Live data from Hacker News

Men's Shed

en.wikipedia.org

51–53 of 53 posts

Re: Men's Shed

#51

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I noticed there was no criticism section on Wikipedia (Hackerspaces has that section). Looking at this comment being downvoted.. Can anyone explain why men sheds should not be critisized?

The absence of a criticism section on a Wikipedia page has nothing to do with whether or not the subject of that page should be criticised..

It is notably missing

Re: Men's Shed

#52

Earlier quoted context omitted.

If it's good for men's mental health, wouldn't it be good for women's mental health too? I just don't see how using a community workshop is related to gender.

Men behave differently around women, compared to an all-male environment. It's mostly subconscious, but men (especially the older generation) would instinctively put up a tough front while women are present, and would be hesitant to show signs of weakness, so some would have trouble truly opening up. No doubt there are also male health concerns that men would feel more comfortable talking about to other men. It's not…

I have to wonder how old I need to get before I understand the "older generation". I'm almost 60 myself. I'm not sure that it's really an age thing. There has always been a "hypermasculinity" culture of men who need to look tough, and you can find plenty of millennial representatives. But other men have no problem interacting with women.

Re: Men's Shed

#53
post #36

Earlier quoted context omitted.

If it's good for men's mental health, wouldn't it be good for women's mental health too? I just don't see how using a community workshop is related to gender.

Would this argument hold up in reverse for a women's shelter?

They're already a thing though. ;)
Post reply on HN