Live data from Hacker News

Google cracks down on VPN based adblockers

community.blokada.org

51–60 of 608 posts

Re: Google cracks down on VPN based adblockers

#51

Wouldn’t favour the growth of alternative app stores? Upcoming European legislation is forcing eve Apple to allow third party stores on iPhones. I doubt Google would get away much longer with those practices.

Third party app stores have always been allowed on Android.

Re: Google cracks down on VPN based adblockers

#52
post #16

There is a legitimate problem with malware that hijacks all traffic via VPN. Maybe you should hear other side before making judgement!

> There is a legitimate problem with malware that hijacks all traffic via VPN

Facebook comes to mind: https://hn.algolia.com/?query=onavo

Re: Google cracks down on VPN based adblockers

#53
post #16

There is a legitimate problem with malware that hijacks all traffic via VPN. Maybe you should hear other side before making judgement!

Ok, so using the same logic we should ban all car traffic because someone was raped in a taxi?

No, this is more like taxi drivers complaining about extra regulations, put on place, bcos someone got raped in taxi.

Re: Google cracks down on VPN based adblockers

#54

Firefox for Android with ublock origin makes my mobile web browsing sane again. Highly recommended.

The experience is so awful when I browse on my iPad, instead of my Android phone with Firefox+UBlock. I really don't understand how most people can stand to browse with all the ads. The modern web is so much worse than the pop up ads of the old web.

Others already mention adblockers exist for iOS. This is possible because Safari on iOS has support for declarative blocking (the inferior API compared to programmatically deciding what to block).

https://developer.apple.com/documentation/safariservices/cre...

Initial content blocker support came with iOS 9 in 2015. They only work in Safari, maybe also other browsers (not sure though).

Re: Google cracks down on VPN based adblockers

#55
post #49

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Apple allows ad-blocking filters that are basically Safari extensions but must be downloaded through a separate app. I can’t recommend any specific ad-blocked though. https://support.apple.com/guide/iphone/get-extensions-iphab0... The usual VPN and DNS solutions also work fine.

I have had a very good experience with 1Blocker so far. Not quite ublock origin but close enough that I almost never notice a difference from my daily desktop use. There is another extension called Vinegar that strips out YouTube ads, but unfortunately it only works with Safari on iOS and not Firefox (even though both are using the same core engine) so I need to remember to bounce over to Safari when watching YouTube…

Vinegar works with Safari on macOS too. I love it, switches YouTube over to the native video player, strips all the recommendations and other crap and only plays the video

Re: Google cracks down on VPN based adblockers

#56

Going on a tangent, how is the adblocking story on iOS? As there is not Firefox+uBlock available, is it possible to block ads via VPN or DNS?

> is it possible to block ads via VPN

1Blocker¹ does it. It’s the “Firewall” section of the iOS app.

¹ https://1blocker.com

Re: Google cracks down on VPN based adblockers

#57

Root access and AdAway from F-Droid. I wouldn't even bother using anything else.

Same, but it is more and more annoying to root your phone with all these banking apps blocking rooted phones. And now, with the new security standards (which are good), banks insist on having you install their proprietary app just to authorize payments (which is annoying). I am not talking about Google Pay here (which I can do without).

There are workarounds of course, but I am becoming tired of the cat and mouse game, in fact, I am tired of smartphones altogether. Unless things change, my current phone is probably the last rooted phone I will use as a daily driver, sadly, the last "high end" phone too.

Re: Google cracks down on VPN based adblockers

#59
post #46

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The experience is so awful when I browse on my iPad, instead of my Android phone with Firefox+UBlock. I really don't understand how most people can stand to browse with all the ads. The modern web is so much worse than the pop up ads of the old web.

What's wrong with Firefox Focus as a Safari content blocker? I barely see ads on my iPhone and websites breaking because I have an ad blocker is more common than seeing ads.

I've never knowingly encountered a website breaking because I have an adblocker, but I've being running adblockers of one sort or another for about as long as there's been ads on the web - so maybe there's just features I don't know I should experience.

Can you give an example of a website that breaks with an adblocker? (Please describe what breaks as well. Otherwise I might not notice it.)

Post reply on HN