Live data from Hacker News

CD Projekt is remaking the first Witcher game in Unreal Engine 5

gamedeveloper.com

51–60 of 228 posts

Re: CD Projekt is remaking the first Witcher game in Unreal Engine 5

#51
> With the game being rebuilt in Unreal Engine 5, Fool's Theory will also have plenty of opportunity to revisit the somewhat clunky combat mechanics of the first game

Hopefully they will revisit them just long enough to throw them in the trash and implement an entirely different combat system than the bad ones they had in Witcher 1.

Re: CD Projekt is remaking the first Witcher game in Unreal Engine 5

#52
post #13
post #7

I couldn't get myself to play the first 2 Witcher games due to the dated mechanics but I watched other people stream their play throughs at the time. > [removed] the playing cards players can earn that depict pinup art of Geralt's various sexual partners. The system has been criticized over the years for treating women's bodies as a reward for player progression. This pin-up card collection of your sex partners was e…

I'm not sure "laundering reputation" is how I would frame "re-evaluating including potentially objectionable content in a remake".

The reason I would frame it that way is because CD Projekt has subsequently had a fall from grace and are on thin ice regarding PR attack vectors

Re: CD Projekt is remaking the first Witcher game in Unreal Engine 5

#53
I get the feeling that a lot of these game remakes are sort of IP normalization moves. Get all the studio's IP onto standard modern tools so that new game devs won't be surprised by custom engines to make maintenance and rerelease easier, especially as the studio transitions from a small boutique studio to a bog-standard AAA sweatshop.

I also think this is the reason for Naughty Dog rereleasing The Last of Us on PS5. Though the engine itself was written in C++, it used a lot of Scheme code to generate game data and components and I think they want to move off that because it's baffling to the new devs they want to onboard.

I'm waiting for Id Software to throw in the towel and rerelease Unreal versions of Doom (2016) and Doom Eternal.

Re: CD Projekt is remaking the first Witcher game in Unreal Engine 5

#54
post #12

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The GTA remaster issues were hardly due to the engine. People over-focus on the engine. I wouldn't worry about this.

The graphics look plastic. Is it not because of an engine? Serious question.

It's hard to know for sure but most people believe they did a ton of either super rushed manual work and/or AI upscaling on the textures and models that would explain the "plastic" look to everything. It doesn't really matter what engine is backing it if the textures and modeling are bad. And if they didn't spend the time to sort out material properties then the engine won't treat skin any differently than cloth, or cloth differently than metal, etc.

these are more examples of modelling issues but it shows how little care and QA went into the remake:

they rounded out this 6-sided nut : https://old.reddit.com/r/GTA/comments/quutz7/definitive_lazy...

hot dog fingers: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qQWw0hHMUoc

Re: CD Projekt is remaking the first Witcher game in Unreal Engine 5

#55
post #7

I couldn't get myself to play the first 2 Witcher games due to the dated mechanics but I watched other people stream their play throughs at the time. > [removed] the playing cards players can earn that depict pinup art of Geralt's various sexual partners. The system has been criticized over the years for treating women's bodies as a reward for player progression. This pin-up card collection of your sex partners was e…

Meh. Steam's got a billion games now that do that exact thing. Tons and tons of games did before it, too. The only notable thing about it was having that kind of thing in a game that was otherwise good enough and had enough else going on not to be categorized primarily as a porn game.

I'll just wait for it to be modded back in.

[EDIT] Actually a few other mainstream non-porn games have done almost the same thing, since, too. The Saboteur comes to mind. Some whole series are all about that sort of thing, like DOA.

Re: CD Projekt is remaking the first Witcher game in Unreal Engine 5

#56
post #7

I couldn't get myself to play the first 2 Witcher games due to the dated mechanics but I watched other people stream their play throughs at the time. > [removed] the playing cards players can earn that depict pinup art of Geralt's various sexual partners. The system has been criticized over the years for treating women's bodies as a reward for player progression. This pin-up card collection of your sex partners was e…

I played the Witcher when it was released back in the day; I had heard some vaguely good things about it, and it seemed like something I would enjoy. I had no idea the card thing existed until I actually received one. I remember laughing at how silly it was. I felt it kinda fit within the kind of semi-serious adult theme of the game; "your mother sucks dwarven cock" etc. From what I recall, the second game was a bit more serious; never played the third one.

I think the cards had basically nothing to do with the game success, and judging from the comments here, it seems the first game wasn't even all that successful in the first place.

Re: CD Projekt is remaking the first Witcher game in Unreal Engine 5

#57
post #21

> Now we know that it's a ground-up remake of the game that introduced Geralt of Rivia to Witcher fans outside of Poland. I was always of the impression that it was Witcher III that achieved this. I'm Polish so I genuinely don't know. Were the previous two installments popular outside of Poland?

The Witcher 1 had a relatively large cult following for such an obscure game. The Witcher 2 took it to the next level.

Re: CD Projekt is remaking the first Witcher game in Unreal Engine 5

#58
post #21

> Now we know that it's a ground-up remake of the game that introduced Geralt of Rivia to Witcher fans outside of Poland. I was always of the impression that it was Witcher III that achieved this. I'm Polish so I genuinely don't know. Were the previous two installments popular outside of Poland?

> Were the previous two installments popular outside of Poland? Witcher 2 was the first time I heard of the franchise.

Heavy gamer here. I heard of the first Witcher but didn't think to play it until after I tried The Witcher 2: Assassins of Kings, which is still my favorite game in the series.

Re: CD Projekt is remaking the first Witcher game in Unreal Engine 5

#60
post #7

I couldn't get myself to play the first 2 Witcher games due to the dated mechanics but I watched other people stream their play throughs at the time. > [removed] the playing cards players can earn that depict pinup art of Geralt's various sexual partners. The system has been criticized over the years for treating women's bodies as a reward for player progression. This pin-up card collection of your sex partners was e…

I played the Witcher when it was released back in the day; I had heard some vaguely good things about it, and it seemed like something I would enjoy. I had no idea the card thing existed until I actually received one. I remember laughing at how silly it was. I felt it kinda fit within the kind of semi-serious adult theme of the game; "your mother sucks dwarven cock" etc. From what I recall, the second game was a bit…

They just replaced it with 3D sex scenes in the later ones, AFAIK. But for some reason that was OK, while fade-to-black and a pinup wasn't? It's weird.
Post reply on HN