Live data from Hacker News

Linux-factory: A framework used to create custom Linux Debian operating systems

github.com

51–60 of 88 posts

Re: Linux-factory: A framework used to create custom Linux Debian operating systems

#51

How is this different / better than live-build?

It’s easier to use. It actually uses live-build under the covers, and even supports enabling you to tap into the live build system directly.

A couple of things it supports that live build does not support.

- overlays (basically configuration modules)

- templating

- python hooks

Re: Linux-factory: A framework used to create custom Linux Debian operating systems

#52
post #13

Is there anything that makes it worth to switch from debian live-config scripts ?

- overlays (basically you can separate configuration into separate units)

- templating support

- configuration in yaml files

- it still fully supports live-build support, so it should be super easy to migrate. You just put the live build files in os/lb or in the lb folder of an overlay.

Re: Linux-factory: A framework used to create custom Linux Debian operating systems

#53

default.nix in this repo doesn’t seems to work since it doesn’t include poetry and many other requirements.

Yes, sorry about that. I need to work a bit more on the nix compatibility. Please file an issue on this.

Re: Linux-factory: A framework used to create custom Linux Debian operating systems

#54
post #5

This sounds like something I'd be very interested in, though I'm not sure what it is. It'd be great if I could easily customize Debian (i3, vim, zsh, chrome, etc.) and distribute / share it with others. But I'm not sure what this does and cannot tell even after reading the first few sections of the README.

See also https://www.refracta.org/docs/readme.refractasnapshot.txt

The reason I didn’t use refracta is because I wanted a reproducible approach.

Re: Linux-factory: A framework used to create custom Linux Debian operating systems

#55

This project is a product of 4 years of work, mostly learning the Debian ecosystem. I started with Ubuntu, I’ve tried Arch, I’ve tried Gentoo, but nothing beats the ease of Debian when it comes to custom distributions. Debian was almost built to fork. Their ecosystem is amazing. Their live build tool is super. I built Linux Factory so everyone else can build custom Debian distributions easily without having to know t…

Thanks for tool. Will there be GUIed version in future ? Like Suse had previously ?

Re: Linux-factory: A framework used to create custom Linux Debian operating systems

#56

Hey just noticed all the activity here. I’m the author of Linux factory. I just opened up issues on GitHub so more discussion can happen there.

Congrats and thanks. Not sure people interested in Debian want to contribute to the borg producing copilot and chatgpt based on their work on gh, among other things.

Re: Linux-factory: A framework used to create custom Linux Debian operating systems

#57

Alternatives that support more than just Debian: https://github.com/buildroot/buildroot https://github.com/skiffos/SkiffOS (Based on buildroot) https://www.yoctoproject.org/

these are for embedded boards though

Does that mean it can't be used for desktop PCs? I remember using it in the past but on a vm.

Re: Linux-factory: A framework used to create custom Linux Debian operating systems

#59
post #34

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I use arch btw. It’s better because we the arch users say so. I’m an arch user btw.

That's not arguing in good faith. Here's a simple example: you want hyprland, patheon and interception-caps2esc on ubuntu? Good luck! On arch, it's just a pacman away. You don't like how arch is perceived as elitist? Use manjaro. Ubuntu had its place in the last century, but with most development happening on git you need a rolling release.

It’s not funny if you have to explain it but it was mostly a joke, without rolling eyes. Also making fun a bit about how easy it is to make a claim that something is better than another thing and leave it at that, which is very common in every population but in particular something you hear from the arch one. I use Arch btw.

Re: Linux-factory: A framework used to create custom Linux Debian operating systems

#60
post #38

There are a ton of Debian system build tools out there and people keep making new ones: https://wiki.debian.org/SystemBuildTools

There's nothing wrong with making new tools. I love making my own tools, both physical tools and software tools.

The feeling you get from it is great! Plus, this is often how new things (or ways to do things) are discovered.

Post reply on HN