Live data from Hacker News

JetBrains AI

jetbrains.com

51–60 of 113 posts

Re: JetBrains AI

#51

Who owns the source code if AI is helping you write it? Is this a concern for companies that are copyrighting their code? What if multiple companies use this AI tool to implement an algorithm and then copyright it?

IIRC, (US) copyright would be assigned to the person who used the tool*. Just like how your keyboard doesn't own the copyright to what you write with it.

* Existing contracts with copyright assignment clauses notwithstanding

Re: JetBrains AI

#52

I will only want to use this if i'm able to host the LLM locally. Currently using CodeGPT and running CodeBooga 34b @ 4bit on my work laptop. This is good enough for me, but i'd love some more advanced functionality, such as code completion. CodeGPT - Repo: https://github.com/carlrobertoh/CodeGPT - Plugin: https://plugins.jetbrains.com/plugin/21056-codegpt

[dead]

Re: JetBrains AI

#53

    Does AI Assistant send data and code fragments from my IDE?

    When you use AI-powered features, the IDE needs to send your requests and code
    to the LLM provider. In addition to the prompts you type, the IDE may send additional
    details, such as pieces of your code, file types, frameworks used, and other
    information that may be necessary for providing the LLM with sufficient context.
That'll eliminate its use from a lot of environments.

Re: JetBrains AI

#54

I will only want to use this if i'm able to host the LLM locally. Currently using CodeGPT and running CodeBooga 34b @ 4bit on my work laptop. This is good enough for me, but i'd love some more advanced functionality, such as code completion. CodeGPT - Repo: https://github.com/carlrobertoh/CodeGPT - Plugin: https://plugins.jetbrains.com/plugin/21056-codegpt

Isn't that going to be extremely slow? I can only realistically run 7B 5-bit models on my RTX 3060, anything more and it offloads to the CPU. My responses go from almost-instantaneous to 3mins+.

Re: JetBrains AI

#55

Would love to see an unbiased direct comparison between GitHub Copilot and Copilot Chat. How do folks handle competing "helpers"? I've found I need to turn one on at a time. Otherwise, it's distracting.

One thing to note is Copilot Chat does not work in JetBrains IDEs, yet. You have to use a text editor like Visual Studio Code instead.

You can apply to get beta access to Chat. It took about a week to get approval for me (I did it last month).

Re: JetBrains AI

#56

I will only want to use this if i'm able to host the LLM locally. Currently using CodeGPT and running CodeBooga 34b @ 4bit on my work laptop. This is good enough for me, but i'd love some more advanced functionality, such as code completion. CodeGPT - Repo: https://github.com/carlrobertoh/CodeGPT - Plugin: https://plugins.jetbrains.com/plugin/21056-codegpt

Give it another year. In theory it's not going to be difficult, but sampling speed/power consumption is prohibitive for normal hardware at the moment.

Re: JetBrains AI

#57

Just like many others are saying here, and i hope JetBrains hears and sees the feedback- this should 100% be included in the all products pack. We are already paying for products we don’t use, incentivize us not to downgrade. An extra subscription on top of gpt-4 is rough. I’ve been a loyal customer for years and have convinced many others to switch and pay for your products. Now it’s going to effectively double in p…

I was a bit skeptical of Cursor, but I have fully migrated over and have had no issues.

Re: JetBrains AI

#58

> We encourage you to download the 2023.3 version of your go-to JetBrains IDE, open the AI Assistant tool window, log in with your JetBrains Account, and give the new functionality a try. Oh I would love to. Upgraded RubyMine to 2023.3, subscribed to AI on their website. Clicking "Get Started" in the login window just closes it and nothing happens :D I'll be happy to ditch GitHub Copilot if I get this to work. Sendin…

Don't worry, it'll get to OpenAI^H^H^H^H^H^HMicrosoft soon enough via the API.

Re: JetBrains AI

#59

Just like many others are saying here, and i hope JetBrains hears and sees the feedback- this should 100% be included in the all products pack. We are already paying for products we don’t use, incentivize us not to downgrade. An extra subscription on top of gpt-4 is rough. I’ve been a loyal customer for years and have convinced many others to switch and pay for your products. Now it’s going to effectively double in p…

If you use this at any scale using an API key directly will cost a lot more than $16/mo. I’m convinced that these products are purely loss leaders at this point having seen how crazy expensive GPT-4 is when used direct.

No kidding, I'm spending $10-20 a day on API calls just between summarization and development using aider.

Re: JetBrains AI

#60

Sidenote, are there any videos of a real world developer just programming real stuff, and using AI integrations like these sprinkled in? I'd be really curious to see how someone uses this. I use GPT/etc (currently through Kagi's Ultimate) so i have long seen value in them, but i've not yet figured out how to bridge the gap with integrating it directly into my code. Too often i feel like i'm writing logic and i don't…

I use GitHub Copilot IntelliJ plugin every day and would not consider going back to the pre-LLM state of affairs.

I don't use it to generate entire classes or tests, because it doesn't work well for that, and definitely not for big refactors, but it works well as a "super autocomplete" for 1-3 lines of code at a time.

Post reply on HN