Live data from Hacker News

GM confirms $130k Cadillac won’t have Apple CarPlay or Android Auto

theverge.com

51–60 of 106 posts

Re: GM confirms $130k Cadillac won’t have Apple CarPlay or Android Auto

#51
post #6

It should have no screen at all and high-quality pushers and displays... or Carplay/Auto because there is no way an old car company like GM can build software properly.

The screen is essentially required by law thanks to backup cameras. I agree that I don't trust any auto manufacturer to make quality software and keep it updated.

Re: GM confirms $130k Cadillac won’t have Apple CarPlay or Android Auto

#52

Earlier quoted context omitted.

This isn't really true except for Rivian and Tesla, which as start ups, wrote their own stack and want to fully control it. GM is moving to Google Automotive and doesn't want to enable Carplay or Android Auto, but Google is already in there deep. No other legacy manufacturers have announced plans to take away Carplay/Android Auto. Quite a few are basing their systems on Android Automotive, though (BMW, Volvo/Polestar…

If a car with Google Automotive has CarPlay, how would Google get data from the iPhone? Is CarPlay not just an interface so your phone can display things on a bigger touchscreen?

At a minimum, it will pull location and anything the drivetrain knows about.

It wouldn't surprise me at all if it also somehow ended up MITM'ing / screen scraping / OCR'ing apple services.

The only solution at this point is legislation.

Re: GM confirms $130k Cadillac won’t have Apple CarPlay or Android Auto

#54
Hope you don't have to enter your Spotify account/password on the car screen to just listen music. I already have in my phone all my service and account, I don't want to relogin on everything on TV or car screen. I don't care about smart TV since a have a Chromecast.

Re: GM confirms $130k Cadillac won’t have Apple CarPlay or Android Auto

#55
post #12

This sounds like someone is trying to empire build at GM to create their own version of carplay so they can be promoted.

Imagine the pleasure in 3-4 years when your 130k car plays an advert on the main screen whenever you start your car, a "feature" that can only be disabled if you pay for the 20$/month premium GM+ package that includes GPS map updates and unlocks the sunroof.

[deleted]

Re: GM confirms $130k Cadillac won’t have Apple CarPlay or Android Auto

#56
post #39

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It's honestly insane. CarPlay does everything I want and the best part is it just works. A large part of that "it just works" is the fact that it's all based directly on my phone. * That restaurant we just decided to go to. Already in navigation. AND! the maps are all current with road closures/traffic issues. * The music that I was playing, it just keeps going * The garage door opener/lock/etc that I just added to H…

> It's honestly insane. CarPlay does everything I want and the best part is it just works. A large part of that "it just works" is the fact that it's all based directly on my phone. The insanity goes both ways: I refuse to use a cellphone, so I will not buy a car that has Android or Apple stuff. Hopefully I'll have other options than this $130k Cadillac, but it's good to know some automakers cater to my preferences t…

> I refuse to use a cellphone

Like at all? That immediately puts you in a pretty niche category.

Re: GM confirms $130k Cadillac won’t have Apple CarPlay or Android Auto

#57
post #37

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Darn. I got excited for a moment thinking that a major car manufacturer was selling a car that didn't have any infotainment features at all. Oh well.

Why wouldn't you want any infotainment features? Surely it's a positive if done well.

It's not something I would ever use, so I don't want to have to pay for it. Its presence also implies that there are other things present that I actively object to, such as a touch screen interface and internet connectivity.

Re: GM confirms $130k Cadillac won’t have Apple CarPlay or Android Auto

#58

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It is even worse than that - the CEO has this pipe dream that they are going to build a Netflix sized subscription business: https://techcrunch.com/2021/10/06/gm-aims-to-build-netflix-s...

OnStar's been around so long, and people value it enough, that it's unreasonable to sneer about pipedreams. Once you throw in Tesla-like subs for automation, etc., it's reasonable to make that a goal for 2030.

Does OnStar have that many paying subscribers? I know the cars come with X years of free service but are they really getting that many takers for years X+1 and beyond?

Re: GM confirms $130k Cadillac won’t have Apple CarPlay or Android Auto

#59
I just got a Rivian R1S and lack of CarPlay is by far the worst thing about the car. The built in Spotify app is janky, podcasts and music can’t continue where it left off, built in map seems to only direct me to busy roads. It’s so annoying I’m thinking of selling (for a profit).

Why is this happening? Car executives aren’t stupid, and must realize software is not core to their business. Unless they plan to start selling phones down the line they can never ‘win’ this battle. It’s clearly a huge waste of internal effort.

Does Apple try and take a % of the car sale as a license fee? Even if the fee were $2000 per car… that could be passed on to the car buyer. I would pay $2000 today to get CarPlay into my Rivian.

Re: GM confirms $130k Cadillac won’t have Apple CarPlay or Android Auto

#60

I know some people at GM who work on in car interfaces. I remember asking one a few years ago why people would prefer an in-house solution over Carplay/Android Auto, and the answer I got was that there's a solid chance people won't. Guess we're about to find out.

The big downside to me with CarPlay/Auto is that it doesn't leverage screen real estate properly. At least not yet. I end up with CarPlay/Auto on the main entertainment screen but with the manufacturer's system on the HUD and main cockpit screen - which I'd rather look at.
Post reply on HN