Live data from Hacker News

Watchdog ponders why Apple doesn't apply its strict app tracking rules to itself

theregister.com

51–60 of 72 posts

Re: Watchdog ponders why Apple doesn't apply its strict app tracking rules to itself

#51

Earlier quoted context omitted.

You also don’t have a choice when Apple embeds tracking into their apps, third-party or not. I don’t see why Apple gets away with it just because it’s first party. Should I assume Reminders is sending tracking data to Apple and that’s okay?

For diagnostics and usage patterns only, of course.

Where's the consent? Where's the opt out? These are things we demand of all companies.

Re: Watchdog ponders why Apple doesn't apply its strict app tracking rules to itself

#52

Love how Apple requires App Store free trials to last the full duration even if you cancel, but Apple's own free trials cancel instantly. Rules for thee but not for me...

I have not found this to be the case - just last week I signed up for a free 4 month trial of Apple Music and immediately (like, the next 30 seconds) canceled and retained my trial period. I have also done this with News and TV in the past.

Re: Watchdog ponders why Apple doesn't apply its strict app tracking rules to itself

#53

Thankfully iOS is pretty complete without apps. I don't use apps, I don't find them more convenient than websites. I use my phone like a basic computer. I only really use more advanced things outside of news/calendar/maps on a home desktop PC. I'm not particularly old-fashioned as I had a 12 year career in FAANG mostly working with sensitive PII and business data which is quite boring if you're not a criminal. But I…

iOS devices come with apps pre-installed and this article is about how those apps do not conform to Apple's privacy policies.

Re: Watchdog ponders why Apple doesn't apply its strict app tracking rules to itself

#55

Love how Apple requires App Store free trials to last the full duration even if you cancel, but Apple's own free trials cancel instantly. Rules for thee but not for me...

I have not found this to be the case - just last week I signed up for a free 4 month trial of Apple Music and immediately (like, the next 30 seconds) canceled and retained my trial period. I have also done this with News and TV in the past.

Same here, did it with apple music last week.

Re: Watchdog ponders why Apple doesn't apply its strict app tracking rules to itself

#56
post #53

Thankfully iOS is pretty complete without apps. I don't use apps, I don't find them more convenient than websites. I use my phone like a basic computer. I only really use more advanced things outside of news/calendar/maps on a home desktop PC. I'm not particularly old-fashioned as I had a 12 year career in FAANG mostly working with sensitive PII and business data which is quite boring if you're not a criminal. But I…

iOS devices come with apps pre-installed and this article is about how those apps do not conform to Apple's privacy policies.

Yes I read the article and the only new information for me was the opt-in dialog being used 4 times vs 2. I must not understand it because I've never seen it. The only one I can recall is the one they spam every time iOS updates, asking me to use Wallet several times until I navigate to the menu in settings.

What it doesn't mention is that ATTF is a voluntary program with no enforcement mechanism, currently.

Re: Watchdog ponders why Apple doesn't apply its strict app tracking rules to itself

#58

Earlier quoted context omitted.

For diagnostics and usage patterns only, of course.

Where's the consent? Where's the opt out? These are things we demand of all companies.

Every time I've ever updated my MacBook or my iPhone to the newest OS I got a popup asking if I wanted to consent to reporting anonymous usage data to Apple. I've always refused.

Am I to believe that Apple ignores my explicit refusal of consent and reports the data anyway?

Re: Watchdog ponders why Apple doesn't apply its strict app tracking rules to itself

#59

Thankfully iOS is pretty complete without apps. I don't use apps, I don't find them more convenient than websites. I use my phone like a basic computer. I only really use more advanced things outside of news/calendar/maps on a home desktop PC. I'm not particularly old-fashioned as I had a 12 year career in FAANG mostly working with sensitive PII and business data which is quite boring if you're not a criminal. But I…

Do you only use iMessage? No music player? No robot vacuum you need to control? Fitness tracker, car remote, Steam app for MFA, etc?
Post reply on HN