Live data from Hacker News

Popular Mac app 'Bartender' acquired by new unknown developer

9to5mac.com

51–60 of 151 posts

Re: Popular Mac app 'Bartender' acquired by new unknown developer

#51
post #5

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It’s a $22 paid app. Of course it’s not going to be open sourced.

I think there are some open source macOS apps that provide code but sell binaries on the App Store, no?

I know at least of Textual. Open source but you can buy a pre-built binary for $10. Compiling it yourself was fairly easy when I tried it out once though.

https://github.com/Codeux-Software/Textual

Re: Popular Mac app 'Bartender' acquired by new unknown developer

#52
post #18

I dropped Evernote when it was bought and the entire U.S. staff was fired. Replacing it with another, preferably free and open source. (search going on at this time)

Evernote never worked reliably, well, or consistently. Apple Notes squished their business model and now Obsidian has somewhat juiced Apple's.

It does now.

Re: Popular Mac app 'Bartender' acquired by new unknown developer

#55
post #7

What looks odd to me is this silence about acquisition. I've got a lot of emails and read enough blog posts from developers that brags about new owners and new opportunities that goes with it. Bartender is just utility app, but has permissions to e.g screen recording, so new version from new developer without prior explanation just seems shady

With the most recent update, macOS notified me that I needed to allow new permissions. But macOS didn't explain that this was because the cert changed. When I Googled the issue, I found this support article: https://www.macbartender.com/Bartender5/PermissionIssues/

The support article doesn't mention the cert change or the new owners, and instead calls it "a known issue where certain apps, including Bartender, might not receive Accessibility and Screen Recording permissions properly, despite the user granting them in System Settings."

Highly disingenuous. I've uninstalled Bartender.

Re: Popular Mac app 'Bartender' acquired by new unknown developer

#56
post #20
post #17

I got a new Mac recently, had run Bartender in the past and decided to but the newest version without checking it out first. I was surprised to see the screen recording permission. This was 12 days ago. I wrote support saying: > I think screen recording is too much of a privacy and security concern. > Even if you have no bad intentions, if someone compromises your security, they have access to an app that I've allowe…

This permission request predated the change of ownership of Bartender.

Yes, but you had to re-enable it due to the cert change. Bartender doesn't explain this is what happened and simply states "there's a known issue where certain apps, including Bartender, might not receive Accessibility and Screen Recording permissions properly, despite the user granting them in System Settings."

https://www.macbartender.com/Bartender5/PermissionIssues/

Re: Popular Mac app 'Bartender' acquired by new unknown developer

#57
post #27

This is the danger of closed source software. There is no guarantee that the developers incentives will remain aligned with yours.

This happens with OSS apps as well, see the Simple Mobile Tools takeover by an Israeli adware company, affecting several popular Android apps (Gallery, File Manager, others). https://github.com/SimpleMobileTools/General-Discussion/issu...

Yep, and also the xz backdoor debacle.

Re: Popular Mac app 'Bartender' acquired by new unknown developer

#58

Use Ice instead: https://github.com/jordanbaird/Ice

I’ve been using this for the last six hours or so, and it’s decent. You use Cmd+drag to move icons between shown and unshown, which at the time of writing isn’t clear from the Readme or site

Re: Popular Mac app 'Bartender' acquired by new unknown developer

#59
I've been using Dozer for some time with no complaints, I'm not sure how much of the feature set overlaps as I use it primarily hiding extraneous menubar items.

https://github.com/Mortennn/Dozer

(For what its worth it looks like it hasn't been update in 3+ years)

Post reply on HN