Live data from Hacker News

Human Or Not: Guess if you're chatting with an AI or a Human

app.humanornot.ai

51–60 of 62 posts

Re: Human Or Not: Guess if you're chatting with an AI or a Human

#53
post #14

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I think it’s very easy for a human to lie and behave like a chatbot. And the only defence against that is the incentive for both parties to focus on testing each other efficiently.

100%. Of 7 games I played, 4 were bots and only once did a bot not use strictly correct capitalization and punctuation.

That is kind of interesting, I got a batch of bots at first that were using correct capitalization and punctuation and then later got a batch of bots that composed like teenagers including typos.

Re: Human Or Not: Guess if you're chatting with an AI or a Human

#56

That web site is great fun! I went 2 for 2. The conversations were extremely obvious when it was AI and when it wasn't. I wonder why the site will become unavailable after 6/28/2023? Seems odd it would simply disappear after only a day or two.

My hypothesis: it's a kind of performance art... All AI responses, with your score given randomly with a win probability of two-thirds.

Re: Human Or Not: Guess if you're chatting with an AI or a Human

#59
post #45

"something" went wrong? why lie and pretend you are surprised by what happened? it's your censorship filter going haywire, just admit it

This is unfairly downvoted. The site bans people who use rude words (I tested the n-word and the r-word). This is bad because the ability to use slurs is a fundamental difference between humans and AIs, which are trained to avoid inappropriate language. If the point of the game is to suss out the difference between AIs and humans, you shouldn't ban language that distinguishes AIs from humans. And you certainly should…

[deleted]

Re: Human Or Not: Guess if you're chatting with an AI or a Human

#60
post #45

"something" went wrong? why lie and pretend you are surprised by what happened? it's your censorship filter going haywire, just admit it

This is unfairly downvoted. The site bans people who use rude words (I tested the n-word and the r-word). This is bad because the ability to use slurs is a fundamental difference between humans and AIs, which are trained to avoid inappropriate language. If the point of the game is to suss out the difference between AIs and humans, you shouldn't ban language that distinguishes AIs from humans. And you certainly should…

Thanks for putting it far more eloquently than I did.
Post reply on HN