Live data from Hacker News

Gemma3 – The current strongest model that fits on a single GPU

ollama.com

51–60 of 148 posts

Re: Gemma3 – The current strongest model that fits on a single GPU

#51
post #26
post #24

Earlier quoted context omitted.

can you expand a bit?

The model performs very poorly in practice, while in the benchmark it is shown to be DeepSeek V3 level. It's not terrible but it's at another level compared to the models it is very close to (a bit better / a bit worse) in the benchmarks.

Hey, Gemma engineer here. Can you please share reports on the type of prompts and the implementation you used?

Re: Gemma3 – The current strongest model that fits on a single GPU

#53
post #6

I have tried a lot of local models. I have 656GB of them on my computer so I have experience with a diverse array of LLMs. Gemma has been nothing to write home about and has been disappointing every single time I have used it. Models that are worth writing home about are; EXAONE-3.5-7.8B-Instruct - It was excellent at taking podcast transcriptions and generating show notes and summaries. Rocinante-12B-v2i - Fun for s…

Nice, I think you're nailing the important thing -- which is "what exactly are they good FOR?"

I see a lot of talk about good and not good here, but (and a question for everyone) what are people using the non-local big boys for that the locals CAN'T do? I mean, IRL tasks?

Re: Gemma3 – The current strongest model that fits on a single GPU

#54

Earlier quoted context omitted.

From the limited testing I've done, Gemma 3 27B appears to be an incredibly strong model. But I'm not seeing the same performance in Ollama as I'm seeing on aistudio.google.com. So, I'd recommend trying it from the source before you draw any conclusions. One of the downsides of open models is that there are a gazillion little parameters at inference time (sampling strategy, prompt template, etc.) that can easily impa…

At the end of the day it doesn't matter how good it its, it has no system prompt which means no steerability, a sliding window for incredibly slow inference compared to similar sized models because it's too niche and most inference systems have high overhead implementations of it, and Google's psychotic instruct tuning that made Gemma 2 an inconsistent and unreliable glass cannon. I mean hell, even Mistral added syst…

If you actually looked at gemma-3 you’ll see that it does support system prompts.

I’ve never seen a case where putting the system prompt in the user prompt would lead to significantly different outcomes though. Would like to see some examples.

(edit: my bad. i stand corrected. it seems the code just prepends the system prompts to the first user prompt.)

Re: Gemma3 – The current strongest model that fits on a single GPU

#56

I'm curious. Is there any value to do these OSS models? Suddenly after reasoning models, it looks like OSS models have lost their charm

Thee are a lot of open source reasoning models. The true value to local models is privacy and the ability to have the models be uncensored.

Re: Gemma3 – The current strongest model that fits on a single GPU

#57
Small Models should be train on specific problem in specific language, and should be built one upon another, the way container works. I see a future where a factory or home have local AI server which have many highly specific models, continuously being trained by super large LLM on the web, and are connected via network to all instruments and computer to basically control whole factory. I also see a future where all machinery comes with AI-Readable language for their own functioning. A http like AI protocol for two way communication between machine and an AI. Lots of possibility.

Re: Gemma3 – The current strongest model that fits on a single GPU

#58
post #22

After reading the technical report do the effort of downloading the model and run it against a few prompts. In 5 minutes you understand how broken LLM benchmarking is.

That's why I like giving it a real world test. For example take a podcast transcription and ask it to make show notes and summary. With a temperature of 0 different models will tackle the problem in different ways and you can infer if they really understood the transcript. Usually the transcripts that I give it come from about 1 hour of audio of two or more people talking.

Re: Gemma3 – The current strongest model that fits on a single GPU

#60
post #6

I have tried a lot of local models. I have 656GB of them on my computer so I have experience with a diverse array of LLMs. Gemma has been nothing to write home about and has been disappointing every single time I have used it. Models that are worth writing home about are; EXAONE-3.5-7.8B-Instruct - It was excellent at taking podcast transcriptions and generating show notes and summaries. Rocinante-12B-v2i - Fun for s…

Thanks for the overview. > Qwen2.5-Coder-14B-Instruct - Good for simple coding tasks > OpenThinker-7B - Good and fast reasoning Any chance you could be more specific, ie give an example of a concrete coding task or reasoning problem you used them for?

Qwen2.5-Coder:32B is the best open source coding model. I use it daily, and I don't notice that it lags much behind Claude 3.5.

I would be actually happy to see R1 distilled version, it may make it perform better with the less resource usage.

Post reply on HN