Live data from Hacker News

Microsoft closes several large Bethesda affiliated game studios

ign.com

51–60 of 233 posts

Re: Microsoft closes several large Bethesda affiliated game studios

#52
post #9

What is extraordinary about the Microsoft games unit and Xbox is how immune their senior staff are to the repercussions of their bad decisions. They're certainly not taking responsibility for the failed gamepass experiment, trashing the Xbox brand, or the acquisitions they now regret since successfully closing Activision. Failing upwards has never been so conspicuously obvious as it is in modern corporate America tha…

'member Games For Windows ~~Live~~ Dead ?

Re: Microsoft closes several large Bethesda affiliated game studios

#53

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Theyve released 5 bad games since prey

Arkane Austin only made Redfall since Prey, the rest were Arkane Lyon (which didn't close). Allegedly (based on some articles) Redfall started as a pure singleplayer game ala Prey 2017 (and their older titles) but Zenimax and Bethesda wanted to add multiplayer and Games-as-a-service elements because they thought it'd increase the company's value back when they were looking for buyers Essentially the studio was forced…

thank you for the context.

Re: Microsoft closes several large Bethesda affiliated game studios

#54

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Just as with movies, it seems like we’re witnessing the death of mid-budget (AA) games.

Honestly I think it might make sense. I can't remember a single AA game that was great. Actually, I can't remember a single AA game other than the ones I remember because of how bad they were. I think AA in games has, for a long time, meant "We want to do a AAA but don't have the money or time" and this can only end in disaster.

"I don't like this so it should stop existing"

Re: Microsoft closes several large Bethesda affiliated game studios

#55
post #29

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Just as with movies, it seems like we’re witnessing the death of mid-budget (AA) games.

Conversely, the recently released surprise hit Helldivers 2 is a very prominent AA game has sold millions of copies and seems well poised to win a bunch of game of the year awards (recently concluded PSN account linking controversy notwithstanding).

Sidebar: Helldivers II is not a genre I’d normally enjoy but I have absolutely fallen in love with the very rewarding gameplay loop and grind.

I have never enjoyed spreading democracy more with my friends than dropping a perfectly targeted orbital strike on a bunch of unpatriotic bugs.

Re: Microsoft closes several large Bethesda affiliated game studios

#56
post #13

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It's like destroying a factory when the chips it produces do not sell.

Firing an entire sports team after a loss. Although in Tango's case, not even a loss, just not a big enough victory.

Game studios have always been very brutal in their hire/grind/fire cycle. Not sure they really want to change.

Re: Microsoft closes several large Bethesda affiliated game studios

#57
post #2

Anecdotally, as an avid gamer, I, personally do not miss the studios listed

But that clearly isn't equivalent to "they will not be missed", or "the gaming industry is better without them". Rockstar or Treyarch could disappear and I personally wouldn't care, but I also wouldn't pop into threads about them and pat myself on the back for not being bothered.

Re: Microsoft closes several large Bethesda affiliated game studios

#58

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Honestly I think it might make sense. I can't remember a single AA game that was great. Actually, I can't remember a single AA game other than the ones I remember because of how bad they were. I think AA in games has, for a long time, meant "We want to do a AAA but don't have the money or time" and this can only end in disaster.

>I can't remember a single AA game that was great I'm always skeptical of "I can't remember ____" as an assessment of any given historical record because, well, the average person just doesn't remember anything. Which is all well and good, you have no obligation to be ready for a pop-quiz, but snapshot moment of free-association is just not a reliable stand in for the actual record. I actually couldn't think of any A…

As an aside of this discussion: I do not get people who like Outer Worlds. I am a huge fan of New Vegas, I was so pumped for that game, and it was so, so bland. The combat damn near put me to sleep, the writing was atrociously heavy-handed and made me think the authors thought I was a complete fucking idiot (and I agree with them!), and the moment-to-moment gameplay was just thoroughly, thoroughly unsatisfying.

I know it has a loving if smaller community and man, I wanted to love it, but I just could not. I have hope for the sequel and will definitely play it if not day one, close to it, but yeah. Outer Worlds was one of my most disappointing games of all time.

Re: Microsoft closes several large Bethesda affiliated game studios

#59

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Just as with movies, it seems like we’re witnessing the death of mid-budget (AA) games.

Honestly I think it might make sense. I can't remember a single AA game that was great. Actually, I can't remember a single AA game other than the ones I remember because of how bad they were. I think AA in games has, for a long time, meant "We want to do a AAA but don't have the money or time" and this can only end in disaster.

The list of great non AAA games would be so long, here, as to be obnoxious. A lot of game greatness is found in the explicit avoidance of AAA conventions, like extended cut scenes. Many AAA games are masterpieces, and yet few to no no AAA games are 2D platformers for example. Which is one of the all time great formats for pure fun.

Re: Microsoft closes several large Bethesda affiliated game studios

#60
post #9

What is extraordinary about the Microsoft games unit and Xbox is how immune their senior staff are to the repercussions of their bad decisions. They're certainly not taking responsibility for the failed gamepass experiment, trashing the Xbox brand, or the acquisitions they now regret since successfully closing Activision. Failing upwards has never been so conspicuously obvious as it is in modern corporate America tha…

I don't play games at all so I'm very out of the loop but gamepass was a failure? I have friends at Microsoft who worked on it and they all seemed to think it was going well last I checked (about a year ago).

>they all seemed to think it was going well last I checked

...based on what?

Post reply on HN