Live data from Hacker News

An image of the Australian desert illuminates satellite pollution

thisiscolossal.com

51–60 of 136 posts

Re: An image of the Australian desert illuminates satellite pollution

#51

Just paint the satellites black?

Might then have a lot of overheating satellites :)

Put the black surface an inch away from the satellite, supported by standoffs. That'll keep the heat away from the satellite.

Also, the black surface only needs to be on the Earth facing side.

Re: An image of the Australian desert illuminates satellite pollution

#52
post #17
post #10

You know those airplanes with a banner at the beach? I can imagine a constellation of satellites writing ads (live) in space using mirrors and other nifty tech. Unless regulation stops it.

I don't think such a thing could hold together very long, unless it was just a string in a line. Maybe in Morse code? With multiple launches you could probably get several parallel strings, and use it like a dot matrix printer. It would be a heck of a stunt. But I wouldn't expect it to last for more than one orbit, and only part of the planet could see it.

You can change brightness and color of individual satellites as they move, so they would match the "pixel" they are in now. Just imagine swarm of very small emitting light bugs moving chaotically behind your screen and changing colors as they move from one pixel to an other. The only issue is to make sure that at every moment each pixel has enough bugs to get the required brightness.

Re: An image of the Australian desert illuminates satellite pollution

#54
post #44

Earlier quoted context omitted.

This is very easy to say sitting in a developed country where your access to information has never been in question. There are still millions if not billions that don't have access to the rest of humanity's knowledge.

I've been thinking about it for a while; and that's exactly the thing I've been questioning for some time. I'm not as convinced as I was that more knowledge equals a better life. I reflect back on how much time I've spent on countless hours of useless YouTube binges. I've wasted so much time on the internet that could have been spent on things that would have made me happier.

There's good and bad. The important thing is having an internet bullshit filter which the vast majority of people don't have because they didn't grow up with the internet.

Re: An image of the Australian desert illuminates satellite pollution

#55

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I don’t know what the hell you’re going on about for the most part, but the fact is it’s not economically viable for ISPs or even governments to build fibre out to most rural areas. Satellite internet has been a game changer for people living in these areas. The people who grow your food deserve to be able to video chat with their family and stream videos at resolutions higher than 480p without constant buffering.

I agree that there are strong economic reasons in favor but lets not overstate things. If it was economically viable to build out copper telephone lines to those areas then there is zero reason fiber should pose an issue. As far as raw materials go fiber is much cheaper than copper.

>If it was economically viable to build out copper telephone

It wasn't, it was subsidized by the government.

Re: An image of the Australian desert illuminates satellite pollution

#56

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Might then have a lot of overheating satellites :)

Put the black surface an inch away from the satellite, supported by standoffs. That'll keep the heat away from the satellite. Also, the black surface only needs to be on the Earth facing side.

It isn't that simple, is it? Even if you place the black surface on a spacer (adding mass, might I add), the black surface itself is going to radiate heat back onto the satellite via blackbody radiation. This is always going to create a worse thermal situation unless you can somehow radiate away as much heat as you could with reflections. To see what I mean, check out JWST's thermal shield.

Re: An image of the Australian desert illuminates satellite pollution

#57

Just paint the satellites black?

It should also be possible to de-orbit obsolete satellites faster if they can at end-of-life deploy a "sail" that will cause more drag.

Eddy-current-generating tethers seem a more practical option:

https://www.colorado.edu/faculty/kantha/sites/default/files/...>

(A plot point in Neal Stephenson's Seveneves.)

Re: An image of the Australian desert illuminates satellite pollution

#59

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Starlink and similar do not have the capacity for true global internet access. They are suitable only for their current, niche markets e.g. rural areas. If you truly want global internet access fibre is the best option.

How do you get fiber to the top of a mountain or the middle of the ocean?

That isn't a big problem due to several factors. To begin with, OFCs on the ocean bed is how route the majority of the internet traffic already. You can easily bury it a few inches under the surface anywhere. Another point is that these are often used only just high capacity backhaul links. You don't need to criss-cross the terrain with it. And even in the case of the worst of terrains, you can switch to high capacity, highly directional RF or Laser data links for short stretches.

Re: An image of the Australian desert illuminates satellite pollution

#60

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Perhaps there is more to be gained from terrestrial astronomy than pretty pictures?

Such as?

There are massive telescopes around the world with adaptive optics doing cutting edge observations. Their service time is still under high demand. Those aren't just 'pretty pictures'.
Post reply on HN