Live data from Hacker News

GitHub stars won't pay your rent (2020)

kitze.io

51–60 of 251 posts

Re: GitHub stars won't pay your rent (2020)

#51
post #46
post #34

Earlier quoted context omitted.

A lot of people and companies are making money from Linux, including Linus Torvalds and many kernel hackers. Linux is GPL’d. I think it is hard to make the claim that making money is antithetical to FOSS.

This is quite the definition of an outlier.

“Antithetical” is a normative, not a descriptive statement. The fact that a high-profile FOSS counterexample exists is in contradiction with it.

Re: GitHub stars won't pay your rent (2020)

#52

> it made 93$ in 2.5 years > When was the last time you chose a value above 1$ > you're a saint for choosing 2.5$ > OMFG THIS SHIRT IS 20$ For the record: the dollar sign comes before the number. I'll take the downvotes, I just can't stand it. I did read the article, and my heart goes out to the author.

That convention is regional and, increasingly in the US, generational.

Re: GitHub stars won't pay your rent (2020)

#53
post #47
post #40

Imagine for a moment though, if GitHub stars could pay your rent. Imagine a corporation spends money on an experiment where they purchase some luxury units of a fancy apartment building, and then rent was decided based on GitHub stars. You must collect a certain number of GitHub stars each month to satisfy rent or you get evicted. I wonder what kind of projects would come out of this.

A method to artificially pump up the GitHub star count will be found, but little useful software will be made.

It would perhaps be called "starhacking" or "repoCD"

Re: GitHub stars won't pay your rent (2020)

#54
post #40

Imagine for a moment though, if GitHub stars could pay your rent. Imagine a corporation spends money on an experiment where they purchase some luxury units of a fancy apartment building, and then rent was decided based on GitHub stars. You must collect a certain number of GitHub stars each month to satisfy rent or you get evicted. I wonder what kind of projects would come out of this.

That idea sort of proves that Github has evolved into a popularity contest/social platform. It use to be a git hosting company.

Re: GitHub stars won't pay your rent (2020)

#55
May I ask: let's say I am Joe Schmoe, an individual, not a corporation. But I have a particular need for coding done in, say, AutoHotKey or as an Outlook macro. I wish to pay someone for this small coding project. What is the best forum to do this exchange?

I'm assuming this question would be on-topic to this thread because it is essentially, "If someone DOES want to help you to pay your rent, or at least for a week's worth of coffee, where's the best place for that?"

Re: GitHub stars won't pay your rent (2020)

#57
post #42
post #37

Earlier quoted context omitted.

From the link: But it is MIT, can't I use it for free? Yes all projects are under MIT so the community backing honesty system can be ignored and Fody used for free. Do I need to be a Patron to contribute a Pull Request? Yes. Users must be a Patron to be a user of Fody. Contributing Pull Requests does not cancel this out. It may seem unfair to expect people both contribute PRs and also financially back this project. H…

> Many developers can afford $36 a year You realize that my dependency stack contains about 2500 dependencies right? If they all follow this model I’m looking at $90k/year just to contribute to a project.

? What contribution are you imagining that involves a PR to all 2500 projects?

Re: GitHub stars won't pay your rent (2020)

#58

May I ask: let's say I am Joe Schmoe, an individual, not a corporation. But I have a particular need for coding done in, say, AutoHotKey or as an Outlook macro. I wish to pay someone for this small coding project. What is the best forum to do this exchange? I'm assuming this question would be on-topic to this thread because it is essentially, "If someone DOES want to help you to pay your rent, or at least for a week'…

Fiverr, but make sure to separate wheat from the chaff.

Re: GitHub stars won't pay your rent (2020)

#60
post #52

> it made 93$ in 2.5 years > When was the last time you chose a value above 1$ > you're a saint for choosing 2.5$ > OMFG THIS SHIRT IS 20$ For the record: the dollar sign comes before the number. I'll take the downvotes, I just can't stand it. I did read the article, and my heart goes out to the author.

That convention is regional and, increasingly in the US, generational.

Wikipedia:

> In the United States, Mexico, Australia, Argentina, New Zealand, Hong Kong, Pacific Island nations, and English-speaking Canada, the sign is written before the number ("$5"), even though the word is written or spoken after it ("five dollars", "cinco pesos"). In French-speaking Canada, exceptionally, the dollar symbol usually appears after the number, e.g., "5$".

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dollar_sign#Prefix_or_suffix

The linked article appears to be talking about U.S. dollars, and all evidence points to it being written in English, so I don't believe the regional usage is relevant.

It's hard to argue what the accepted usage will be in future generations, but using the dollar sign as a suffix does not appear to have become accepted by any institutions I'm aware of at the moment. Distinguishing a simple mistake from a visionary act of linguistic prophecy is beyond my capabilities.

If you can point me at a reference that makes a good case that the linked article is the accepted usage, I'd be obliged.

Post reply on HN