Live data from Hacker News

How to measure frequency response of a speaker at home

crabman.me

51–58 of 58 posts

Re: How to measure frequency response of a speaker at home

#51

You need a calibrated measurement microphone to do this for real. Otherwise the microphone’s frequency response will skew the results.

Looking at those spectrograms, the uncorrected frequency response of the phone's microphone is unlikely to be responsible for most of what you can see.

Re: How to measure frequency response of a speaker at home

#53
post #48

I just want to point out that it's a pretty big leap to go from "I observed the same frequency response curve with two different inputs" to "there is no audible difference between the two inputs". There are many other measurements you would need to take to prove or disprove the hypothesis, such as signal to noise ratio and dynamic range. And even then you couldn't really prove it definitively due to the complexity of…

are there any established speaker metrics that would get at something like "reconstruction error"? i've seen total harmonic distortion (THD) published in some spec sheets, but i'm not clear if there's a standard method for how that gets calculated or if it's just marketing hype.

moreover, i'm not sure if/how something like THD relates to accuracy of reconstructing more complex naturalistic (i.e., non-sine wave) signals.

Re: How to measure frequency response of a speaker at home

#55

You need a calibrated measurement microphone to do this for real. Otherwise the microphone’s frequency response will skew the results.

iPhone mics are consistent enough to be used for most purposes. Apple provides the correction curves and they are used by apps like Audiotools

Do you know if the same is true of iPads and if there is a program like Spectroid for iOS?

Re: How to measure frequency response of a speaker at home

#56
post #48

I just want to point out that it's a pretty big leap to go from "I observed the same frequency response curve with two different inputs" to "there is no audible difference between the two inputs". There are many other measurements you would need to take to prove or disprove the hypothesis, such as signal to noise ratio and dynamic range. And even then you couldn't really prove it definitively due to the complexity of…

Do different DACs frequently sound different? I would expect that it's audiophile's fairy tales.

Re: How to measure frequency response of a speaker at home

#57

> I eyeballed the two (red) plots and I think they look more or less identical. I overlaid those two images [0], and they seem significantly (though not hugely) different to me. Wouldn't speculate as to why that is though, without checking the consistency of passes with the same setup. 0 - https://imgur.com/a/7GUSmPW (with hue shift for comparison)

This is useful, thanks. I should've done it on my own. And checking the consistency of passes would be a good idea too. If you don't mind, I'll update my blog post to include your overlaid image.

Re: How to measure frequency response of a speaker at home

#58

> I eyeballed the two (red) plots and I think they look more or less identical. I overlaid those two images [0], and they seem significantly (though not hugely) different to me. Wouldn't speculate as to why that is though, without checking the consistency of passes with the same setup. 0 - https://imgur.com/a/7GUSmPW (with hue shift for comparison)

This is useful, thanks. I should've done it on my own. And checking the consistency of passes would be a good idea too. If you don't mind, I'll update my blog post to include your overlaid image.

No worries.. I'd be interested to see the results of a multi pass consistency test.
Post reply on HN