Live data from Hacker News

MacFlim: Full-motion video on B&W Macs

macflim.com

51–60 of 64 posts

Re: MacFlim: Full-motion video on B&W Macs

#51
post #45
post #43

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Knowing people appreciate that made the oh-so-many hours worth it. Thx!

It's actually really fun to see it play so well, and then think back to those times, wonder what would have been possible, what people might say

The catch being the storage solutions employed here would have been impossible to imagine back then. But, perhaps just a 3-5 second video (like some of the gifs on the site) could have made the rounds. Even then they probably wouldn't have fit on a disk! Storage was so tough back then.

Re: MacFlim: Full-motion video on B&W Macs

#52
post #45

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It's actually really fun to see it play so well, and then think back to those times, wonder what would have been possible, what people might say

The catch being the storage solutions employed here would have been impossible to imagine back then. But, perhaps just a 3-5 second video (like some of the gifs on the site) could have made the rounds. Even then they probably wouldn't have fit on a disk! Storage was so tough back then.

Yeah, totally. It was. I myself remember my first 10 megabyte hard card. I had stuffed it into some 8086 PC to run a CAD program. Prior to that, anything over a floppy seemed huge!

Funny, I had a flash back to a high school chat. Friend had picked up on digital music. Sampling was a thing we all heard about and the chat was no noise, perfect music one can carry around on chips...

Seemed like sci-fi. We were using Apple 2 computers, some with a half megabyte of RAM. A CD held so much information!

It all just happened. Fairly quick too.

Re: MacFlim: Full-motion video on B&W Macs

#53
post #7

Hi. I am the author of macflim. This is the old video, I am finishing the techdemo that have sound, there is a video on youtube ( https://youtu.be/YRe6I5AICJ0 ). I'll update the macflim.com website later today. And yes, diskspace is one of the reason why it is impractical, but with a SCSI2SD, one can get 4 2Gb partitions on you mac for around $100. And yes, it is bizarre and useles, hence absolutely necessary. If you…

Wow! The clip on the Mac 128K is kind of rough, but the one on the Mac SE is totally watchable! I could easily see myself watching an entire movie that way, if I didn't have access to any other screen for some bizarro reason.

Re: MacFlim: Full-motion video on B&W Macs

#54
post #29

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Super cool! How are you handling the dithering? The website examples look a bit 'swimmy,' with dots wandering around a lot, but looks a bit better in the bit of the tech talk I looked at. Did you find a nice improvement to the dithering technique? In both cases, there's lines of dots in wide dark spaces, as one would expect from an error-diffusion dither. Did you look into other approaches?

I looked at several approaches, but I absolutely wanted to do floyd-steinberg, as this is what were, for me, "realistic" images on my Mac back in the 80s. The example on the website are identical to the ones in the first video, as the simple looping gif is a by-product of the encoding. On the second video (the one with sound), you cannot compare, as the video is compressed and not all the parts of the image are updat…

Another period-accurate approach would be Atkinson dithering, which is similar to Floyd-Steinberg but slightly simpler in implementation. I did a writeup about this technique a while back:

https://beyondloom.com/blog/dither.html

Re: MacFlim: Full-motion video on B&W Macs

#55
post #7

Hi. I am the author of macflim. This is the old video, I am finishing the techdemo that have sound, there is a video on youtube ( https://youtu.be/YRe6I5AICJ0 ). I'll update the macflim.com website later today. And yes, diskspace is one of the reason why it is impractical, but with a SCSI2SD, one can get 4 2Gb partitions on you mac for around $100. And yes, it is bizarre and useles, hence absolutely necessary. If you…

Do you have patreon or something? This is a project I can wholeheartedly support with my hard earned money.

Re: MacFlim: Full-motion video on B&W Macs

#56
It's interesting to see old hardware being used for video that was never thought capable.

A few weeks ago I saw that there is a guy making carts that play 80's movies on Atari 2600's.

(The quality of the movies is terrible, but it's a fascinating project. And the carts and boxes look real.)

Re: MacFlim: Full-motion video on B&W Macs

#57
post #22

Ah, full justification for me to now upgrade my Mac Plus with an accelerator board: https://www.micromac.com/products/multispeed.html Surprised these are still ~$100-200 ... that's a bargain.

i'm skeptical this link actually works... googling around, it looks like no one might be watching this site: https://www.reddit.com/r/VintageApple/comments/6svp32/any_ac...

I've been looking for an accelerator board for my mac SE, but can't find anything reasonably priced anywhere...

Re: MacFlim: Full-motion video on B&W Macs

#58
post #7

Hi. I am the author of macflim. This is the old video, I am finishing the techdemo that have sound, there is a video on youtube ( https://youtu.be/YRe6I5AICJ0 ). I'll update the macflim.com website later today. And yes, diskspace is one of the reason why it is impractical, but with a SCSI2SD, one can get 4 2Gb partitions on you mac for around $100. And yes, it is bizarre and useles, hence absolutely necessary. If you…

This is simply wonderful!

Full color next? https://www.anfractuosity.com/projects/rainbow/

Re: MacFlim: Full-motion video on B&W Macs

#59

Old Apple II’s and Macs will never truly die, they’re just too much fun. Emulation and FPGA solutions exist and once gone over, the hardware is very robust. Replace the old caps with tantalum, align the screen, and you’re set.

There's something special about that stark 1-bit B/W display and the necessary dithering to produce shades of grey. There are patterns to it and a very particular aesthetic.

Early 16- and 256-color systems are great too, but pure B/W has that certain look to it.

Re: MacFlim: Full-motion video on B&W Macs

#60
post #33

I first read “B&W Macs” as meaning “Blue & White Power Mac G3s” and couldn’t figure out why full-motion video would be impressive. Anyway, this is awesome!

Because full motion video can be impressive on a Power Mac G3. I recall downloading a video from Apple's website soon after the introduction of the G4. Of course I still had a G3. The G3 struggled to play the video at a couple of frames per second. (In retrospect, the video was intended as a technology demonstration of codec quality and performance on the G4.)

Eh, if the G3 has altivec suport it could play XVid videos perfectly.

If you got a MOV file with a MP4 video, OFC a G3 would struggle, but mplayer/mpv may be able to play it fastly if the resolution is under 720p if you skip the loop filter.

EDIT: Ok, just for G4 and up. Understandable.

Also, is NOT that impressive. You could watch XVid illegal rips just fine in 2002-2006.

Heck, even a Pentium 2@450 with NetBSD could do that seamlessly.

Post reply on HN