> The site is experiencing higher than normal traffic and we have temporarily halted database creation. Ironic coming from the infinitely scalable database, isn't it?
PlanetScale – Database for Developers
51–60 of 135 posts
Re: PlanetScale – Database for Developers
#52Wondering will we see something like this for Postgres? I like the cool things but I can’t migrate to MySQL just because of this.
Sure you can! and we will make it worth it.
On the one hand, making light of how big an undertaking a _database engine migration_ would be makes you come off sounding like the "mongodb is web scale" guy. That's a pretty terrible look for a company proposing to take on critical production infrastructure.
On the other hand, adding postgresql support to vitess is probably a _massive_ undertaking. Sure, it might make sense for you to contribute to in the long run to open up that customer segment, but at your current stage postgresql customers are probably more of a product-distraction than anything. In that light, driving us away for now is probably the best policy.
I'm gonna give you the benefit of the doubt. Well played, sir. Well played.
EDIT: nevermind, all your other comments so far in this thread are variations on "Yes, we can do that!". You're promising the moon, and that's fishy.
Bit of unsolicited advice (you know what they say about unsolicited advice, but here goes...): You'd be better off admitting some weaknesses and discussing tradeoffs. For examples, take a look at other HN threads where execs have hopped on. What qualities do you seen in posts that get the most positive responses? Now compare that to the confusion and skepticism in this thread. Your messaging has landed off-target.
You're proposing to take over a piece of people's critical production infrastructure. As a potential buyer considering an infrastructure provider, seeing "buy our product and we'll solve all your problems" just makes me skeptical. It makes you sound like a used car salesman. Your landing page delivers that basic message, and your comments in this thread reinforce the resulting impression.
Conversely, if in these comments you soberly acknowledged your limitations, transitioned to a detailed treatment about tradeoffs, and _then_ used that save to toot your horn some more, that would give the impression you've considered this problem deeply, help me figure out how closely your value prop is aligned to my goals, and make me more inclined to trust you, your company, and your product.
As it is...
I see your comment and it makes me think your company isn't ready to take on my infrastructure (this is my database we're talking about here... if you're not taking something as basic as migration costs seriously, what other nasty surprises are waiting for me down the line?).
Then, I take a look at your about page (maybe this guy's just an entry-level marketer in the people-pleaser phase), and I see that you, Sam Lambert, are the Chief Product Officer. That gives me some serious doubts about the future viability of your company, because now I'm worried the CPO is fundamentally out of touch with the userbase and can't grapple with difficult details.
You will not be touching my data any time soon, but I'll be watching for changes, and I honestly wish you luck. I like your vision, but your messaging execution needs work and your product execution is yet-unproven.
EDIT: kudos to lizztheblizz for giving more detailed answers that inspire confidence. You've significantly repaired my impressions of your company.
Re: PlanetScale – Database for Developers
#53> Developers want the durability, stability, and scalability of a SQL database but do not want to be constrained by managing a schema. It has been our goal to give both, not compromising on the power of your datastore but making changes feel as easy as deploying code.
Sorry. There’s always a schema, and learning to manage it is a _good_ thing. If you’re not ready to manage and migrate, then you’re not in production. You’re in something else.
Re: PlanetScale – Database for Developers
#54Re: PlanetScale – Database for Developers
#55Earlier quoted context omitted.
Sounds great! One question about pricing -- I can't tell if the "free" tier costs are for one month, or ongoing. That is, do you get the free tier amounts for one month and then pay from then on, or is that level of service free from then on?
The free tier is free forever.
Re: PlanetScale – Database for Developers
#56Where are you hosted? What latency should we expect from AWS, GCP, DigitalOcean and fly.io?
And also what degree of compatibility should we expect with MySQL? The doc is quite sparse on this.
Re: PlanetScale – Database for Developers
#57Sounds interesting but there is not enough information for me to get a picture of what this actually means. Thought I was gonna be clever and install it, run it and see what it is all about but I can't figure out how to get it. One link is "sign up" and the other is "contact sales" but I'm not interested in either, I'm interested in "Download" but I cannot find it anywhere. Am I stupid or misunderstanding something f…
It's a hosted DB, and as far as I can tell the Killer Feature is that it makes schema updates less painful. How it does that without significant performance trade-offs or caps is unclear to me. [EDIT] on reading further in their docs, my suspicion is that their "branching" concept is a hell of a lot more limited than I believed at first. I initially took it to mean you could have multiple active schemas working on yo…
Re: PlanetScale – Database for Developers
#58Earlier quoted context omitted.
Does it mean you can write 10 million rows every month for free or does it mean you can write ten million rows, however many months that may take, and then pay for all use after that. The first one is how pricing generally works, but the page could be read as the second.
This is monthly. :)
Re: PlanetScale – Database for Developers
#59Can I install this locally? Will it work without an internet connection? Is it fully open source? From what I can tell, the answer to all three questions is no. Is it yet another example of vendor lock-in? Yes.
Re: PlanetScale – Database for Developers
#60Wondering will we see something like this for Postgres? I like the cool things but I can’t migrate to MySQL just because of this.