Live data from Hacker News

Chrome is entrenching third-party cookies that will mislead users

brave.com

51–60 of 329 posts

Re: Chrome is entrenching third-party cookies that will mislead users

#51

Damn. If there was ever any doubt about why you should get off chrome, this seems to put an end to that.

Shed a tear for the Firefox that could have been

Forget Firefox as a fix. Call your legislators and explain this Google Chrome funny business to them.

Re: Chrome is entrenching third-party cookies that will mislead users

#52

Damn. If there was ever any doubt about why you should get off chrome, this seems to put an end to that.

right but at least google will tell you. brave a lot more shady and just wont say anything or let you opt out. many examples in the past. imagine if they were anywhere near a quarter of googles size it wouldnt be pretty imo.

I wouldn't count the Privacy Sandbox doublespeak as "telling you". Brave is not my browser, but it seems completely unjustified to just put them on the same (or even lower) level as Chrome.

Re: Chrome is entrenching third-party cookies that will mislead users

#53
post #46

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Shed a tear for the Firefox that could have been

I certainly do. That said, I struggle to find another browser that's any better and most are worse. So I accept Firefox as the lesser evil.

Safari. That's the only browser I really use.

Re: Chrome is entrenching third-party cookies that will mislead users

#54
post #23
post #19

Padme: So then Brave isn’t going to be based on Chrome anymore, right?

Brave is a Chromium derivative, not Chrome. Can't imagine why any of this would imply they would need to stop deriving Chromium: they can develop and deploy whatever cookie policies and defaults they want.

At this point they likely have no choice but to keep building on a chromium base. However the cost of maintaining their changes and additions will likely increase.

Re: Chrome is entrenching third-party cookies that will mislead users

#55
post #46

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Shed a tear for the Firefox that could have been

I certainly do. That said, I struggle to find another browser that's any better and most are worse. So I accept Firefox as the lesser evil.

Brave browser is such an obvious win for me… chrome + privacy. None of the bugs and missing features that come with Safari or Firefox.

Re: Chrome is entrenching third-party cookies that will mislead users

#56
post #44

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Shed a tear for the Firefox that could have been

Firefox is still working great for me, and I intend to keep using it for the foreseeable future. I don't know what it might take for people to migrate away from Chrome en masse, but the alternative is there.

Mozilla is slowly turning to ad company too. Let's see what future brings us.

Re: Chrome is entrenching third-party cookies that will mislead users

#57
post #45
post #12

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Do you mean that Brave is a competitor, or something else?

Both a competitor AND a history of operating in, to be polite, less than good faith.

As a competitor, let's add that they are ad company too.

Re: Chrome is entrenching third-party cookies that will mislead users

#58
post #25

Earlier quoted context omitted.

right but at least google will tell you. brave a lot more shady and just wont say anything or let you opt out. many examples in the past. imagine if they were anywhere near a quarter of googles size it wouldnt be pretty imo.

the only two browsers, Chrome and Brave

That doesn't make a bit of sense. There's plenty of browsers, there's chrome, brave, firefox, opera, edge and safari, those are the big ones. There's also a ton of spinoffs like ice weasel or that browser Kagi is developing that I can't remember the name of.

Way more than just two chromium browsers in existence.

Re: Chrome is entrenching third-party cookies that will mislead users

#59
post #29

Earlier quoted context omitted.

statistically, 50% chance, innit?

OP seems to claim 13% same / 87% opposite

I don't think you can make that conclusion.

I think you're making the assumption that all three data points are needed for all 87%. But obviously some people can be uniquely identified based on just {zip, date or birth}, such that gender isn't necessary.

So the distribution could e.g. be 8% same, 8% opposite, 5% both, 79% neither, and explain the original numbers without triggering the paradox.

Re: Chrome is entrenching third-party cookies that will mislead users

#60
post #23
post #19

Padme: So then Brave isn’t going to be based on Chrome anymore, right?

Brave is a Chromium derivative, not Chrome. Can't imagine why any of this would imply they would need to stop deriving Chromium: they can develop and deploy whatever cookie policies and defaults they want.

> Can't imagine why any of this would imply they would need to stop deriving Chromium: they can develop and deploy whatever cookie policies and defaults they want.

Maintaining a very diverged fork can take even more work than building your own browser. I think they don't want to stop receiving upstream updates when the upstream is one of the biggest software projects in the world.

Post reply on HN