Live data from Hacker News

Advertising Is a Cancer on Society (2019)

jacek.zlydach.pl

51–60 of 286 posts

Re: Advertising Is a Cancer on Society (2019)

#51

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I would rather live with ads than with literal bread lines my family stood in decades ago, in a socialist state (that funnily had more govt propaganda than ads).

my local food bank has lines every week

Now imagine that but with everyone in that line except the leaders.

Re: Advertising Is a Cancer on Society (2019)

#52

Apple used to seem particularly egregious because their marketing used Spin and exploited status insecurities. They would put the word "Security" or "Privacy" on the screen. They never claimed they were good at security. They just said "Security". It was implied. Factually, they had little to stand on. They also did the thing car markers do, where they exploit status insecurities. They were wholly successful, a lower…

> They were wholly successful, a lower-class person cannot own an Android phone without getting flack.

Who gives a fuck about status if you can't use imessages

Re: Advertising Is a Cancer on Society (2019)

#54

This analogy seems weak. In general, this post argues one way while ignoring all the good advertising does. Do cancers typically do good things at their baseline?

All the good advertising does? What are you referring to?

probably meant something like the cheapening and commercializing of the arts by sponsoring them

Re: Advertising Is a Cancer on Society (2019)

#55
> This is why my kid isn't going to watch YouTube. If and when we decide to show her any children's show, it'll be from a manually curated set of videos downloaded and streamed from a NAS. In my opinion, it's irresponsible to expose children to modern advertising.

I think we need to be careful with this approach. It's also irresponsible to not expose them to modern advertising. Unfortunately, modern advertising does exist, and if they are exposed to it first as a teenager, or worst as an adult, they are likely to be scammed/convinced to buy things they don't need.

Maybe a better way is, instead of banning anything, to supervise and explain to our children what they're seeing.

Re: Advertising Is a Cancer on Society (2019)

#56
After reading the symptoms of the disease, I would say that Advertising could qualify as "Flu on Society". Adverse effects, some people might die of it, but not as fatal or devastating as cancer. Arguably advertising has some benefits for society as well. I have at least found some products that I really wanted and enjoyed thanks to their ads (not many compared to the number of ads I have seen through all my life. Still, I did find some).

The author himself is falling to the "Advertising Trap" of click-baiting his potential audience.

Re: Advertising Is a Cancer on Society (2019)

#57
Was in São Paulo recently, and very much enjoyed the lack of billboards. It surprises me that more cities don't follow their example. (TLDR, kagiing for a list, that 4 US states also have banned billboards.)

https://www.theguardian.com/cities/2015/aug/11/can-cities-ki...

Re: Advertising Is a Cancer on Society (2019)

#58

In a world of finite attention, some form of advertising will inevitable appear. Unless your critique of advertising includes a solution to the attention problem, it's not useful. Then you might say, well there should be some regulations that prevent advertisers from doing X bad thing or saying Y exaggerated statement. Most of these exist already, and if they don't, the legislation required to ban such practices woul…

Just like you can demand that corporations provide correct product information on the packaging, you can easily demand that they only communicate in that way around their products.

The difference between advertising and product information is that the former is deceitful.

Re: Advertising Is a Cancer on Society (2019)

#59
“any effort you spent on advertising serves primarily to counteract the combined advertising efforts of your competitors. The same results could be achieved if every market player limited themselves to just informing customers about their goods and services“

This is a really shallow view of advertising, most of the time you don’t know who is your competitor and you don’t know all the possible ways that you can inform your audience about product, and you don’t fully know what your customer wants.

Re: Advertising Is a Cancer on Society (2019)

#60
post #26

This analogy seems weak. In general, this post argues one way while ignoring all the good advertising does. Do cancers typically do good things at their baseline?

"all the good things advertising does" is doing a lot of the leg work without much being specified.

Here's a good that advertising does: letting people know how your product or services address some pressing need.
Post reply on HN