Live data from Hacker News

The Universal Structure of Storytelling

quillette.com

51–54 of 54 posts

Re: The Universal Structure of Storytelling

#51
post #30

Counterpoint argument based on the Japanese/Korean story structure called kishōtenketsu: > The necessity of conflict is preached as a kind of dogma by contemporary writers’ workshops and Internet “guides” to writing. A plot without conflict is considered dull; some even go so far as to call it impossible. This has influenced not only fiction, but writing in general–arguably even philosophy. Yet, is there any truth to…

Thank you for this link! I was looking to an alternative model for so long since the "traditional" confrontational structure is quite tiring, not just for the reader.

I'm trying to write fiction and this article helped me to build a tool box that I can use to decide what a story really needs. I don't have to use a hammer anymore to solve every problem!

Do you maybe have more resources like the one you shared, other than in this thread already?

Re: The Universal Structure of Storytelling

#52
> Stories show us problem-drenched worlds and encourage us to turn on the people who are lousing things up. In other words, to proliferate narratives is to proliferate villains. To proliferate villains is also to proliferate rage, judgment, and division.

I feel this doesn't apply to The Wire or other things I consider good stories, say Terry Pratchett, but does apply to stuff I don't like say 24 or several religious stories. Is it really inherent in storytelling?

Re: The Universal Structure of Storytelling

#53
I first noticed a similar thing in zombie movies, back when they were a bit more traditional (before they got tired and needed remixed).

The 'bad guy' in those stories wasn't the zombie horde (often a fictional stand in for disease or other other non-human dangers), but the selfish character who ruins other people's chances of surviving by being a selfish asshole. By being put in the survival situation, they didn't need to be comic book style villains with lairs and evil plans, they could just be ordinary people put into situations where they could get other people killed via their actions.

Post reply on HN