Live data from Hacker News

How Home Assistant is being used to protect from missile and drone attacks

denysdovhan.com

51–60 of 191 posts

Re: How Home Assistant is being used to protect from missile and drone attacks

#51
post #22

It's 2024, instead of riding our personal spaceships to habitat on Mars, we use Home Assistant software to alert us about incoming missile attacks. War is the single most unproductive activity humans can do. Sure, maybe Putin has his rationale, but spiting on a cake is never how one can secure the cake for themself, because guess what, others can also spit on it and then the cake is ruined. A greater leader knows tha…

Some of the telegram channels are government run, so it's not just open source intel

Of course it would be possible to detect these things yourself, you would just need an extensive radar network covering 600k km2 of Ukraine, and as much of Russia as you can. You'll need quite a variety of systems to detect both hypersonic missiles and slow low flying drones.

Re: How Home Assistant is being used to protect from missile and drone attacks

#52
post #34

Earlier quoted context omitted.

[flagged]

What would you do? Install a favorable dictator? Thanks to warmongering there isn't much of a diplomatic route to peace where we still need it. Petty ulterior motives held by world 'leaders' have made it hard.

Accept Ukraine to NATO in 2008 and none of this would have happened. Thank France and Germany for blocking it.

Re: How Home Assistant is being used to protect from missile and drone attacks

#53

Earlier quoted context omitted.

They are indeed violating other countries waters though.

And how would you propose deterring them from doing this while also avoiding escalation?

The problem is that avoiding escalation with an imperialist dictatorship IS escalatory.

If NATO escalated a little more in 2008 - hundreds of thousands of people in Ukraine AND in Russia would still live.

Instead we made Putin think he can get away with it.

Re: How Home Assistant is being used to protect from missile and drone attacks

#54

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Isn’t history showing that letting aggressors nibble away at norms and borders and letting them get away with it ‘to avoid escalation’ is just emboldening the aggressor? Peace in our time.

So countries should have attacked the US when it committed it's illegal wars in the middle east, to stop emboldening the aggressor? I don't think that would have created a better world. It's easy to say things like this about your geopolitical enemies, but allies get away with it all the time.

Sanctioning US back then would be interesting.

BTW war in Afghanistan wasn't illegal.

Re: How Home Assistant is being used to protect from missile and drone attacks

#55
post #34

Earlier quoted context omitted.

[flagged]

What would you do? Install a favorable dictator? Thanks to warmongering there isn't much of a diplomatic route to peace where we still need it. Petty ulterior motives held by world 'leaders' have made it hard.

peace unfortunately is made by deterrence. defending the potential victims of aggressors works.

Re: How Home Assistant is being used to protect from missile and drone attacks

#56
post #34

Earlier quoted context omitted.

[flagged]

What would you do? Install a favorable dictator? Thanks to warmongering there isn't much of a diplomatic route to peace where we still need it. Petty ulterior motives held by world 'leaders' have made it hard.

> What would you do? Install a favorable dictator?

Oh, there's a lot between not doing anything at all and repeating the mistakes from Iranian days:

- provide economic / humanitarian aid contingent on progress in democratic values and actually audit where the money goes. This ended being effective around 2010 when China began hitting the global stage though.

- supporting countries or democratic, pro-Western parties/groups that are threatened by an aggressor (e.g. every former Soviet state)

- when supposed "allies" end up funding our enemies (e.g. Saudi-Arabia, who not just financed Bin Laden and is the main ideological driver in fundamentalist madrasas (religious schools) all over the world, thus being the main contributor to Islamist terrorism), cut them off. Hell the Saudis butchered a journalist (a father of U.S. citizens) in an embassy and we didn't do shit. Instead, we allow Saudi-Arabia and Qatar to host fucking World Cups. What a bunch of bullshit.

- aggressive, actually effective sanctions instead of just making the lives of a few oligarchs a tiny bit more difficult

- increase our own security posture in terms of military and provide a credible retaliation threat towards any potential aggressor

- invest into academic research on other countries. That one got shamefully disbanded after the collapse of the USSR and the shift towards prioritizing STEM over humanities - we now lack the academic capacity for actually understanding other countries or provide actual evidence-backed advice to politicians. Instead we got completely dependent on think tanks and consultancies.

- respond in-kind to Russia and China banning Western activities: they effectively force pro-democracy organizations to close shop? Fine, no more Chinese police stations in Western countries. They engage in cyberwarfare? Fine, we cut them off from the Internet. They refuse to allow Western countries fair and equal access to their markets? Fine, we ban investments from China and force-divest existing investments, and raise tariffs on their exports.

The last part is the easiest... over decades we believed in "change by trade", we hoped that they would become similar to us culturally. That worked in certain areas - McDonald's and Coca-Cola show that - but politically, we didn't give a slightest interest in both countries getting ever more authoritarian. And now it's biting us in our collective arses.

Re: How Home Assistant is being used to protect from missile and drone attacks

#57
post #34

Earlier quoted context omitted.

[flagged]

What would you do? Install a favorable dictator? Thanks to warmongering there isn't much of a diplomatic route to peace where we still need it. Petty ulterior motives held by world 'leaders' have made it hard.

Much more international response (sanctions) to:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Poisoning_of_Sergei_and_Yulia_... in 2018.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-europe-28357880 MH17 shootdown in 2014.

and in the UK, https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-politics-62068421

"Controversy surrounds that appointment, since it was alleged - first in a Tortoise Media podcast and then in the Sunday Times - that the peerage was granted despite a warning from the security services that it posed a national security risk."

People were very happy to overlook Russian misbehavior so long as the money kept coming.

Re: How Home Assistant is being used to protect from missile and drone attacks

#58

Earlier quoted context omitted.

They are indeed violating other countries waters though.

And how would you propose deterring them from doing this while also avoiding escalation?

Show of force, easy as that. Pirates get deterred when cargo ships have gunmen armed to the teeth with AK-47 and look for easier targets, Russian ships get deterred from Ukrainian autonomous naval drones, and China gets deterred if random fisher boats get escorted in their territorial waters by an US carrier group.

Re: How Home Assistant is being used to protect from missile and drone attacks

#59

The existence of this is fascinating and horrifying at the same time. I wonder how he tests it though; when writing tons of YAML for K8s or Ansible, you usually test it in a test environment before putting it in production. Unlike the other cases though, a bug in your YAML here can literally lead people to lose their lives.

Welcome to the dystopian future timeline! It gets worse

Re: How Home Assistant is being used to protect from missile and drone attacks

#60
post #36

The existence of this is fascinating and horrifying at the same time. I wonder how he tests it though; when writing tons of YAML for K8s or Ansible, you usually test it in a test environment before putting it in production. Unlike the other cases though, a bug in your YAML here can literally lead people to lose their lives.

The term “battle tested” is used literally here

Made by the people from the trenches
Post reply on HN