Live data from Hacker News

Demo of =GPT3() as a spreadsheet feature

twitter.com

51–60 of 149 posts

Re: Demo of =GPT3() as a spreadsheet feature

#51
post #5

From one of the replies: “This is awesome. I also love how 20% of the zip codes are wrong. Messy AI future seems really fun and chaotic.”

>I also love how 20% of the zip codes are wrong.

Only they aren't. Check the video again, they come out fine.

Edit: Oh dang, you're all right, several of them have wrong digits. :l

Re: Demo of =GPT3() as a spreadsheet feature

#52

51s -- "We are truly grateful", says the heartfelt thankyou card that was written by an algorithm in a spreadsheet.

If people want to put this sort of language in a thank-you note, I guess... I dunno, it always comes off as inauthentic to me, so I don't really care if I got mass produced or artisanal hand-crafted lies.

Re: Demo of =GPT3() as a spreadsheet feature

#53

The amount of 90% sensible, 10% ridiculously wrong computer generated crap we’re about to send into real humans’ brains makes my head spin. There’s truly an awful AI Winter ahead and it consists of spending a substantial amount of your best brain cycles on figuring out whether a real person wrote that thing to you (and it’s worth figuring out what they meant in case of some weird wording) or it was a computer generat…

[deleted]

Re: Demo of =GPT3() as a spreadsheet feature

#54

The amount of 90% sensible, 10% ridiculously wrong computer generated crap we’re about to send into real humans’ brains makes my head spin. There’s truly an awful AI Winter ahead and it consists of spending a substantial amount of your best brain cycles on figuring out whether a real person wrote that thing to you (and it’s worth figuring out what they meant in case of some weird wording) or it was a computer generat…

Probably closer to a Butlerian Jihad than a AI winter as per se, assuming something dramatic does happen

Re: Demo of =GPT3() as a spreadsheet feature

#55
post #5

From one of the replies: “This is awesome. I also love how 20% of the zip codes are wrong. Messy AI future seems really fun and chaotic.”

>I also love how 20% of the zip codes are wrong. Only they aren't. Check the video again, they come out fine. Edit: Oh dang, you're all right, several of them have wrong digits. :l

What are you talking about? Look at 27 seconds into the video. Many of the zip codes are wrong.

Re: Demo of =GPT3() as a spreadsheet feature

#56
post #46

Do I understand that correctly? When I have to create a spreadsheet like this, there are 2 options. Option 1 I write a table zipcode to state and use this table to generate my column. If I carefully check my table my spreadsheet would be okay. Option 2 I ask GPT3 to do my work. But I have to check the whole spreadsheet for errors.

[deleted]

Re: Demo of =GPT3() as a spreadsheet feature

#57
post #34

Now wait for =deep_dream() or maybe =stable_diffusion() as a graph-generating function! (Graphs plotted with this function will of course zoom in infinitely but the further you go the more eyes and shiba dogs you'll notice in the corners ...)

Plots that devolve into madness as if you zoom in too close? Finally the programmers get to experience electronics class.

Re: Demo of =GPT3() as a spreadsheet feature

#58
post #36
post #19

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It depends on how people use the tools. For example the thank you note one -- if someone just prints off the output of this and sends it, yeah, that's bad. But if someone uses this to do 90% of the work and then just edits it to make it personal and sound like themselves, then it's just a great time saving tool. I mean, in this exact example, 70 years ago you'd have to hand address each thank you card by hand from sc…

> But if someone uses this to do 90% of the work and then just edits it to make it personal and sound like themselves, then it's just a great time saving tool. This is still way too optimistic. Reading through something that's "almost right", seeing the errors when you already basically know what it says / what it's meant to say, and fixing them, is hard. People won't do it well, and so even in this scenario we often…

Gmail's autocomplete already works great for this, and it will only get better over time. The key is to have a human in the loop to decide whether to accept/edit on a phrase by phrase or sentence by sentence basis.

Re: Demo of =GPT3() as a spreadsheet feature

#59

Earlier quoted context omitted.

What about subtle formatting differences (Country, Territory, Postal code is the norm. Doesn't have to be.). What if we applied this to hand written addresses? (Adding an OCR component). I'm sure the USPS is already doing this and more, and if not, there's probably some AI jobs lined up for it :)

Yes, USPS has Remote Encoding Centers (REC) to handle handwritten address that can't be recognized with OCR. So AI is already there, just that humans are for harder and tedious jobs ;-)

> So AI is already there, just that humans are for harder and tedious jobs ;-)

Increasingly less so ;-)

Re: Demo of =GPT3() as a spreadsheet feature

#60
I said it before: we need Copilot flash fill. Infer what the user wants the output to be from patterns and labels, so they can enter a few examples and then “extend” and automatically do the equivalent of a complex formula. e.g.

    Formal          | Informal
    Lane, Thomas    | Tommy Lane
    Brooks, Sarah   | Sarah Brooks
    Yun, Christopher |
    Doe, Kaitlyn    |
    Styles, Chris   |
    …
Automating something like this is extremely hard with an algorithm and extremely easy with ML. Even better, many people who use spreadsheets aren’t very familiar with coding and software, so they do things manually even in cases where the formula is simple.
Post reply on HN