Live data from Hacker News

Sidekick: Local-first native macOS LLM app

github.com

51–60 of 97 posts

Re: Sidekick: Local-first native macOS LLM app

#51

Neat. It would be nice to provide an option to use an API endpoint without downloading an additional local model. I have several models downloaded via ollama and would prefer to use them without additional space being taken up by the default model.

From the README:

Optionally, offload generation to speed up generation while extending the battery life of your MacBook.

Screenshot shows example, mentions OpenAI and gpt-4o.

Re: Sidekick: Local-first native macOS LLM app

#52

What an great looking tool. Amazingly generous that it’s open source. Let’s hope the author can keep building it, but if they need to fund their existence there is precedent - lots of folks pay for Superwhisper. People pay for quality software. In a past tech cycle Apple might’ve hired the author, acquired the IP and lovingly stewarded the work into a bundled OS app. Not something to hope for lately. So just going to…

Yep, I think the guy who’ll make the GUI for LLMs is the next Jobs/Gates/Musk and Nobel Prize Winner (I think it’ll solve alignment by having millions of eyes on the internals of LLMs), because computers became popular only after the OS with a GUI appeared. I just started ASK HN to let people and me share their AI safety ideas, both crazy and not: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43332593

I’ve read the same thing about cryptocurrencies for so long (it needs a proper GUI to take off)

Re: Sidekick: Local-first native macOS LLM app

#53

Looks super neat! Somewhat related, one issue i have with projects like these is it appears like everyone is bundling the UX/App with the core ... pardon my ignorance, "LLM App interface". Eg We have a lot of abstractions for LLMs themselves such as Llama.cpp, but it feels like we lack abstractions for things like what Claude Code does, or perhaps this RAG impl, or whatever. Ie these days it seems like a lot of the m…

On MacOS, look at things like Msty.app (and of course LM Studio)?

They are pluggable across more than just LLM itself.

Re: Sidekick: Local-first native macOS LLM app

#54

Looks super neat! Somewhat related, one issue i have with projects like these is it appears like everyone is bundling the UX/App with the core ... pardon my ignorance, "LLM App interface". Eg We have a lot of abstractions for LLMs themselves such as Llama.cpp, but it feels like we lack abstractions for things like what Claude Code does, or perhaps this RAG impl, or whatever. Ie these days it seems like a lot of the m…

On MacOS, look at things like Msty.app (and of course LM Studio)? They are pluggable across more than just LLM itself.

I went with msty because I didnt want to run docker and it's been rock solid for my needs.

Re: Sidekick: Local-first native macOS LLM app

#55
post #27
post #16

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Some features use private cloud, but it's pretty decent in terms of security and privacy. https://security.apple.com/blog/private-cloud-compute/

"Pretty decent" is irellevant for proprietary code that's not my property. The only safe option is if it's guaranteed to not leave my machine, so for this app, to disable anything that has a chance of exfiltrating data.

I encourage you to try to understand how verifiable transparency works.

https://security.apple.com/blog/pcc-security-research/

Re: Sidekick: Local-first native macOS LLM app

#56
post #34

This is not local, but uses the Tavily cloud ( https://tavily.com/ ) ?!

Sure seems to. https://github.com/search?q=repo%3Ajohnbean393%2FSidekick%20...

This is getting murky.

As a suggestion to the author, please try to make it verifiably local only with an easy to set option.

Re: Sidekick: Local-first native macOS LLM app

#57

What an great looking tool. Amazingly generous that it’s open source. Let’s hope the author can keep building it, but if they need to fund their existence there is precedent - lots of folks pay for Superwhisper. People pay for quality software. In a past tech cycle Apple might’ve hired the author, acquired the IP and lovingly stewarded the work into a bundled OS app. Not something to hope for lately. So just going to…

Yep, I think the guy who’ll make the GUI for LLMs is the next Jobs/Gates/Musk and Nobel Prize Winner (I think it’ll solve alignment by having millions of eyes on the internals of LLMs), because computers became popular only after the OS with a GUI appeared. I just started ASK HN to let people and me share their AI safety ideas, both crazy and not: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43332593

The ideal UX isn’t a secret: audio with AR for context

I’m bullish on an AirPods-with-cameras experience

Re: Sidekick: Local-first native macOS LLM app

#58

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Yep, I think the guy who’ll make the GUI for LLMs is the next Jobs/Gates/Musk and Nobel Prize Winner (I think it’ll solve alignment by having millions of eyes on the internals of LLMs), because computers became popular only after the OS with a GUI appeared. I just started ASK HN to let people and me share their AI safety ideas, both crazy and not: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43332593

What you describe seems to be OpenAI’s “moat”. They currently are the farthest ahead in app UX for nontechnical users and in Brand Recognition. It doesn’t matter if they are 10% behind Anthropic in frontier model quality if Claude For Mac is a shitty Electron app.

I miscommunicated( I meant new 3D game-like UIs. There can be a whole new OS full apps that represent multimodal LLMs in human-familiar ways. All the UI now is what I consider commandline-like. They are like a strict librarian that only spits quotes, no one allows you to truly enter the library. We need better 3D and even “4D” long exposure photo like UIs

Re: Sidekick: Local-first native macOS LLM app

#59
post #52

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Yep, I think the guy who’ll make the GUI for LLMs is the next Jobs/Gates/Musk and Nobel Prize Winner (I think it’ll solve alignment by having millions of eyes on the internals of LLMs), because computers became popular only after the OS with a GUI appeared. I just started ASK HN to let people and me share their AI safety ideas, both crazy and not: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43332593

I’ve read the same thing about cryptocurrencies for so long (it needs a proper GUI to take off)

I miscommunicated( I meant new 3D game-like UIs. There can be a whole new OS full apps that represent multimodal LLMs in human-familiar ways. All the UI now is what I consider commandline-like. They are like a strict librarian that only spits quotes, no one allows you to truly enter the library. We need better 3D and even “4D” long exposure photo like UIs

Re: Sidekick: Local-first native macOS LLM app

#60

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Yep, I think the guy who’ll make the GUI for LLMs is the next Jobs/Gates/Musk and Nobel Prize Winner (I think it’ll solve alignment by having millions of eyes on the internals of LLMs), because computers became popular only after the OS with a GUI appeared. I just started ASK HN to let people and me share their AI safety ideas, both crazy and not: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43332593

What you describe seems to be OpenAI’s “moat”. They currently are the farthest ahead in app UX for nontechnical users and in Brand Recognition. It doesn’t matter if they are 10% behind Anthropic in frontier model quality if Claude For Mac is a shitty Electron app.

Claude for Mac works quite well for me, and now with these MCP servers looking better than ever. And regarding electron - I have seen (and created for myself) awesome apps that would never existed without it.
Post reply on HN