advertiser's target audience is most likely to be watching. Like ads for toys between cartoons. That's all fine, you can do the same on the internet without harming anyone's privacy. As an advertising network, you can receive the topic information from the websites themselves as part of them signing up, and users' approximate location can be derived from the IP address.

But instead, they're all hellbent on doing some form of personalization (via tracking) and attribution, and act as if the world would end if all technical means to do that, like third-party cookies, would cease to exist.

Re: Facebook and Instagram to offer ad-free service in UK for up to £3.99 a month

#54

I went ad-free on IG by no longer using it. FB ruined that product.

Took me ages to realise I never get ads on IG. I'm in some sort of permanent control group.

Most non-ads content also is ads but more or less subtle.
Post reply on HN