Live data from Hacker News

Ask HN: Why are there no 5G USB-C dongles for laptops?

news.ycombinator.com

51–60 of 75 posts

Re: Ask HN: Why are there no 5G USB-C dongles for laptops?

#51
post #8

Good question. Not sure why it’s like this. Perhaps wifi is ubiquitous enough that most people don’t care…? My preferred solution: I carry a small 4g router (TP-Link M7350) in my backpack. Extremely useful when working in places that lack wifi (e.g. some coffee shops etc). The battery lasts very long.

Probably a combination of (relative) WiFi ubiquity, the ability to use a phone as a hotspot in many cases, and as soon as you're using cellular on a different device you're talking about a subscription of some sort. I don't use cellular other than on my phone enough to even activate cellular on a couple of other devices of mine that have a cellular modem.

Re: Ask HN: Why are there no 5G USB-C dongles for laptops?

#52
I think most people with this particular need would prefer a portable hotspot, like the Netgear Nighthawk M5, but they are not cheap as you've found, any 5g android phone can be used in it's place, and so it probably a better alternative in many cases.

Since you're talking about USB, and battery drain, you can probably assume that the phone will use roughly the extra power that is required to do the 5G data transmission and relay to the USB host, and so, if you connect your phone to your computer via USB, and enable internet sharing via USB, you've achieved USB dongle behaviour ?

Re: Ask HN: Why are there no 5G USB-C dongles for laptops?

#55
post #19

GSM dongles simply aren't that popular anymore. Wifi access is near-universal, so the average consumer will pretty much never be without internet access - and their phone is a pretty suitable backup hotspot. The people who do need GSM-based internet - like surveyors or door-to-door people - are probably better served by tablets anyways, and definitely don't want to deal with a USB dongle. If they have to, they'll jus…

Considering that 5G is newer than 4G and all the carriers upgrading to pack their users into 5G, I thought it would be future-prood to get there instead of using 4G. Other than that, I dont really _need_ 5G for bandwidth or anything. I'll check out the 4G options then!

Re: Ask HN: Why are there no 5G USB-C dongles for laptops?

#56
post #36

With MacBooks it's very seamless to connect to your iPhone's hotspot, it just appears in the WiFi menu. It's definitely more convenient than a dongle, as long as you have your phone with you

The seams start to appear when you phone battery is depleted

In which case you connect it via USB, like you would with the dongle

Re: Ask HN: Why are there no 5G USB-C dongles for laptops?

#57
Previously a lot of carrier would lock down the ability to share a phone's internet connection. This was the main reason cellular hotspot devices existed. Nowadays people just use their phone are we're all better off. Would be great if Framework released a module for it though, it's slightly more convenient that connecting through your phone.

Re: Ask HN: Why are there no 5G USB-C dongles for laptops?

#58
post #9

A lot of laptops have a built in 5G modem, or just a slot and antennas for a 5G card that user can install if needed. https://www.delltechnologies.com/asset/en-us/products/laptop... https://www.dell.com/en-us/shop/dell-laptops/latitude-5440-l...

I'm not sure about the "a lot" part... I've never seen it before

Re: Ask HN: Why are there no 5G USB-C dongles for laptops?

#59
post #56
post #36

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The seams start to appear when you phone battery is depleted

In which case you connect it via USB, like you would with the dongle

Connecting your phone with via USB is exactly where the 'seamless' part falls apart. The comparison to dongle is also wrong, I don't use dongle for anything else, so I don't care if its not mobile

Re: Ask HN: Why are there no 5G USB-C dongles for laptops?

#60
post #58
post #9

A lot of laptops have a built in 5G modem, or just a slot and antennas for a 5G card that user can install if needed. https://www.delltechnologies.com/asset/en-us/products/laptop... https://www.dell.com/en-us/shop/dell-laptops/latitude-5440-l...

I'm not sure about the "a lot" part... I've never seen it before

All the business series laptops offer it as an option.
Post reply on HN