Live data from Hacker News

AnimeGANv2: Convert Face Portraits into Anime

huggingface.co

51–60 of 66 posts

Re: AnimeGANv2: Convert Face Portraits into Anime

#51
post #26

May be those examples should have instant results? I guess most people are just clicking them to see what it looks likes instead of waiting 100s. Most of them look like photoshop filter as per other comments, but IU and Billie Eilish definitely looks good.

I think it is pretty impressive, and dismissing it a simply a photoshop filter is not right.

While they don't look true anime style, they look properly very cartoonish, like someone would have drawn them.

Good job to the op.

Re: AnimeGANv2: Convert Face Portraits into Anime

#53
Viewing these images remind me a lot of caricature portraiture.

As with real artwork, the eye is drawn to embelishments, exagerations, and simplification and directed by composition.

In pieces by a competant artist, these add a new level of interest and dimension to the piece.

With these images, following what makes each image is always a dead end. There is no composition and the embelishments are mechanical, random and uninteresting.

For example, I find myself wondering why the the artist chose to paint the mouth so asymetrical. Is the artist trying to express an emotion? Who is the subject, and why have the been rendered as they have. It's confusing and a challenge to critique the artwork... until I realize its just bit of randomness generated by algorithm incapable of any creativity beyond how the programmer applied generic and randomizing programming methods.

There isn't and cannot be anything unique to any of the images. Once you've studied any one of them, you've really experienced most of what the programmer/artist has contributed.

Re: AnimeGANv2: Convert Face Portraits into Anime

#54
post #26

May be those examples should have instant results? I guess most people are just clicking them to see what it looks likes instead of waiting 100s. Most of them look like photoshop filter as per other comments, but IU and Billie Eilish definitely looks good.

They don’t look anything like filters it’s actually super impressive just how clean the results are.

Re: AnimeGANv2: Convert Face Portraits into Anime

#55
One big mistake is that this is not anime. This is obviously comic-style, which is more realistic, and, in turn, closer to automated filtering.

Note that Japanese anime normally uses a much simplified style to increase the production speed. This naturally results in a highly distorted(?!) depictions that even humans often find disturbing. This makes anime-style difficult to mimic.

Re: AnimeGANv2: Convert Face Portraits into Anime

#56

Like many other comments, I don't see much resemblance to anime styles, but dismissing the results as a Photoshop filter is nuts. The animation style this does look like is that of 2006's A Scanner Darkly, or 2019's Undone.

> The animation style this does look like is that of 2006's A Scanner Darkly, or 2019's Undone. Rotoscoping is the technique. Basically, you film real life and trace over the frames by hand yielding an animated version of your irl footage.

American Pop is a hidden gem that uses this technique. Fantastic movie.

Re: AnimeGANv2: Convert Face Portraits into Anime

#57

Interesting, you can see how it feminizes faces quite clearly in the examples of Bill Gates and Elon Musk. Gates looks kind of like Ellen DeGeneres to me in the anime version.

This one didn’t do me too bad, but a lot of the “anime filters” I’ve seen will completely feminize my face into an obviously female character despite the facial structure and beard, I assume because I have long hair.

Re: AnimeGANv2: Convert Face Portraits into Anime

#58
I found that it did an awesome job on some photos and messed up some. When it messed up, it generally made mouths look way too distorted. I also thought it was funny that it turned obviously green eyes blue. Overall, I think it is a fun implementation, but it would be much better to have a larger output file.

Re: AnimeGANv2: Convert Face Portraits into Anime

#59

Like many other comments, I don't see much resemblance to anime styles, but dismissing the results as a Photoshop filter is nuts. The animation style this does look like is that of 2006's A Scanner Darkly, or 2019's Undone.

If you've seen what photoshop can do you wouldn't say that's a dismissive statement.

Re: AnimeGANv2: Convert Face Portraits into Anime

#60
post #26

May be those examples should have instant results? I guess most people are just clicking them to see what it looks likes instead of waiting 100s. Most of them look like photoshop filter as per other comments, but IU and Billie Eilish definitely looks good.

People keep stating these look like photoshop filters. This is a very shallow dismissal imo. Why don't you prove it instead by applying some Photoshop filters and achieving a similar effect? Include how long it took as well.

Here's a tutorial I found online that achieves a similar effect in under 15 minutes: https://youtube.com/watch?v=XojsUNBLfic

It takes the presenter about seven minutes to go from "image opened in Photoshop" to "comic-style effect applied to image", and that includes a verbal explanation of each step. (The rest of the video talks about things like making sure the image is an adequate size, and adding extra elements like borders and dialogue balloons.)

Post reply on HN