Live data from Hacker News

DIY Book Scanner

diybookscanner.org

51–60 of 132 posts

Re: DIY Book Scanner

#51

I built one of these out of pine 2x4s and plywood. I thought it would be cheaper than buying one (I was wrong) but I'm also not a skilled woodworker and had to buy most of the tools. It works quite well and I digitised dozens of textbooks I'd purchased and needed to reference but couldn't carry around every day while finishing my masters. My one had 2 Nikon mirrorless cameras controlled via Pi-Scan. https://github.co…

What was the purpose? Did the digitized books go to the public domain/your university, or something, or was it purely for personal research?

Re: DIY Book Scanner

#52

I remember reading about Google's book scanner that operated automatically using vacuum pressure to gently flip pages. I'd love to see an open source variety of that.

Automated page turning is an incredibly complex problem to tackle. It won't gain you as much as you'd think either. "Book" and "page" are a surprisingly difficult to define categories.

If my experience helping to build the diybookscanner.org project taught me anything, it's that picking the low hanging fruit of small efficiency improvements to the (semi-)manual process is so much more effective...

Re: DIY Book Scanner

#53
These kinds of discussions need more real examples to accurately depict the tradeoffs of destructive vs non-destructive scanning, so I'll add scans I personally made.

Here are two pages from Cracking the Coding Interview, 6th Edition, that I preferred over the digital versions I found online that were hard on the eyes because I disliked the black-and-white scans. Feel free to ask me about "details" in the process

https://imgur.com/2ZQFZ5p

It's entirely possible to accomplish post-processing without writing code if you have Adobe Photoshop.

I used a free-to-the-public bookscanner built by the Digital Archivists at Noisebridge in San Francisco to take pictures of all pages in my textbooks (it took a while). In Photoshop, you can record a macro to automatically crop to a rectangular region determined by just one or more points that are guaranteed to be on the page in every photo. The selection is made by the quick selection tool (selects similar pixels to the page color in the same region). With this macro recorded, you can run it in bulk through all files.

The textbook size was still large digitally (a gigabyte) because I wanted the highest quality possible for studying, but it beat having to carry heavy textbooks for sure. I also shared these files with friends and we were able to study without any physical textbooks for books that were not available digitally—it was amazing.

Personally I avoided all the deskewing technologies and preferred just pictures, all in color, as close to the real thing as possible, because Noisebridge's scanner used two DSLRs and the pictures were high quality. It was better than converting everything to black-and-white for reading enjoyability. OCR through ABBYY FineReader.

Overall it gets more annoying the thicker the textbook is. If destructive scanning is acceptable, one can just buy the book, go to FedEx and ask them cut the spine off for $4 to convert it to loose-leaf, then run it through a document scanner such as ScanSnap ix500, which is much faster at around 25 pages/min at its slowest

One really cool feature about Noisebridge's scanner (picture below) was that you could view the camera's viewfinder live in real-time, thereby speeding up iteration and catching errors much faster

https://imgur.com/4Pkdp1j

Re: DIY Book Scanner

#54
post #51

I built one of these out of pine 2x4s and plywood. I thought it would be cheaper than buying one (I was wrong) but I'm also not a skilled woodworker and had to buy most of the tools. It works quite well and I digitised dozens of textbooks I'd purchased and needed to reference but couldn't carry around every day while finishing my masters. My one had 2 Nikon mirrorless cameras controlled via Pi-Scan. https://github.co…

What was the purpose? Did the digitized books go to the public domain/your university, or something, or was it purely for personal research?

Just for personal use as all the books were still in copyright and I own the paper versions, it was a (probably legal) fair use of them purely for reference while studying.

I often needed to find information in the books and couldn't reasonably carry them all with me every day between work and uni.

Re: DIY Book Scanner

#55
At Japan in the meantime, people in book scanning community (that exists) often just cut the book spine and scan the pages using normal scanner, throw it away once all the pages are scanned.

People (rightly) value room spaces than books there. It's called "Ji-sui" (scanning by oneself) and gear recommendation sites like [1] are abundant. Another reason of "Ji-sui" prevalence was the poor availability of ebooks, although that reason was less relevant today.

[1] http://monomania.sblo.jp/article/60578693.html

Re: DIY Book Scanner

#57
post #48
post #45

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Spreads[0] is probably what you are referring to. Some backstory: I saw the diybookscanner community - which at that point mostly had Daniel Reetz [1] as its active contributor- struggle with mechanical contraptions for triggering cameras and very little software experience. I built a simple proof of concept to reliably trigger cheap consumer cameras using software. I built it on CHDK[2], the Canon Hack Development K…

Actually, it was a project called Paper Upgrade. Here is an old archive link: http://web.archive.org/web/20140101000000*/http://www.paperu... I don't know if you can find the code through there, but I'm pretty sure he had made it free. I think spreads is a bit newer. Edit: Found some more info. It did indeed use Scantailor in the backend. His SW was more of a Web based frontend to all the parts. You can see a video d…

Paper Upgrade was an awesome project and the author changed my life. I met my future wife on the plane while flying to visit him and donate a book scanner.

Re: DIY Book Scanner

#58

Hello if anyone is in the Bay Area and has a book scanner I’d love to scan my copy of this book which was only printed in India in 2001 and seems relatively rare: https://www.abebooks.com/9780140298246/Patents-Myths-Reality... I did fill out the form for the internet archive but it talked about scanning a library and I’m not sure they want to deal with just one book.

NoiseBridge maintained a DIY Book Scanner for a long time.

Re: DIY Book Scanner

#59

I built a similar one of these from a kit that Dan Reetz made. (Technology has improved since I built mine.) I have eliminated most printed books. I had to pass a "psychological barrier" before I was able to discard the books I scanned. The last holdout was music scores, but I now use an iPad for music at the piano.

Thanks for buying and building a kit. I appreciated everyone who did that so much.

Re: DIY Book Scanner

#60
post #30

My first job out of college was scanning books for the Internet Archive down in the basement of the Library of Congress. Their scanning machines used a foot pedal to raise and lower the glass Platen, so I'd use one hand to flip the page and wiggle the cradle to get things nice and flat and the other would snap the photo. You can get pretty fast after a while, but boy is it mindless. Older books that had been rebound…

Later on I worked briefly for the Archive. The scanner I designed later became their "ttscribe". It was fascinating to see their process up close.
Post reply on HN