Live data from Hacker News

YouTube made AI enhancements to videos without warning or permission

bbc.com

51–60 of 292 posts

Re: YouTube made AI enhancements to videos without warning or permission

#51

> YouTube did not respond to the BBC's questions about whether users will be given a choice about AI tweaking their videos. Says everything. Hey PM at YouTube: How about you think stuff through before even starting to waste time on stuff like this?

[dead]

Re: YouTube made AI enhancements to videos without warning or permission

#53
The recent sinking in quality of youtube as a platform has been awful to watch.

Just a couple days ago I got an ad with a Ned Flanders singing about the causes of erectyle dysfunction (!), a huge cocktail of copyright infringement, dangerous medical advice and AI generated slop. Youtube answered the report telling me they've reviewed and found nothing wrong.

The constant low quality, extremely intertwined ads start to remind me of those of shady forums and porn pages of the nineties. I'm expecting them to start advertising heroine now they've decided short term profits trump everything else.

Re: YouTube made AI enhancements to videos without warning or permission

#54
post #8

> "You know, YouTube is constantly working on new tools and experimenting with stuff," Beato says. "They're a best-in-class company, I've got nothing but good things to say. YouTube changed my life." My despondent brain auto-translated that to: "My livelihood depends on Youtube"

And the other day he posted about the abusive copyright claims he has to deal with that cost him a lot of money and could maybe have his channels closed.

Re: YouTube made AI enhancements to videos without warning or permission

#55
post #26

Now to that stupid robot auto translation on non-english videos I never asked for and can not turn off.

This one is the worst. I can't imagine the thought process behind it. How on earth it was seen as a wanted feature, and especially without a simple way to disable it? This feels like they used AI to code this AI thing in.

Re: YouTube made AI enhancements to videos without warning or permission

#56
post #46
post #21

Earlier quoted context omitted.

How does that remove them?

do you feel a need to stop other people doing things you personally don't like?

I want to remove them from my own feed. I want the button that says "hide" or "show fewer shorts" to actually work and ideally hide them forever. I have to play whack-a-mole on the different devices and browsers to try to hide shorts.

Re: YouTube made AI enhancements to videos without warning or permission

#57
post #20

I've seem some game of thrones clips recently in youtube shorts which looked like they'd been generated by ai. I couldn't understand why anyone would have done that to the original good looking material. The only thing I could think was that it was some kind of copyright evasion.

As a fan of the early seasons, I get lots of suggestions for Got clips. I assume that's done by the author to get around copy right blocks. Quite often they also add music, which would make it easier to get around sound detection.

I haven't noticed it outside copyrighted material, so it's probably intentional.

Re: YouTube made AI enhancements to videos without warning or permission

#58
post #45

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The worst thing for me is they don't show the channel names. So much of the channels pushing Star Wars shorts are quite obvious bot names, and it's hard to filter these from legitimate SW content creators who are, on top of that, all using the same damn AI voice.

If I hear an AI voice I click the little menu button with three dots, then click don't show this channel or whatever it says. The Venn diagram of AI voice users and good content creators is pretty close to two separate circles. I don't really care about the minority in the intersection.

Except that now Youtube also "helpfully" auto-dub legitimate videos in other languages (along with translating the titles) by default, so even the 'AI voice' isn't a good signal for gauging if it's quality content or not.

As a french-speaking person, I now find myself seeing french youtubers seemingly posting videos with english titles and robotic voice, before realizing that it's Youtube being stupid again.

What's more infuriating is that it's legitimately at heart a cool feature, just executed in the most brain-dead way possible, by making it opt-out and without the ability to specify known languages.

Re: YouTube made AI enhancements to videos without warning or permission

#59
post #17

Earlier quoted context omitted.

To make people more accustomed to the AI generated look so that when they release their next Veo integration to YouTube content creator tools, these videos will stand out less as unnatural.

There's also the on-by default, can't be disabled, auto-dubbing YouTube performs on every video that's not in the single browser's language. The dubbing quality is poor for the same reason, to intentionally expose viewers to AI content. It's 100% a push to remove human creators from the equation entirely.

That's exactly it. All social media platforms are experimenting with replacing humans with AI.

Re: YouTube made AI enhancements to videos without warning or permission

#60
post #8

> "You know, YouTube is constantly working on new tools and experimenting with stuff," Beato says. "They're a best-in-class company, I've got nothing but good things to say. YouTube changed my life." My despondent brain auto-translated that to: "My livelihood depends on Youtube"

Maybe that statement was just an AI edit and he actually said "YouTube is an evil scourge upon the planet".
Post reply on HN