Live data from Hacker News

Design Tricks Facebook Uses To Affect Your Privacy Decisions

techcrunch.com

51–60 of 71 posts

Re: Design Tricks Facebook Uses To Affect Your Privacy Decisions

#51

Anybody know how to read techcrunch articles on an iPad these days? I get fifteen seconds of article, then get redirected to that "download our app" thing. No combination of back/forward or clicking "no, let me read the article" results in me being able to actually read the article. I'm not about to pollute my iPad just for one site, so I guess from here on out I just have to make a mental note to stay away from tech…

If it leads to fewer people reading techcrunch, that's all to the good.

Re: Design Tricks Facebook Uses To Affect Your Privacy Decisions

#52

Anybody know how to read techcrunch articles on an iPad these days? I get fifteen seconds of article, then get redirected to that "download our app" thing. No combination of back/forward or clicking "no, let me read the article" results in me being able to actually read the article. I'm not about to pollute my iPad just for one site, so I guess from here on out I just have to make a mental note to stay away from tech…

This exceptionally annoying trend is not even limited to Techrunch but is becoming more common on other sites too. I started to avoid Techrunch links for this reason as well.

In addition, does anyone have an issue with font resizing on Techrunch? When I zoom in to the text it becomes pixelated and unreadable. I end up being forced to read tiny text at original site resolution.

Horrible UX. I expect more tech savvy from Techrunch.

Re: Design Tricks Facebook Uses To Affect Your Privacy Decisions

#53

This is a small nit-pick, but I feel like the word "design" gets thrown around a lot these days, until it doesn't even mean anything anymore. I would expect a "design trick" to be using color, contrast, or typography to achieve a result. If getting rid of the "don't allow" button counts as "design", then I wonder if "design" has become too broad a term to still be useful.

"Design" is any sort of intentional non-obvious, non-arbitrary choice made in the process of creation, as contrasted against using whatever defaults come from the environment and tools at hand.

Re: Design Tricks Facebook Uses To Affect Your Privacy Decisions

#54
post #35

Earlier quoted context omitted.

What games are you claiming need the same level of information about me as a doctor? Frankly, your analogy is ridiculous. Facebook apps aren't integral parts of my health and well-being. They don't need to delve into my personal life. They want to. That's one way to exploit me to advertisers. But a Doctor absolutely needs to, for my own well being. Games and the advertisers they serve don't have that claim.

The social element is absolutely essential to such simple games. If it weren't for the constant nagging of your friends there wouldn't be much fun they would practically not work. If you feel the games exploit you (or the doctor invades your life) , then avoid them.

> If it weren't for the constant nagging of your friends there wouldn't be much fun they would practically not work.

"It wouldn't work without constant nagging" is supposed to support your point?

> If you feel the games exploit you (or the doctor invades your life) , then avoid them.

The entire point of the article is that Facebook is intentionally making it less obvious that these games are exploiting your personal information.

Re: Design Tricks Facebook Uses To Affect Your Privacy Decisions

#56

Anybody know how to read techcrunch articles on an iPad these days? I get fifteen seconds of article, then get redirected to that "download our app" thing. No combination of back/forward or clicking "no, let me read the article" results in me being able to actually read the article. I'm not about to pollute my iPad just for one site, so I guess from here on out I just have to make a mental note to stay away from tech…

Install Opera Mini. Opera (the company) hosts the servers that will preprocess and send you significantly less bandwidth and processor demanding results. You don't have to do anything special for that, just use Opera Mini as a normal browser.

There are pages that can crash Safari on iOS which are no problem to be read in Opera Mini.

I've just followed the link and the whole page is fully readable.

Re: Design Tricks Facebook Uses To Affect Your Privacy Decisions

#57
Some more of these tricks, not specific to Facebook, are compiled here: http://wiki.darkpatterns.org/Main_Page

This wiki has been around for a number of years and I always thought it was a great idea. Shame it hasn’t really seemed to have taken off.

Re: Design Tricks Facebook Uses To Affect Your Privacy Decisions

#58
post #46

Facebook is simply not trustworthy. I feel sorry for people having to create an account simply to use Spotify.

You don't have to use the same account for everything. I have one for social interactions with all privacy settings maxed out (including opting out of the Facebook platform [0]), and one for apps, with no friends. The same goes for Twitter. http://twitter.com/loganloginski [0] Otherwise the apps of your friends have access to your data.

Facebook recently caught up with me and all of my "fake" accounts.

Re: Design Tricks Facebook Uses To Affect Your Privacy Decisions

#59

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Techcrunch wants you to install their app so they can steal your mobile data while you read about how Facebook steals your personal data... Everything is an app today! Yay!

Is that allowed though? Microsoft was penalized heavily for not providing options to Internet Explorer. Can this fall under a lawsuit?

Not sure how that's relevant. Are you implying that Apple is like Microsoft regarding anti-trust, because TechCrunch makes itself hard to read in Mobile Safari without downloading a specific app?

Re: Design Tricks Facebook Uses To Affect Your Privacy Decisions

#60

Anybody know how to read techcrunch articles on an iPad these days? I get fifteen seconds of article, then get redirected to that "download our app" thing. No combination of back/forward or clicking "no, let me read the article" results in me being able to actually read the article. I'm not about to pollute my iPad just for one site, so I guess from here on out I just have to make a mental note to stay away from tech…

We have pulled the offending ad. Sorry about that. -Ned
Post reply on HN