Live data from Hacker News

OpenAstroTracker: 3D printed, open source star tracker

openastrotech.com

51–52 of 52 posts

Re: OpenAstroTracker: 3D printed, open source star tracker

#51
post #10

The kit costs over 200 bucks. I've been very causally considering whether to get into astrophotography, so don't yet know anything about it but I'm curious: what makes this so expensive? A printed frame is cheap, and the other major component is a way for it to automatically move. Are the motors the expensive part then, because they have to be so precise?

For reference, there are 2.5 types of star trackers (called mounts):

- Equatorial: follows star in one direction. Works best on lower stars since the move E-to-W mostly. Cheapest models start at $200 USD (MSM)

- Altazimuth (azimuth+altitude): follows the star in two directions. Can be used for stars higher in the sky. Models start at $400+

- Computer guided and GOTO: Use a secondary telescope to lock onto stars and counter small integration errors. GOTO means you can type a star by name into a computer and the mount will move to its location in the sky (based on a database of where the star is at that moment). These start at $1000+ and can easily be a lot more.

These systems are so expensive because they need to swing a typically very heavy telescope with a lot of precision. My mount (on the smaller end) is rated for 11lbs. Being off by 1 arcsecond (1/3600 degrees) at the distance of Alpha Centauri is an error of 200,000,000 km.

If this tracker can provide all these features + precision at $200, that’s a steal.

Re: OpenAstroTracker: 3D printed, open source star tracker

#52
post #42

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Great, Apple's new M1 based systems now exist on the market. Go make one for me for less than what Apple sells theirs. Should be easy according you since someone else is already doing it. R&D is everything in making of something. Just because someone else made it doesn't mean you get to start exactly where they left off (except in cases of open source where you get their literal plans). Even in wood working or any sh…

I'll add one more thing to my sibling comment. This person is clearly unaware of whether there is ongoing R&D in the realm of hobby astrophotography mounts. They mentioned they're just considering getting into it. They're talking about mass manufactured goods. They were not aware that this is a field of active innovation. We could have given someone a warm welcome to the hobby by clarifying that politely. I know when…

Thank you the comments you wrote. There's no contact info in your profile so without going too off topic, I appreciate this really a lot.
Post reply on HN