Live data from Hacker News

Helix Editor 25.07

helix-editor.com

51–60 of 167 posts

Re: Helix Editor 25.07

#51
post #45

Very nice to see a text editor that is very capable, yet still minimal and not focused on including a bunch of useless AI features.

> minimal https://github.com/helix-editor/helix/issues/6187

> As an example, here's the official Alpine package: https://pkgs.alpinelinux.org/package/edge/community/x86_64/h...

> It comes with no grammars installed and it's up to the user to install what they need ... and the grammars can be shared with other editors.

Re: Helix Editor 25.07

#52
post #16
post #10

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It looks very interesting and I'd love to support it, but editors that must be modal are difficult for me to use, personally. Editors that are not modal can be made modal, but can modal editors be made non-modal?

I wouldn't want to go from modal to non-modal. In fact, I have a hard time editing in web browser textareas and Google Docs because of the muscle memory of vimlike keybindings and how I've associated them with tactile keyboards. (Smartphones and tablets don't give me this problem since they feel different, but laptop/desktop Google Docs editing throws me for a loop.) Once you learn, modal is the way to go. It feels l…

I think it really does come down to taste. I learned how to do modal text editing. I believe it is a fine and efficient way to edit. So is non-modal. So is mouse editing. I still prefer the emacs way of doing things

Re: Helix Editor 25.07

#53
post #44
post #39

Congrats! I am happy for helix but i don't think it's a good fit for me. I use Neovim. It does what i want it to do. It's one of the best available options. But, i am not completely satisfied with it. I personally want an editor with following: * Modern codebase. Written from scratch. * VIM Keybindings: I have muscle memory of Vim. I would like to use Vim Keybindings in my editor. I don't want to use any other keybin…

Its not very clear to me which of these Helix hasnt hit. To me it looks like Helix is very close to what you are looking for.

[deleted]

Re: Helix Editor 25.07

#54
Heh. A "post-modern" editor. The second best joke since Fish's "Finally a command line shell for the 90s".

And looking at the video it seems to be tui based. Nice. Gave me Emacs tui vibes.

Re: Helix Editor 25.07

#55
post #45

Very nice to see a text editor that is very capable, yet still minimal and not focused on including a bunch of useless AI features.

> minimal https://github.com/helix-editor/helix/issues/6187

111mb is bloat apparently in a time where storage is in the terabytes.

Re: Helix Editor 25.07

#56
post #10

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It looks very interesting and I'd love to support it, but editors that must be modal are difficult for me to use, personally. Editors that are not modal can be made modal, but can modal editors be made non-modal?

Have you ever used a modal editor? It takes the smallest bit of brain training to adapt, but feels more logical for long form coding. I spend a lot more time reading code than writing. Having more tools to grep/highlight/move text in one mode is quite productive.

Oh, wow. I really enjoy modal editors, especially the Kakoune model seen in Helix and meow-mode for Emacs but I could never put it into words why I actually preferred them.

Yep, that's precisely it.

Re: Helix Editor 25.07

#57

Helix is great and includes a lot of stuff out of the box (file pickers, syntax highlighting, linting etc) without any configuration or installing plugins (contrary to vim or neovim). I would definitely use it but the main disadvantage is that some keybindings work differently than vim. I understand that the keybindings may be better that the vim ones but after years of using vim I expect "x" in normal mode to delete…

Omg. Vim keybindings is the single blocker for me to try helix.

It means that it's possible to add vim support for Helix but they don't want to?

Re: Helix Editor 25.07

#58
post #25

Earlier quoted context omitted.

And then you start craving modal interfaces in your browser, file manager, terminal, messenger... Some Google Docs markdown buffer as a modal editor feature (or a plugin) would be cool.

This, though I've always found the Chrome/Firefox vimlike browser plugins to be such second class citizens that they've never stuck with me. I used to use modal tiling window managers on Linux, but since window managers are always second class on Mac/Windows, that never stuck either. I bounce around too frequently for it to work. I just suffice with tmux for now. I was pleasantly surprised to find Discord's `s/search…

I've had a good experience with Tridactyl on Firefox, but yeah, definitely second class citizens.

Re: Helix Editor 25.07

#59
post #57

Helix is great and includes a lot of stuff out of the box (file pickers, syntax highlighting, linting etc) without any configuration or installing plugins (contrary to vim or neovim). I would definitely use it but the main disadvantage is that some keybindings work differently than vim. I understand that the keybindings may be better that the vim ones but after years of using vim I expect "x" in normal mode to delete…

Omg. Vim keybindings is the single blocker for me to try helix. It means that it's possible to add vim support for Helix but they don't want to?

Sure, why wouldn’t it be? Plenty of programs have Vim keybindings. The challenge is matching the behavior perfectly 1-1.

Re: Helix Editor 25.07

#60
post #44
post #39

Congrats! I am happy for helix but i don't think it's a good fit for me. I use Neovim. It does what i want it to do. It's one of the best available options. But, i am not completely satisfied with it. I personally want an editor with following: * Modern codebase. Written from scratch. * VIM Keybindings: I have muscle memory of Vim. I would like to use Vim Keybindings in my editor. I don't want to use any other keybin…

Its not very clear to me which of these Helix hasnt hit. To me it looks like Helix is very close to what you are looking for.

FYI (for OP): check this fork out https://github.com/usagi-flow/evil-helix
Post reply on HN