Live data from Hacker News

Cunningham's Law

meta.wikimedia.org

51–60 of 79 posts

Re: Cunningham's Law

#51
post #39

Please don't editorialize titles. It's against the site guidelines: " Please use the original title, unless it is misleading or linkbait; don't editorialize. " - https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html (Submitted title was "Someone Is Wrong on the Internet".)

Sorry. I didn't know that rule when I posted the link. Thanks for correcting me.

Re: Cunningham's Law

#52
post #41

I noticed a similar thing with my own young kids: if someone asked them a question and they weren't answering out of shyness, the the surest way to get them to respond would be to suggest a wrong answer, at which point they couldn't help but correct you (which was generally enough to break the ice).

Ha ha yes this is great. To get my daughter to snap out of crying at night when she needs to go to bed I name her fluffy toys incorrectly. She immediately forgets her worries to correct me. So much fun. (Here, hug this big - handing her a koala).

pig

Re: Cunningham's Law

#53
Whenever I join a new team and need to inhale a new architecture or complex process, I take a stab at documenting what currently exists, and then share my notes with the team. Corrections immediately pour in, and this "wrong answer" inevitably produces a much better end result than asking any single person to tell me the "right answer".

Re: Cunningham's Law

#54

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I wasn't aware you could block in-app ads. (Thanks for the heads-up!) That may be a primary reason that many don't block these ads. Browser adblockers are relatively well known, and relatively popular, but I don't think that's true of blocking in-app ads. For in-app, there's also the tech hurdle. Now that I know there's a method, I'm tech savvy enough to search it out an implement it, but there's going to be a much h…

Many games will allow users to do something advantageous by watching an ad. If they are blocked, then this will not work. I've seen these fail when the device cannot connect to the network or other causes of timeouts, but they are smart enough to know this and not give you the reward.

> Many games will allow users to do something advantageous by watching an ad.

That's… horrifying.

Why would you want to play a game that treats you like that? I mean, is it fun? I suppose some people must enjoy window-shopping, and I guess this is like that, but… I just can't imagine hoping to see an advert — it feels really manipulative and sinister.

Re: Cunningham's Law

#55
This might be controversial, but I honestly think it's important to recognise and counteract his in content moderation. When people deliberately give bad info they should be banned, and posters in good standing who exercise insufficient caution and feed the trolls must be reprimanded.

If you allow people to troll a help forum or bug tracker with low-grade content, you will soon be overrun with low-quality information, and that will make the search function in your forum useless, leading to a cascade of more low-quality questions.

I know reprimanding people for answering badly phrased questions or clear trolling is not something many people want to do because they want to be beginner friendly, but harsh penalties for deliberate disinformation should be the norm. Punishing people for falling for this would at least starve the trolls of oxygen.

Re: Cunningham's Law

#56

A sort of interesting "corollary" to this is something I've noticed in mobile games with in-app ads for other mobile games: The best way to attract a player isn't by showing them someone playing well, it's by showing them someone playing very bad Because these ads show demo play (usually of puzzles) where the player is making obviously bad decisions, and watching it is sort of like seeing a dozen objects in a row, bu…

Man, I just don't understand people who don't use ad blocking[1]. You just wrote a whole post analyzing how you are being manipulated, causing you to feel "uneasy", "impatient", so that you almost do things that are "awful and tedious". Why do people live like this? [1] You can block ads in mobile games with a proxy that takes less than a minute to set up, at least on Android.

I may not like the ads, but I like that they pay for a lot of cool stuff on the web that otherwise would not see the light of day.

Re: Cunningham's Law

#57

Whenever I join a new team and need to inhale a new architecture or complex process, I take a stab at documenting what currently exists, and then share my notes with the team. Corrections immediately pour in, and this "wrong answer" inevitably produces a much better end result than asking any single person to tell me the "right answer".

That's a really clever strategy and so obvious that now I'm feeling guilty of not thinking it out myself earlier. Thanks a lot.

Re: Cunningham's Law

#59
post #39

Please don't editorialize titles. It's against the site guidelines: " Please use the original title, unless it is misleading or linkbait; don't editorialize. " - https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html (Submitted title was "Someone Is Wrong on the Internet".)

This should probably be noted on the submit page, right next to the title box. Or at least the submit page should have a link to the guidelines.

Re: Cunningham's Law

#60
People are a lot more prone to editing than writing. PR nits, architecture diagrams, product briefs, etc. Everyone will weigh in and hopefully make things better, but very few people are willing to start from a blank canvas.
Post reply on HN