Live data from Hacker News

Microsoft Teams will soon block screen capture during meetings

bleepingcomputer.com

51–60 of 359 posts

Re: Microsoft Teams will soon block screen capture during meetings

#51
post #5
post #2

Any security feature that can be totally defeated with a spicy HDMI splitter and a 2nd computer should not exist. This stuff looks much more to me like "fuck the user" than anything else. I am 100% convinced there is a cult of evil bastards at Microsoft, et. al. that is hellbent on making everyone's UI/UX as janky as possible.

Yea, this sounds like "Microsoft teams no longer supporting video on Linux and old versions of mac/windows" more than anything

Sounds like an good reason to turn down invites with an Teams link

Re: Microsoft Teams will soon block screen capture during meetings

#53
post #33

Which APIs would one use to implement this feature on Mac and Windows? For example is there a OS level flag that one can include on windows to not allow capturing of the app’s window - or is a notification sent out when someone tries to capture the screen (and then one can just blank the window)?

One method for Windows. Nothing can prevent a dedicated user though.

https://learn.microsoft.com/en-us/windows/win32/api/winuser/...

Re: Microsoft Teams will soon block screen capture during meetings

#54
This and DRM and other restrictive anti-features like self destroying messages, un-recordable strings, unprintable files are all fully artificial restrictions. They make no sense when the source code is available since removing it is as simple as removing an if.

I payed for my device, it is mine, it is up to me to decide whatever I'll do with it. It is my right under the private ownership definition. The current situation on modern devices, especially smartphones, is ridiculous and a complete distortion of rights that are fundamental even for the roots of capitalism.

Users should organize and, at the least, avoid using such services even if it means to lose some convenience. Losing my freedom is not a fair price to pay for such conveniences.

Re: Microsoft Teams will soon block screen capture during meetings

#55

What's to stop me embedding a pinhole camera in the lamp behind me, zooming it in on the screen, and recording every meeting? These kinds of measures only stop the good guys from doing their jobs. The bad guys put way too much effort into espionage for this to work.

I love all the comments imagining complex technical workarounds while skipping right over the obvious workaround of using a smartphone camera to take a picture of the screen (which was mentioned near the top of the article that everyone read, of course). Modern camera phones are wide angle enough that it’s not hard to grab a shot of the monitor out of frame.

> These kinds of measures only stop the good guys from doing their jobs. The bad guys put way too much effort into espionage for this to work.

This is for preventing casual screenshots and reminding average office workers that meeting content is sensitive. It’s not an iron-clad tool for defeating dedicated espionage involving hidden pinhole cameras.

There have been similar arguments for ages about how if something isn’t iron-clad perfect protection then it’s pointless, but in the real world making something more difficult actually makes people think twice and stops most of the people who would casually do it.

See for example Snapchat’s screenshot notifications. It’s well known that there’s an elaborate way to circumvent it. However the fact that it takes a lot of work and there’s a risk of getting caught trying really hard to deceive the other party is enough to make most people not want to risk it.

Re: Microsoft Teams will soon block screen capture during meetings

#56

What's to stop me embedding a pinhole camera in the lamp behind me, zooming it in on the screen, and recording every meeting? These kinds of measures only stop the good guys from doing their jobs. The bad guys put way too much effort into espionage for this to work.

The vendors of the camera have the same interests of the vendor of the software. It is just a matter of time until the software watermarks the video and your camera automatically stops recording.

Users have to resort to (exclusively, if possible) open source tools.

Re: Microsoft Teams will soon block screen capture during meetings

#57

What's to stop me embedding a pinhole camera in the lamp behind me, zooming it in on the screen, and recording every meeting? These kinds of measures only stop the good guys from doing their jobs. The bad guys put way too much effort into espionage for this to work.

Or… y’know having a HDMI capture box with a trigger pedal.

Re: Microsoft Teams will soon block screen capture during meetings

#58
post #40

Earlier quoted context omitted.

You can’t really sniff out disgruntled employees until they act on it.

maybe if your employees are disgruntled and feel like they can't talk to you about it you are shit at your job

I had aggressively disgruntled colleagues that couldn‘t deal with being fired, having 3 month notice period and 2 extra salaries and called the CEO names via anonymous all hands meeting.

Many people are babies.

Re: Microsoft Teams will soon block screen capture during meetings

#59
post #36

What's to stop me embedding a pinhole camera in the lamp behind me, zooming it in on the screen, and recording every meeting? These kinds of measures only stop the good guys from doing their jobs. The bad guys put way too much effort into espionage for this to work.

That's the equivalent of sitting in a movie theater with a camcorder. Not important enough to bother crafting a solution for.

But if it makes Microsoft’s claim untenable then it’s worth noting that security is only limited…a sweeping generalization that “screen capture is blocked” isn’t really valid anymore.

Making something more difficult is okay to claim in my view, but trying to over-state capabilities or security concerns is problematic.

Post reply on HN