Live data from Hacker News

OBS Studio Now Ready with Wayland Capture Support

phoronix.com

51–60 of 69 posts

Re: OBS Studio Now Ready with Wayland Capture Support

#51
post #7

I think the original blog post from the developer is a better link: https://feaneron.com/2021/03/30/obs-studio-on-wayland/ Michael added zero extra information on top of that.

I appreciate the summary. Also there's a clear link in the summary to the developer's much longer post.

There's also countless links to ads. I feel like a three paragraph summary that offers you no real information over the title, does not warrant the visit to Phoronix.

Re: OBS Studio Now Ready with Wayland Capture Support

#52
post #44

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Taking screenshots/streaming is not a hard problem. However Wayland artificially turns something as simple as taking a screenshot into a hard problem what was before a simple function call to XGetImage(). As exercise I recommend to implement a native screenshot application in both X11 and Wayland.

I think you're completely ignoring the security implications of "a simple function call to XGetImage()".

What are the security implications? Programs that call XGetImage() when sandboxed in a Xpra/Xephyr session will get back nothing.

Re: OBS Studio Now Ready with Wayland Capture Support

#54
post #52

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I think you're completely ignoring the security implications of "a simple function call to XGetImage()".

What are the security implications? Programs that call XGetImage() when sandboxed in a Xpra/Xephyr session will get back nothing.

Will get nothing... that means the screenshot won't be taken.

Re: OBS Studio Now Ready with Wayland Capture Support

#55

Are there people on here who regularly scrape HN posts for data? Because I'd love a list of user handles of people who-- before this day-- have written variations of, "Wayland-based systems have been totally ready for use for years now." And maybe a browser extension that greys out comments from those handles.

Or the ‘Just rewrite it in Rust!’ clan

Re: OBS Studio Now Ready with Wayland Capture Support

#56

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I appreciate the summary. Also there's a clear link in the summary to the developer's much longer post.

There's also countless links to ads. I feel like a three paragraph summary that offers you no real information over the title, does not warrant the visit to Phoronix.

It's not so bad. It takes less than 30% of the screen. Running a site like Phoronix takes time and the author deserves compensation for it.

Re: OBS Studio Now Ready with Wayland Capture Support

#57
post #31
post #18

When I made the jul over to full time Linux last February,this is something iran into and was confused about. Wayland was the default on Ubuntu, and it worked great! Except for a lot of applications that just wouldn't load... After some reading, I moved to X, but I can't wait for the day Wayland is ready to go. Will there ever be a good way to run things like dmenu on Wayland? I'm still a novice, but will all X progr…

> I'm still a novice, but will all X programs need to be converted? No. Because Wayland is fundamentally different from X the following won't ever work: * Window managers * Programs that need to know their absolute window coordinates * Windows that want to draw to the root window * Programs that want to capture the screen via XGetImage()

> * Programs that need to know their absolute window coordinates

> * Windows that want to draw to the root window

Gnome certainly won't support it, but in principle a compositor could expose that functionality.

> * Programs that want to capture the screen via XGetImage()

Yeah, doing anything via XAnything() only works on X. So you replace XAnything() by somethingElse().

Re: OBS Studio Now Ready with Wayland Capture Support

#58
post #18

When I made the jul over to full time Linux last February,this is something iran into and was confused about. Wayland was the default on Ubuntu, and it worked great! Except for a lot of applications that just wouldn't load... After some reading, I moved to X, but I can't wait for the day Wayland is ready to go. Will there ever be a good way to run things like dmenu on Wayland? I'm still a novice, but will all X progr…

With XWayland there is no urgent need for conversion. And "a lot of applications that just wouldn't load" sounds pretty fishy to begin with.

Old drivers have issues with XWayland. There's nothing fishy about that statement whatsoever. Hell, NVidia only JUST got XWayland working, though that's probably more an issue of corporate stubbornness.

Re: OBS Studio Now Ready with Wayland Capture Support

#59

What's up with the recent Flatpack/Snap fetish? Doesn't anybody just get their software into a distro anymore? Edit: EFF's recommendation for certbot, their ACME/LetsEncrypt client, is to use snap on a freaking server. Why?

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5PmHRSeA2c8&t=3414s

Re: OBS Studio Now Ready with Wayland Capture Support

#60

Totally unrelated but: The day I can wireless screencast my Linux Laptop to my home television I will lite a candle.

If your home television supports Miracast, you can do it today: https://flathub.org/apps/details/org.gnome.NetworkDisplays

Wow, that's pretty crazy. I didn't know Wi-Fi Direct was already supported on (non-Android) Linux.

It doesn't seem to establish a connection properly with my Intel 8265 card out of the box though. I'll have to play around with it a bit more.

Post reply on HN