Live data from Hacker News

Amazon Closing AmazonSmile

aboutamazon.com

51–60 of 581 posts

Re: Amazon Closing AmazonSmile

#51
This is horrendous and is going to take away huge amounts of money from charities that rely on it.

Charities that customers care about, not Amazon executives.

The charity I support is the ASPCA, which gets significant funding from Smile and it’s going to translate directly into fewer animals getting care.

Shitty.

Re: Amazon Closing AmazonSmile

#52

> All US charities have received $400,026,236.70 as of December 2022. $400 million in donations to charities and Amazon has the gall to say "the program has not grown to create the impact that we had originally hoped."

Absolute peak corpo-speak. I think I can translate: > We don't want to send smaller amounts of money to a huge amount of charities chosen by users, since some users likely chose charities that we do not support. It also doesn't allow us to print out those huge oversized checks for photo ops. We will continue to give a bare pittance out to a small number of organizations selected for peak public relations points while…

wow. are you looking for a gig? i have some public facing pages that i need rewritten. you sound perfect! ;-)

Re: Amazon Closing AmazonSmile

#54
post #21
post #17

Earlier quoted context omitted.

One million eligible recipients around the world, according to Amazon, so $400 per recipient over the decade the program has existed.

That's the average, sure, but since Amazon allows each customer to pick a charity, I imagine some charities got a lot more, and some a lot less. According to my account page, I've generated $100.71 for the charity I selected, and, overall, they've received $273.64 as a part of the program. So I guess the charity I selected wasn't all that popular. But I expect other, more mainstream charities, were.

We give to the Southern Poverty Law Center, who according to the app have received $315k up to Nov 2022.

Sad to see this program go.

Re: Amazon Closing AmazonSmile

#55
This honestly might be a net good if everyone complaining buys less plastic junk on Amazon as a result. To me the program always felt like a lot of recycling: a way to make people feel better about unsustainable overconsumption.

Re: Amazon Closing AmazonSmile

#59

> All US charities have received $400,026,236.70 as of December 2022. $400 million in donations to charities and Amazon has the gall to say "the program has not grown to create the impact that we had originally hoped."

Absolute peak corpo-speak. I think I can translate: > We don't want to send smaller amounts of money to a huge amount of charities chosen by users, since some users likely chose charities that we do not support. It also doesn't allow us to print out those huge oversized checks for photo ops. We will continue to give a bare pittance out to a small number of organizations selected for peak public relations points while…

I asked ChatGPT to translate your paragraph back to positive sounding corporate speak:

> We are committed to being strategic and efficient with our charitable giving by focusing on a select number of organizations that align with our values and support our business objectives. This approach allows us to make a meaningful impact and gain positive visibility through high-impact initiatives and partnerships. Additionally, it maximizes the benefits of our charitable investments, including cost savings and tax advantages.

Re: Amazon Closing AmazonSmile

#60

While it's sad to see this program close, I feel like backlash isn't the answer. How are companies supposed to create beneficial programs like this if they know they're expected to keep it forever?

By starting a program and saying "for the next x amount of time, this is what we're doing".
Post reply on HN