Live data from Hacker News

Cisco Acquires Splunk

splunk.com

51–60 of 525 posts

Re: Cisco Acquires Splunk

#51

I guess Cisco's AppDynamic acquisition from a few years ago isn't panning out. Or maybe they're complimentary, who knows?

I bet they will just try to upsell all the AppD customers with Splunk ES/SIEM. If the Thousand Eyes and AppD integration is any indicator they will add a button in AppD that opens up Splunk...

Re: Cisco Acquires Splunk

#52

Does anyone have an example of an acquisition where the products of the acquired company then became better?

The responses here are giving me some hope. I’ve just had many experiences as a customer where products I’ve used became worse (or were shut down) after their companies were acquired

Re: Cisco Acquires Splunk

#53
post #35
post #19

Earlier quoted context omitted.

GitHub I'm sure there are tons of other, lesser known acquisitions... looking at what Apple acquires - seems relevant to be integrated into their products: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_mergers_and_acquisitio... Oh, wow, they even acquired Intel smartphone modem business at 2019 and other Semiconductor businesses.

DarkSky seems to be a big exception to this

I disagree. Apple Weather has become an amazing app since the DarkSky acquisition. I especially like the hourly charts.

Re: Cisco Acquires Splunk

#54

I hated Splunk so much that I spent a couple days a few months ago writing a single 1200 line python script that does absolutely everything I need in terms of automatic log collection, ingestion, and analysis from a fleet of cloud instances. It pulls in all the log lines, enriches them with useful metadata like the IP address of the instance, the machine name, the log source, the datetime, etc. and stores it all in S…

For how many data sources? The whole reason everyone goes to Splunk is that it scales, and scales incredibly well.

Large enterprises can generate hundreds of terabytes to petabytes every day. Splunk has all sorts of issues, but to pretend as if you can replace them in any large shop with a 1200 line python script and SQLite is just being disingenuous. This acquisition falls right into Cisco's sweet spot, they aren't chasing shops that can dump all their security and infrastructure logging into a SQLite database and not have it tip over in an hour.

Re: Cisco Acquires Splunk

#55

I hated Splunk so much that I spent a couple days a few months ago writing a single 1200 line python script that does absolutely everything I need in terms of automatic log collection, ingestion, and analysis from a fleet of cloud instances. It pulls in all the log lines, enriches them with useful metadata like the IP address of the instance, the machine name, the log source, the datetime, etc. and stores it all in S…

Sounds like a startup

Re: Cisco Acquires Splunk

#56
post #53
post #35

Earlier quoted context omitted.

DarkSky seems to be a big exception to this

I disagree. Apple Weather has become an amazing app since the DarkSky acquisition. I especially like the hourly charts.

Apple Weather may be better, but DarkSky is gone and it has not included all the features it used to have, such as hourly rain probability for any day.

Re: Cisco Acquires Splunk

#57

I guess Cisco's AppDynamic acquisition from a few years ago isn't panning out. Or maybe they're complimentary, who knows?

AppDynamics is primarily an APM product, not a SEIM.

Also, from a business perspective, Cisco basically removed a competitor from the field.

Re: Cisco Acquires Splunk

#58

I hated Splunk so much that I spent a couple days a few months ago writing a single 1200 line python script that does absolutely everything I need in terms of automatic log collection, ingestion, and analysis from a fleet of cloud instances. It pulls in all the log lines, enriches them with useful metadata like the IP address of the instance, the machine name, the log source, the datetime, etc. and stores it all in S…

It sounds like the difference between a car and a freight train.

Re: Cisco Acquires Splunk

#59
post #54

I hated Splunk so much that I spent a couple days a few months ago writing a single 1200 line python script that does absolutely everything I need in terms of automatic log collection, ingestion, and analysis from a fleet of cloud instances. It pulls in all the log lines, enriches them with useful metadata like the IP address of the instance, the machine name, the log source, the datetime, etc. and stores it all in S…

For how many data sources? The whole reason everyone goes to Splunk is that it scales, and scales incredibly well. Large enterprises can generate hundreds of terabytes to petabytes every day. Splunk has all sorts of issues, but to pretend as if you can replace them in any large shop with a 1200 line python script and SQLite is just being disingenuous. This acquisition falls right into Cisco's sweet spot, they aren't…

It's around 6 data sources on ~25 machines, but it could be easily scaled to way more than that with a bit of work. And I mean less work than it takes to do even trivially simple things using the horrible Splunk API. There are many thousands of small companies using Splunk and getting totally ripped off for a very mediocre product with a rapacious and annoyingly aggressive salesforce.

Re: Cisco Acquires Splunk

#60
post #41

Earlier quoted context omitted.

What makes you say Splunk is a dead player? Not arguing with you, it's genuine curiosity on my part.

they price-out medium customers so mind-share decreases

Are medium-sized customers valuable to Splunk?

In sales we call this "Ideal Customer Profile." Why do I want a customer with less money to spend if I have a product with enough capability for the gigantic money-is-no-object customers?

Post reply on HN